Hardcore and its relations have slowly been winning me over in the past year. I finally gave Hatebreed a good listen to, and that did a lot to clinch the deal, plus albums from Bury Your Dead, Bludgeon, and Mower have all added to a growing appreciation for the hardcore genre and its surrounding blends.
However, it is albums such as this that remind me why I was never big into the hardcore scene. To be fair, Gat Rot is not a pure hardcore act, though there are elements of metal mixed in, edging them towards the metalcore genre — but it still fits.
Us Versus Them is just a dull album. There is nothing that challenges me, nothing that grabs me by the throat and forces me to listen. There is no reason to get excited. This is an album that when you turn it on for the first time, you almost have to force yourself to go all the way to the end.
Gat Rot features two vocalists whose voices, at least to my ear, are very similar. I usually think the idea of having two singers is for two different sounds to blend, but that isn't the case here. Occasionally they seem to get into screaming wars to see who can outdo the other, only to end in a stalemate each time. Everything else is just so terribly bland -- straight-up crunchy guitars, with the bass line doubling it and making it a little bit thicker, backed by generic drumming.
I don't demand a lot from my music, and maybe I am being unnecessarily mean, but I got nothing from this release. Some of the songs' paces slow to a crawl that would put an insomniac to sleep. While I don't have high demands, I do have some expectations of original sound, some idea of a thought process behind what I am hearing. Again, this falls way short.
Article comments
1 - Autumn Parry
You Guys Rock so bad and for all you Haters kiss my ass. GAT-ROT is Awesome!!!!!!