The Byrds produced their fourth straight excellent album in a row despite changing their musical direction for a third time. Mr. Tambourine Man and Turn! Turn! Turn! were early excursions into folk-rock while Fifth Dimension would find the group turning toward a psychedelic sound. Younger Than Yesterday would be more diverse than their first three releases as it would feature a number of country related tracks.
The group would write or co-write ten of the eleven tracks and, except for a song or two, they would feature tight structures plus mature and thoughtful lyrics. The best harmonies this side of The Beach Boys were in place and Roger McGuinn’s signature 12 string guitar would continue to provide the foundation for their sound. The big change would be the emergence of Chris Hillman as a major contributor through his creative bass playing and songwriting abilities.
“So You Want To Be A Rock ‘n’ Roll Star,” written by Hillman and McGuinn, may have been a tongue in cheek song about The Monkees but the melody and the harmonies were just about perfect. Hugh Masekela provides some stellar trumpet playing which drives the track along.
Two of Chris Hillman’s contributions were early examples of the fusion between a country and rock sound. “Have You Seen Her Face” and “Thoughts and Words” sounded like The Beatles gone country as the harmonies and guitars provided a counterpoint to the lyrics and basic song structures. At the time very few artists had explored this musical territory and few since have explored it so well. “Time Between” and “The Girl With No Name” both have a country bluegrass feel and looked ahead to his work with The Desert Rose Band.
Tensions had begun to mount in the group, which would hasten David Crosby’s departure. The problems would reach a head when Crosby insisted that several of his songs be included on the album’s final release over the objections of the other group members. “Mind Gardens,” which is just a mess, and the older song “Why” were inferior to the rest of the tracks in terms of both lyrics and melody. “Everybody’s Been Burned” is much better and remains a reminder that he could produce quality music.
Article comments
1 - JC Mosquito
The best Byrds album taken as whole album, or even as a collection of songs - the Byrds' equivalent of the Beatles' Revolver, as it were. The Notorious Byrds Brothers follow closely on its heels as the Sgt. Pepper equivalent.
2 - Paul
Fine album and fine review. "Mind Gardens" is dreadful musically and lyrically, and "CTA 102" is annoying. "Why" is a great song, but the single version, released a full year earlier, is much, much better. The rest of the album is amazingly awesome.
3 - JC Mosquito
Thre remix of Why on the Box Set is the bestest version, if you can afford the box.