Do It Again: Top 10 Covers of 2008

Something intriguing occurs when an artist or band takes on someone else’s song. The interpreter may cover that song by adhering to hallmarks of the original version, but hopefully enough distinctiveness shines through to make it a worthwhile performance and not merely a facsimile. That said, here are ten of the best cover songs from 2008.

10) “See Emily Play” – Martha Wainwright
Album: I Know You’re Married But I’ve Got Feelings Too

Despite (or perhaps because of) his eccentricities and psychedelic excursions, Syd Barrett betrayed a childlike purity in his music. Putting her own quirky yet endearing spin on this Pink Floyd classic, Ms. Wainwright draws on that innocence in such a way that, if he were here, would likely elicit a smile from its cosmic source.

9) “Toxic” – Portland Cello Project
Album: Portland Cello Project

For those with discriminating tastes who have pondered what a Britney Spears song would sound like as rendered in perhaps a more sophisticated medium, look no further than the Portland Cello Project’s cover of “Toxic,” which features a bevy of, well, cellos. The ensemble plays the arrangement close to the vest (and the vocals actually sound a bit like Spears), but its enthusiasm and unorthodox approach is irresistibly satisfying.

8) “Temptation” – Southside Johnny & The LaBamba Big Band
Album: Grapefruit Moon: The Songs of Tom Waits

Soaked in the faded glitz of late-night burlesque and the blue-collar grime of a Jersey shore bar, Southside Johnny bejewels this Tom Waits gem with a big brass band (or is it a brass big band?) and swagger to spare. It’s a nocturnal lament, ladies and gentlemen, rife with carnal delights and callings. It’s Southside Johnny for one night only, every night of the week: He sings! He swings! ‘Til the money runs out, he’ll tango ‘til you pour.

7) “Breaking The Girl” – Anna Nalick
Album: Shine [EP]

Already somewhat peculiar in its original form, Nalick envisages this Red Hot Chili Peppers track into an even starker enigma, stripping it down to its sonic bare bones while sustaining the cryptic bent of its narrative. It’s a riveting, ambitious interpretation, one which says something about Nalick’s creative depth and potential.

6) “All I Want Is You” – Glen Campbell
Album: Meet Glen Campbell

From one of last year’s unexpectedly rewarding albums, Campbell’s earnest rendition of this U2 love song recalls the mood of his most timeless performances. Four decades after pleading, “I need you more than want you/ And I want you for all time,” the proverbial lineman for the county sounds inspired, pining, and ever still on the line.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for Donald Gibson

Article Author: Donald Gibson

A contributing assistant music editor at Blogcritics, Donald Gibson devotes most of his writing to music criticism, paying particular attention to the craft and aesthetic of songwriting. He holds a B.A. in English from the University of South Florida.

Visit Donald Gibson's author pageDonald Gibson's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • In the Name of Love: Africa Celebrates U2 In the Name of Love: Africa Celebrates U2

    In The Name Of Love: Africa Celebrates U2 features brand-new covers of classic U2 songs by Grammy Award-winning and up-and-coming African artists including Angelique Kidjo, Les Nubians, Sierra Leone's ...

  • In Love & Light In Love & Light

    Look out for a new star in the glittering firmament of great Irish singers:with the release of her new album In Love and Light, Heidi Talbot is truly set to shine. After five years as lead singer with ...

  • Home Before Dark (Deluxe Edition with DVD) Home Before Dark (Deluxe Edition with DVD)

    Home Before Dark is the long awaited new album from legendary artist Neil Diamond. Home Before Dark was produced by legendary producer Rick Rubin who also produced Neil's critically acclaimed 12 ...

  • I Know You're Married But I've Got Feelings Too I Know You're Married But I've Got Feelings Too

    In the three years since her critically-acclaimed debut, Martha Wainwright has toured and recorded with acts ranging from Neko Case to Snow Patrol. She has performed Judy Garland at Carnegie Hall, and ...

  • Little Honey Little Honey

    Lucinda Williams has always been adept at painting landscapes of the soul, illuminating the spirit's shadowy nooks and shimmering crannies -- but she's never captured the sun breaking through the clouds ...

  • Portland Cello Project Portland Cello Project
  • Grapefruit Moon: The Songs Of Tom Waits Grapefruit Moon: The Songs Of Tom Waits

    Grapfruit Moon: The Songs of Tom Waits is Southside's tribute to one of his favorite songwriters, but also a pet sound: big band music. The idea to marry the brassy, ballsy sound of a big band to Tom ...

  • Shine Shine
  • Meet Glen Campbell Meet Glen Campbell

    Meet Glen Campbell welcomes the discovery and the re-discovery of the legend, his music, and his artistry. With a distinguished music career that spans more than five decades, Glen Campbell has returned ...

  • Jukebox Jukebox

    Her second album of covers; this one a tribute to the great vocalists who've influenced her over the years. The album comes in two versions: deluxe silver-foil gatefold cover (LP and CD) with bonus disc ...

Article comments

  • 1 - Glen Boyd

    Jan 11, 2009 at 3:12 am

    Brilliant Gibson. Fucking brilliant. And no Fuck Bottons or Monkeys within a mile. I'll take it.

    -Glen

  • 2 - Jordan Richardson

    Jan 11, 2009 at 6:04 am

    The Soweto Gospel Choir's version of "Pride" is incredible in every way. Every song on that album is, as you say, exceptional.

  • 3 - Brian aka Guppusmaximus

    Jan 11, 2009 at 7:49 am

    I would also include the cover of AIC's "Would" by Opeth. A grim track to begin with, Opeth adds a little more of their signature darkness but they keep the song true to form as a pure tribute.

  • 4 - Mark Saleski

    Jan 11, 2009 at 10:30 am

    ...he’ll tango ‘til you pour.

    sweet line, right there!

  • 5 - El Bicho

    Jan 11, 2009 at 3:20 pm

    oh, come on. Gospel has been done already

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.

blogcritics lists for Jul 10, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for June

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs