How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb - Page 2

This isn't to say that Bomb is a rehash of old material and old ideas. Indeed, classic U2 moments occur all over the 50 minutes of music, but there are new experiments as well. I mentioned earlier that the album is guitar-heavy. In addition to their usual, poignant riffs or driving chords, Bomb makes copious use of acoustic guitar in the hands of The Edge. Whereas Bono has traditionally used an acoustic in a rhythm guitar sense, The Edge now showcases his talent sans effect pedals or driving gain. Electric piano is also used effectively at times, but without falling into a 'The Sweetest Thing' dependancy.

The album does have its weak points, however. 'A Man And A Woman' is this album's 'Honey', and 'All Because Of You' sounds unfinished and immature coming from a group with the talent and history of U2. These low spots are easily overlooked in the big picture, as the mastery and beauty of tracks like 'Miracle Drug' with Bono's soaring vocals, 'City Of Blinding Lights' with The Edge's exquisite guitar work, and 'Original Of The Species' with its superb blending of Pop-style synthesizer and the new U2 'Walk On' matured anthem sound, easily overshadow most flaws.

Bomb is not U2's best album, but it does well to re-capture the power of the group's 1980s work and put it in the perspective of their most recent record. It's very solid effort that should have good staying power. I know I'll have it on repeat on my iPod, that's for sure.

I can't wait to see them play these songs live.

Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb

    The album that carries U2 into its 25th year--and likely the mixed blessings of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame--is one of its most frank and focused since the days of October and War. ...

Article comments

  • 1 - news

    Nov 12, 2004 at 11:44 pm

    This album's pretty sweet. U2 still has some creativity left in them.

  • 2 - gavin

    Nov 14, 2004 at 11:55 pm

    These songs are going to be absolutely incredible live -- especially "Love and Peace or Else".

  • 3 - Lono

    Nov 15, 2004 at 3:10 am

    ok, everyone in the world apparently has heard this album but me... and it is killing me. Where can I find downloads. I went through Kazaa lite (my normal channel) but everything I found were spoofs.

  • 4 - joel

    Nov 15, 2004 at 12:57 pm

    I guess I'm in the minority cause I was very disappointed with the album. Bono's lyrics have always been an important part of U2's appeal and I think, to be honest, he's the weak link on this album. The lyrics are non-poetic and cliche and his melodies are tired and sometimes recycled (a couple of understated melody lines are even borrowed.)

    The free flowing and climatic structure of songs that have been their trademark over the years is non-existent. The U2 tradmark elements that are on the album sound forced.

    There are 3 tracks that I think are good, one of which is the single Vertigo, and about 2 of others that are decent. The rest of the album should have never made the cut. I know that I'm being harsh but this is U2 and the expectations are always high.

  • 5 - musiclover

    Nov 15, 2004 at 1:27 pm

    I was confused and almost unimpressed the first time I heard it. Then, the second time it got better...after a week, I can say this is one of the most amazing albumns I have ever heard. Each song is truly incredible. You have to hear it to believe.

  • 6 - m moonan

    Nov 22, 2004 at 6:52 pm

    Like all U2 albums,...the more I listen the more I like. That is still the case here.While I agree with the previous opinionon @ a few questionable lines from Bono , I feel overall he has captured one of their more philosophical and pensive albums to date. I am biased, but no group in history has made an album this strong 25 yrs into existance. I am rarely dissapointed by a new u2 album, (except POP), and this one is no exception.

  • 7 - carl

    Nov 23, 2004 at 9:00 am

    When U2 came up with Actung all those years ago, they were taking a chance. They strayed from their familiar sound to come up with something strong, rhythmic and inventive. They continued in this inventive manner until Pop, (which I thought was overlooked in may areas), after which it appears they got scared of public opinion. Hence ATYCLB. Safe. Nice, but safe. What can I say? My childhood idols are getting old and precautious. This new album has some spinetingling moments (they are still U2) however, for the most part they seem to have forgotten to get to the core of their music. Stripped back is not always a good thing. And Bono, wheres the sarcastic witty one-liners? And why have they been replaced with middle of the road cliches? Maybe I'm being too harsh and expecting too much, but it seems to me that U2 have got lazy. And my heart is broken.

