So in case you're curious, yes, I voted. There are over 100 songs listed to choose from. I could only pick five and it was tough. Here was my ballot: 1) Marvin Gaye - "What's Going On"2) Marvin Gaye - "Lets Get It On"3) The Temptations - "My Girl"4) Stevie Wonder - "Superstition"5) Jackson 5 - "I Want You Back."
What's Going On
No Description Available.Genre: Soul/R&BMedia Format: Compact DiskRating: Release Date: 27-FEB-2001
The Ultimate Collection
Songs in the Key of Life
Gold
Article comments
1 - Donald Gibson
You're right, that was hard. Of course, they could've made it a bit easier by getting rid of those DeBarge tracks. It's supposed to be classic Motown. Or at least good music. "Rhythm of the Night" is neither.
Anyway, here's my ballot:
1) Marvin Gaye - "I Heard It Through the Grapevine
2) Stevie Wonder - "My Cherie Amour"
3) The Supremes - "I Hear A Symphony"
4) Four Tops - "Baby, I Need Your Loving"
5) Smokey Robinson & The Miracles: "Tears of a Clown
2 - Donald Gibson
And for the heck of it " I'm a massive fan of Motown " here's my top 5 list of songs that weren't offered as entries on the voting site:
Marvin Gaye - "Can I Get A Witness"
The Temptations - "I Wish It Would Rain"
Martha & The Vandellas - "Nowhere To Run"
Stevie Wonder - "I Don't Know Why"
The Jackson 5 - "Maybe Tomorrow"
3 - Josh Hathaway
Wow... it seems my comment didn't make it through. Let me try again. First, thanks for playing along, Donald. You have some excellent selections yourself. "Grapevine" was my last one to get voted off. Ultimately I decided not to go three deep on Marvin Gaye just because. It was really, really tough limiting myself to just five.
Martha & The Vandellas' "Nowhere To Run" should have been on that list. That's a great one.
4 - Glen Boyd
Sure, I'll play.
"Mercy Mercy Me" Marvin Gaye
"Baby, Baby Don't Cry" Marvin Gaye
"Love Child" Diana Ross/Supremes
"Reach Out (I'll Be There)" Four Tops
"I Was Made To Love Her" Stevie Wonder
Snapshots in time, every one of them.
-Glen
5 - Glen Boyd
Oops, make that Smokey Robinson on "Baby Baby Don't Cry"...
-Glen
6 - zingzing
"my world is empty without you"
"money"
"i want you back"
"let's get it on"
"i'm coming out"
7 - Cindy
Diana Ross & The Supremes - I'm Living In Shame
Marvin Gaye - What's Going On
Edwin Starr - War
Marvin Gaye - Inner City Blues
The Temptations - Masterpiece
The Temptations - Ball of Confusion
8 - Josh Hathaway
50 songs just isn't enough. There are some great choices here.
9 - Josh Hathaway
It feels a little ominous that I wrote about Michael Jackson being famous for being a singer in this article and a mere few hours later he was gone. Life is strange and so is death.
10 - El Bicho
Only 5 Motown songs? Impossible. I am too neurotic to take part because the number of songs left off would eat away at me.
11 - Josh Hathaway
I'm plenty neurotic and I'm not even a devotee. I hated winnowing that list down to five but I really like the songs I chose. Gibson and Boyd had some good calls, too.
12 - Cindy
Five shmive. Just ignore the rules El B! Put as many as you like. I put 6. But that's only because I ran out of time.
13 - Cindy
You neurotic guys need to learn to loosen up and live a little. :-)
14 - El Bicho
Oh, Cindy, you anarchist you. Here's five that weren't mentioned:
"Do You Love Me" - The Contours
"Dancing in the Street" - Martha & The Vandellas
"(I Know) I'm Losing You" - The Temptations
"For Once In My Life" - Stevie Wonder
"My Guy" - Mary Wells
15 - zingzing
it says something that people can name individual favorites, and not a one of them is obscure. not that i'm saying they should be, but just that we can all get every one of these songs in our heads immediately has to mean something. (that being that motown had a shitload of good songs.)
still, i must say i VASTLY prefer stax/atlantic (southern) style soul to motown. too slick. too urban. gimme something dirty from the sticks.
16 - zingzing
oh, and if you haven't already, go check out the eccentric soul series on numero group. each one is from a different city (or a label) and features obscure 60s/70s soul and funk. usually a city (or label) has a particular sound, so it really brings each album together as a whole while highlighting stuff that's been totally lost to the larger public.
17 - El Bicho
Writing uninformed on the matter, it seems like Motown was more in the business of creating pop music by making R&B more palatable for white audiences at the time.
Stax artists appear to have a little more diversity and originality in their sounds, and the audience came to them.
18 - zingzing
there is that, but i think it was also about creating a different sound than the southern soul of the time. something more urban and tight. which is what they did. their early stuff wasn't quite as obviously poppy, but once they learned what was really selling, they went for it. (and made a lot of good music on the way.)