Music Review: Girl in a Coma - Trio B.C.

In an era where the old business model for marketing and distribution of music is quickly becoming a thing of the past, Girl in a Coma appears to be in good hands with Joan Jett’s small independent record label, Blackheart Records. On Trio B.C., the San Antonio alternative pop/punk band’s second album for Blackheart, you get the feeling that Ms. Jett is aware that the band has a lot of untapped potential. You also get the impression that she’s just the right mentor for the group and can bring out the best in them.

There’s no evidence of a “sophomore slump” or any “jump the shark” moments on Trio B.C. Principal songwriter, guitarist, and lead vocalist, Nina Diaz, 21, Nina’s sister and drummer Phanie Diaz, 27, and the group’s bassist/vocalist, Jen Alva, 28, set the bar high and cleared it. While the songs on the new album preserve the signature sound of the group’s 2007 first full length disc, Both Before I’m Gone, the overall sound is more polished this time around. That’s not entirely unexpected; in fact, you expect to hear that more and more as a young band gains more experience in the studio. Jett, one of four producers credited on the new album, is obviously “pushing all the right buttons” with Girl in a Coma.

The diversity of the material presented on Trio B.C. encompasses elements of alternative rock, 90s grunge, punk, country, 50s rockabilly, and Mexican music. This is a band that can play a number of different styles. With that kind of variety in song structure and performance, the listening experience is rewarding. As each song came to its conclusion, I was anxious to hear the next one. Perhaps more importantly, these new songs reflect the growth and maturation of Nina Diaz as a songwriter. As a singer, Diaz’s tone compares favorably with that of Shirley Manson, the lead vocalist of Garbage.

Both Before I’m Gone was an excellent debut record. It was filled with mostly raw, powerful, punk/pop/rock numbers that hinted at the heavy influence of Morrissey and The Smith’s on the group’s sound. The album hit No. 23 on Billboard’s Heatseekers Chart, and the song, “Clumsy Sky”, earned accolades as the winner of an Independent Music Award for best punk song.

Trio B.C.
builds upon the sound of the first record, but it also takes something from the best work of Blondie (“Static Mind”), The Pretenders (“Pink Lemonade”) and Letters to Cleo (“Pleasure and Pain”). In terms of style, it has something for everyone. There are memorable heartbreaking ballads (“Vino”), rebellious punk rock anthems (“Baby Boy” and “Empty Promise”), and even a few playful songs that have a real pop sensibility (“In the Day”) and (“Joanie in the City”). “Joanie” features Joan Jett on vocals and guitar. It’s a fast paced song, with plenty of flourishes of chunky rhythm guitar. When Nina sings the line, “She’s running away to the city”, I can’t help but wonder if the tune is actually about Jett, a former member of the teen girl band, The Runaways. “Slaughter Lane” is an enticing sample of alternative-country that includes some Telecaster guitar twang.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2
Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for carl-j-mancuso

Article Author: Carl J. Mancuso

Carl J. Mancuso is a graduate of Louisiana State University. He earned a B.A. in Journalism in 1983, and has spent the last 19 years as a paralegal. He likes to play guitar, sing, and record music in his home based studio. …

Visit Carl J. Mancuso's author page

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Trio B.C. Trio B.C.

    2009 sophomore album from the Texas trio. Girl in a Coma, hailing from the Lone Star State, formed when best friends Jenn Alva and Phanie Diaz met in Jr. High School art class over a mutual love of The ...

Article comments

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Feb 09, 2010

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for January

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs

Upcoming Stories from Blogcritics
  •