  • 8 - Matt

    Nov 23, 2004 at 6:24 pm

    I just picked up U2s new album and I must say I am very pleased. Is this their best album...no but nothing short of great. U2 continues to stay fresh with there music and not depend on past achievements that made them popular. "Vertigo" is an awesome tune but I think the best song on the album is "City of Blinding Lights"- cant wait to hear that live. Not to mention "Miracle Drug" "Sometimes you cant make it on your own" "Yahweh" and "One step closer" are all winners.
    After all these years U2 reminds me a lot of Led Zeppelin because they continue to move forward with there music and not backwards. They are always changing and they can play various styles and still be on top of the world. -Another victory for U2... my hats off to Bono and the Boys!

  • 9 - bla

    Nov 25, 2004 at 9:38 am

    well, 1. achtung, 2. joshua....3-5. how to dismantle, together with the unforgettable fire and all that you can't live without. that's how i felt when i heard it and heard it and heard it this past few days. i never really loved boy, war and october...too angry for my ideas of U2

  • 10 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo

    Nov 25, 2004 at 1:03 pm

    i was pretty unimpressed with Verigo, but after hearing the stunning Yahweh on the radio, i figure im gonna give this a listen.

  • 11 - dutchie

    Nov 27, 2004 at 10:47 pm

    i don't think that this album is the finest one ever to be released by u2, but i think it's a good effort. "city of blinding lights" was my first favorite. this album reminds me a lot of the last one, but i miss the days of the joshua tree & even achtung baby. i love david

  • 12 - fze

    Nov 29, 2004 at 10:27 pm

    i love this band....and then i listened to their new album and especially the third song ie 'sometimes you cant make it on your own....'

    and then i realized WHY i love this band so much.

    an amazing album. money well spent. totally.

  • 13 - mop

    Nov 30, 2004 at 8:24 pm

    Wat an album 9 out of 10 Love and Peace or Else unbelivable. The best album in the last 15 years.

  • 14 - Chris M

    Dec 07, 2004 at 9:29 pm

    Another super U2 CD. Absolutely love 'Crumbs from your Table'- and all the other songs. If one criticism, I think it is just a touch 'preachy'. I understand they are very spiritual and Bono was going through a tough time, but I just prefer a little less of the 'bibleisms'. Still love it to death.

  • 15 - Maxbrad

    Mar 02, 2005 at 3:01 pm

    if you download something called winmx you can have any song or fiml in the world even if its not out in the cinema in the uk yet!!!!!

  • 16 - divya

    Mar 21, 2005 at 9:34 am

    I completely agree with JOel.
    one has tremendous expectations from a band like u2. they've been demi-gods for me for years, but of late i can see their clay feet ever so much! i mean after gems like joshua tree and achtung baby, they came out with ATYCLB which kind of showed forth a different sound, slightly pop based rather than rock (and that too only in some places),but nevertheless, is still one of my treasured albums. But vertigo takes the cake for completely losing their sound, their originality and uniqueness, the sheer poetry of the lyrics. whereas their earlier albums would send me into rapturous ecstasy, this one refuses to move a single cell of emotion in me, except for irritation and frustration and even loathing. they are sounding like any other silly band with cliched lyrics and a phoney sound and spirit.the songs seem forced and not spontaneous. I think this poppish avatar is there to attract as many listeners as possible, because the market belongs to easy listening, banal lyrics, and easily understood and remembered tunes. there are also many sounds which seem like straight lift offs from their previous albums. its as if the band has lost out on any such thing as 'inspiration' and are borrowing from their old albums because they have simply run out of ideas, creativity and originality. the depth of their music is lost in order to make as much money and as possible and sell as many albums, so even those for whom music=britney spears can now graduate to u2. easy step now.
    i dont intend to disparage the band. i'm one of their most ardant fans, and this is written in anguish, believe you me!

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 29, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs