Music Review: Brian Wilson - That Lucky Old Sun

"At 25, I turned out the light, cause' I couldn't handle the glare in my eyes," Brian Wilson sings on "Going Home," one of the key tracks on his brilliant new album That Lucky Old Sun, "But now I'm back."

I honestly wasn't sure Brian Wilson still had it in him.

But at 66 years old, coming off of the 2004 creative victory of finally realizing his decades-in-the-making masterpiece SMiLE, it's now clear that triumph was no mere fluke. Like the song says, he really is back.

As brilliant as SMiLE was, and as much as you have to give the often-fragile mind of Brian Wilson credit for storing that music in his head for decades, the fact still remained that it consisted of music conceived some forty years ago.

Not so on That Lucky Old Sun. This is an entirely new cycle of songs that when pieced together as a whole, form a fully realized work that is as sonically dense and layered as SMiLE, while containing Wilson's most deeply personal lyrics — often painfully so — since he sang about the lonely sort of solitude he found "In My Room" back in the sixties with the Beach Boys.

This is a just a gorgeous record. But it's not just the beautiful multi-layered choral harmonies and orchestral arrangements that make it so. It's also the way Wilson — for the first time really — peels away the mystery of his so-called "lost years" with lyrics that are as often honest, as they are bittersweet.

It's often been said that Wilson's genius lies in the childlike way he just hears the songs in his head, capturing both their simple, stripped down emotional essence, while imagining the sort of complex sounds that require nothing less than a symphonic scope. In that sense, as he so aptly demonstrates on this album, Wilson's songs at their best really yearn back to a much more innocent time and place.

Did I mention that I absolutely love this record yet?

On its surface, That Lucky Old Sun is Brian Wilson's personal love letter to his beloved Southern California. In the spoken word narratives that connect this album, Wilson details the "Heartbeat of L.A.," accurately capturing a world where actors wait tables in between pictures, and where "the homeless, the hopeless, and the deranged" populate "Venice Beach," a place where "nothing seems out of place or strange."

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for glen-boyd

Article Author: Glen Boyd

You'll find Blogcritics assistant music editor Glen Boyd sharing his Thoughtmares on his personal blogs The World Wide Glen, and The Rockologist. In a previous life, Glen was a music professional and journalist whose work has appeared in The Rocket, SPIN, Pulse!, and The Source. …

Visit Glen Boyd's author pageGlen Boyd's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • That Lucky Old Sun That Lucky Old Sun

    Brand new album from legendary writer, producer, arranger and performer Brian Wilson, produced by Brian and created in the Capitol Records Studios where he first recorded in 1962.

  • SMiLE SMiLE

    Smile is inarguably the most long-awaited album in modern pop history. It's been more than 37 years since the title first appeared on a label release schedule, intended as the January 1967 follow-up to ...

Article comments

  • 1 - El Bicho

    Sep 14, 2008 at 3:31 pm

    Sold. I will have to give it a listen.

  • 2 - Glen Boyd

    Sep 14, 2008 at 6:26 pm

    Thanx Bicho. I guarantee you won't be disappointed.

    -Glen

  • 3 - Bill Sherman

    Sep 14, 2008 at 6:37 pm

    Considering the hit-and-miss nature of Gettin' In Over My Head, the album that preceded the SMiLE reconstruction, I'm really glad to see that Brian's got his muse back . . .

  • 4 - Glen Boyd

    Sep 14, 2008 at 6:41 pm

    I was afraid of that going in to this one too Bill. But I'm happy to report that SMiLE was no fluke (depite the age of the songs involved). Brian seems to have really regained that muse here.

    -Glen

  • 5 - bliffle

    Sep 14, 2008 at 7:32 pm

    I'm not going to listen to this album since I concluded long ago the the Beach Boys are terminally bland white bread derivative musicians.

    They don't deserve all the hoopla that they get.

  • 6 - Glen Boyd

    Sep 14, 2008 at 7:35 pm

    Your loss, or should i say your bliff?

    -Glen

  • 7 - Joel Patterson

    Sep 15, 2008 at 10:19 am

    Hmmmm... does the album include a cover of the wondrously entrancing 30's song, "That Lucky Old Sun," which's got nothing else to do but roll around Heaven all day?

    Or is it just used as a title to evoke the heydey of Southern California?

  • 8 - bliffle

    Sep 15, 2008 at 11:27 am

    Very little that the BB sang was original. Even the picture at the top of this article is derivative: Al Jardine admits that they started wearing the striped shirts in imitation of the Kingston Trio. Jardines words were something like: "the striped shirts were new and made the Knston Trio unique, so we said 'we need something unique, too, so lets wear striped shirts!'".

    Ten years after Kingston Trio had a hit with "Sloop John B" the BB recorded their drippy version which sounded like they were all passing out in an opium den. They even omitted the charming reggae beat! I suppose that they were incapable of performing it!

  • 9 - Christopher Rose

    Sep 15, 2008 at 11:37 am

    I can take or leave the Beach Boys depending on what part of their very patchy work I'm hearing. I wasn't aware of the earlier version(s) of "Sloop John B" but I'm surprised to read that the Kingston Trio, a folk group, had a version with a Reggae beat as I'm pretty sure Reggae didn't exist in 1956...

  • 10 - DUDE

    Sep 15, 2008 at 12:40 pm

    If you don't like the Beach Boys, why waste part of your life commenting on them? Makes less sense than Brian did when he was whacked out of his gourd!!!!

  • 11 - Lee Richards

    Sep 15, 2008 at 1:01 pm

    On a live recorded version of "Sloop" Dennis Wilson plays some great rock drums. Carl had a beautifully clear, moving voice on ballads, and how anyone can say Brian's compositions and arrangements were derivative is beyond me.

    Many great musicians found him, and the Beach Boys, an inspiration and stimulus to their own talent--the Beatles included(another bland, white bread group?)

    To compare Brian and the BB--a group who were amazingly creative and highly influential in world pop music--to the Kingston Trio, a fun novelty act, is a shallow criticism that completely misses their musicality and originality.

    The Beach Boys were a bridge from the '50s to the '60s; it wasn't their intent to have a heavier or metal sound. Like all the great ones, Brian wrote and played what he felt inside and what touched him. He connected with a couple of generations, at least, and his artistic longevity in a fickle business is strong evidence he and the band accomplished something unique and enduring.

    "Lucky Old Sun" has his trademark sound and style. For fans, it's enjoyable and nostalgic, with plenty of Wilson melody and harmonies, and words that share equally with the music in conveying the personal meaning and emotion of the songs.

    It's not a masterpiece, but it's a fun listen worth many repeats when you want to think about your own salad days, or just feel like humming along to a new Brian Wilson tune.

    If they could all be together once again, they would sound a lot like this.

  • 12 - bliffle

    Sep 15, 2008 at 6:45 pm

    Well, DUDE, I do it to warn young impressionable music listeners from being seduced by Old Music Criminals, like BB.

    It's just one of the many Public Services that I perform.

    DUDE asked:
    "If you don't like the Beach Boys, why waste part of your life commenting on them?"

  • 13 - DUDE

    Sep 16, 2008 at 8:20 am

    Warning?!?! Seems like a lame excuse for wasting your time. Did you ever think that your taste in music isn't for everyone, and that some "young impressionable music listeners" might not share your point of vew, and that in fact you are robbing them of an oportunity that they may cherish for a lifetime, such as Brian Wilson has done for me and countless milllions of others. Voicing a narrow opinion on some you consider "impressionable" is really a dis-service. Not to mention you are never going to get this time back that you fritter away whining about the Beach Boys.

    BTW - That Lucky Old Sun is a great improvement over the previous, and actually has a couple of his best solo songs period!!

  • 14 - Dude

    Oct 01, 2008 at 10:57 am

    Anyone buying into the "various packaging" game? If you purchase it at certain stores you get a free 45 single pressed on clear orange vinyl, then there's the Limited Edition 2-disc version with an extra DVD with a "Making Of" documentary and 2 live in-studio performances.
    "Live Let Live" and "Midnight's Another Day" I think rank with his best stuff!!

  • 15 - Tomato Pie

    Dec 13, 2008 at 4:15 pm

    I like the early BB stuff, but I'm not a fanatic -- I was not moved to tears when Pet Sounds made it to CD. But this new work is magnificent, I play it 5 times a day. The band is brilliant, and Brian has conjured up a perfect blend of looking back and looking ahead.

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 29, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs