The original songs fare a little better than the covers.
“It’s O.K.” is the best of the Brian Wilson songs. It may not be extraordinary but does contain some of the clearest harmonies that the Beach Boys created during their last several studio albums. The simple lyrics and infectious melody hark back to a simpler and better time for the Beach Boys. “Had To Phone Ya” is just too simple in structure and especially lyrics. “Everyone’s In Love With You” states in the liner notes; Written: Michael Love, Arranged: Michael Love, Lead Vocal: Michael Love. That about says it all and it isn’t good. “That Same Song” has an unfinished feel. Brian’s vocal does not match the instrumental background. “T M Song” is another Beach Boys foray into transcendental meditation appreciation. This song is just plain infuriating which defeats the intent of the song.
The best song on the album, by far, is Al Jadine’s “Susie Cincinnati.” Jardine, who wrote the song and sings lead, created a classic Beach Boys song. The harmonies are excellent and full and the melody carries the vocals along. This song would have fit nicely on any of the Beach Boys excellent early 1970’s albums.
Every time I play 15 Big Ones I expect more even though I know it will not happen. This leaves 15 Big Ones as one of the most disappointing albums of the Beach Boys career.
Article comments
1 - scott
David--
Thanks so much for this series of Beach Boys reviews. Really great stuff.
2 - Curth
Hi David, love the reviews, even though I disagree with a lot of them. I am wondering why you skipped over and did not review the Beach Boys In Concert album , released in the early 70's between Holland and 15 Big Ones and which in my humble opinion is their best live album?
3 - Rick
"The best song on the album, by far, is Al Jadine's "Susie Cincinnati." Jardine, who wrote the song and sings lead, created a classic Beach Boys song. The harmonies are excellent and full and the melody carries the vocals along. This song would have fit nicely on any of the Beach Boys excellent early 1970's albums."
In fact "Susie Cincinnatti" is from late 1969. It first appeared as Single B-Side of "Add Some Music To Your Day" in February 1970.
4 - Rick
"I remember seeing the song list from 15 Big Ones for the first time and thinking that there were too many cover songs and that was probably not a good thing. The fact that the Beach Boys could not fill an album with original material after three years proved that I was correct."
There's a simple reason for this. The original plan in 1976 was releasing an all-oldies album, little later changed to a double vinyl album with one record oldies-only and the other new material-only. Finally the record company changed their mind again and released a mixed bag called "15 Big Ones". Some oldies that didn't made it on the final album but were recorded between January and May 1976 are "He's So Fine", "Secret Love", "Mony Mony", "On Broadway", "Come Go With Me", "Tallahassee Lassie", "Sea Cruise", "Running Bear", "Shake Rattle and Roll", "Michael Row The Boat Ashore", "Let's Dance", "Johnny B. Good" and "Peggy Sue". Some of these songs appeared on later Beach Boys albums and compilations, but most of them are still in the vaults. Also the original version of "Honkin' Down The Highway" was recorded during the "15 Big Ones" sessions, but with Billy Hinsche singing lead and not Al Jardine.