“The Storm” is moody and atmospheric with a lovely, cinematic string arrangement. The wailing harmonica in “The Storm” is even better than the wailing harmonica in “Mucky Fingers.” I love wailing harmonicas.
This is a very close race but I cannot vote against Noel Gallagher twice.
ROUND 5 WINNER: OASIS
Round 6: Oasis’ “The Meaning of Soul” vs Doves’ “Walk in the Fire”
Liam is just as good a musical thief as his big brother. Imagine “Jumpin’ Jack Flash” two minutes shorter and you have “The Meaning of Soul.” This is an odd pairing of songs. “The Meaning of Soul” clocks in at under two minutes while “Walk in the Fire” goes well over five.
You will not understand “The Meaning of Soul” from Liam Gallagher’s lyrics. Some Oasis songs take nine minutes to say nothing (“All Around the World”), so props Liam for at least saying nothing fast. The song bursts with energy and attitude. Attitude goes a long way.
“Walk in the Fire” is Doves at their most earnest. The song is like a sequel to their wonderful “There Goes the Fear” from their wonderful The Last Broadcast. It is big. It is ambitious. It is, well, it is a lot like the kind of song Oasis has done so well over the years.
ROUND 6 WINNER: DOVES
Round 7: Oasis’ “Guess God Thinks I’m Abel” vs Doves’ “One of These Days”
Raise your hand if you understand what Gallagher Jr. is talking about in this song. OK, it is not just me. “Guess God Thinks I’m Abel” is a convoluted song. There have been several attempts by different critics to solve the riddle and I am not going down with them. Musically there is a Middle Eastern vibe in the verses giving it a Rubber Soul-era sound. It is undeniably catchy even if you cannot tell what kind of relationship Liam is trying to describe.
“One of These Days” is not the most distinguished moment on Some Cities. It is a good song and it has grown on me. An intro of swir
Article comments
1 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo
fantastic, DJ! really enjoyed this right here. i must confess, however, i ain't ever given much time to The Doves. what i did hear didn't do much for me, but who knows? maybe one day...
2 - DJRadiohead
Thanks, Duke. Glad you dug this. I was hoping my little labour of love would not go uncommented!
I have only gotten into Doves in the last couple years. They never really have dented the US much- and it is a shame. I really dig them a lot.
I heartily suggest re-investigating 'The Last Broadcast' if you ever get a chance and inclination. It is easily one of my favourite albums ever.