CD Review: Neil Young is Living With War - Comments Page 11

After living with Neil Young's Living With War since Friday, the verdict is in. Listen here to render your own.

The new Neil Young album Living With War has created a firestorm of controversy, and it isn't even in record stores yet. The latest word on that seems to suggest a soft release date of May 8, which would put the CD in stores by this Monday or Tuesday — the day most retail outlets adhere to as a rule.…
Read comments below, or read this article from the beginning.

Article comments

— go to most recent comments
  • 476 - Rubberneck

    Oct 17, 2006 at 8:58 pm

    Stem Cell ? Destroy embryos, Ah La' Pre-Born Babies huh ?

    [Edited]

  • 477 - Rubberneck

    Oct 18, 2006 at 6:05 pm

    Bono "Help the Poor, but not with my Money"

    "U2 defends move to avoid Irish tax raise"

    TYPICAL LIBERAL FEEL GOOD PIECE OF MONKEY CRAP.

  • 478 - Rubberneck

    Oct 21, 2006 at 3:25 am

    The "Living with War" album is Treason !

    Neil Young is a Traitor !

  • 479 - Psychorapist

    Oct 21, 2006 at 10:05 am

    I'm glad there's an ocean between me and this cretin.

  • 480 - Jet in Columbus

    Oct 21, 2006 at 10:47 am

    Actually the article is quite good Psychorapist ut;s the jerk that hijacked it that needs your help.

  • 481 - Smurphy

    Oct 23, 2006 at 12:03 am

    FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!!
    this has gone on far to fuckin long, JEEPERS FUCKIN CREEPERS...

    it was funny for a while but fuck man....give it a rest this is psychotic...

  • 482 - Rubberneck

    Oct 24, 2006 at 3:02 am

    What Passes for a
    Democrat Campaign, '06 Style ?
    In 2002 it was the Wellstone Memorial, this year it's Mark Foley!

    Ladies and gentlemen, isn't it the case that what the Democrats are trying to do is suppress GOP turnout in this race? And if they're trying to suppress GOP turnout, could it mean that they're worried about their own ? Oh yeah baby, The Conservatives are gonna pick up seats, watch !

  • 483 - Rubberneck

    Oct 24, 2006 at 3:04 am

    WHERE'S HOWARD DEAN THIS YEAR ? HUMMMM ? THE DNC IS HIDING THAT LITTLE PRICK.

  • 484 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 12:42 pm

    All stem cell research is legal today in Missouri. Jim Talent does not seek to criminalize it, as Michael J. Fox asserts in his television commercial. The truth is that Amendment 2 would put human cloning in the Missouri Constitution. Michael J. Fox is participating in this disinformation campaign. More Democrate Faked Ass Ho-cus Po-cus.

  • 485 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 12:47 pm

    DEMOCRATS LIKE NEIL YOUNG ARE PULLING THE OCTOBER SURPRIZE DON'T FALL FOR IT.

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 486 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 6:24 pm

    This is not about Parkinson's disease to me or Michael J. Fox, and it never was. I think when anyone climbs into the political arena of ideas -- particularly during a heated campaign -- they do not get the special privilege of being the only fighter allowed to throw a punch. We will speak our piece.

  • 487 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 6:29 pm

    Tell me, Diane Sawyer: Do you think there's no shilling for the Democratic Party going on as part of ABC's network news coverage? How about Democrat George Stephanopoulos, Democrat Chris Cuomo, and Democrat whoever else appearing as learned, serious, objective journalists on ABC ?

  • 488 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 6:55 pm

    Fraud claims running rampant after Katrina
    Contractor problems, identity theft among concerns

    02:57 PM CDT on Thursday, October 13, 2005

    Associated Press


    WASHINGTON -- Hurricane Katrina has spawned a second big flood that is surging well beyond the Gulf Coast: thousands of cases and complaints alleging fraud.


    Seven weeks after the storm roared ashore, authorities around the country are amassing cases ranging from identity theft to scams by phony construction contractors to hotel price gouging.


    In Louisiana, dozens of victims have applied for benefits from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, only to find their personal identification information has been stolen and already used. In Texas, authorities say people falsely claiming to be refugees collected hundreds of dollars in emergency aid -- sometimes going back two or three times each day.


    And in Mississippi, authorities are on the lookout for a woman who was charging victims $50 to use her "super-duper FEMA phone" -- which she said would let frustrated callers bypass busy signals on a direct hot line to the relief agency.


    "There are some real oddball cases," said Mississippi Assistant Attorney General Grant Hedgepeth, who heads the state's consumer protection office. Mississippi investigators have received more than 1,000 complaints -- about hotel and gas price gouging, phony insurance adjuster scams, people posing as FEMA workers to collect victims' personal information.


    The Red Cross is investigating more than 500 fraud cases, said spokeswoman Devorah Goldburg. And as of Thursday, the Justice Department had charged 34 people with various fraud crimes stemming from Katrina and Hurricane Rita.


    An estimated 1.5 million people evacuated their homes in Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama when Katrina hit the coast Aug. 29. Congress has approved $62 billion in disaster relief aid.


    The big payout, combined with the scattering of victims to nearly every state, created the potential for rampant fraud in Katrina's aftermath, said Jeannette M. Adkins, executive director of the National Organization of Victim Assistance.


    Scam artists "can show up to disaster relief centers in almost every state and present themselves as victims, and have nothing to show for it," Adkins said. "And people are handing out the money."


    While the number of federal cases is still relatively small, officials say the prosecutions reflect a more aggressive effort by the government to curb fraud than there was after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.


    The federal government prosecuted 13 people accused of fraudulently seeking aid from the September 11th Victims Compensation Fund and New York City, according to the Justice Department's inspector general. Focused on preventing more terror attacks, the department left nearly all 9/11 fraud cases to local and state prosecutors.


    With Katrina, the federal government created an anti-fraud task force the week after the storm hit to curb con artists and contractors trying to cheat the system.


    The goal is to make sure that money from the relief effort "doesn't end up in the pockets or wallets of defrauders," said Assistant Attorney General Alice S. Fisher, who heads the task force of investigators from 35 agencies.


    Nearly all the federal cases target people posing as displaced hurricane victims. Some are charged with applying for FEMA and Red Cross aid using stolen identity information; others are accused of contriving tragic scenarios to blend in with victims who lost all documentation of their properties.


    Two people in Los Angeles are accused of posing as charity officials to collect money from trusting donors. A Miami-area man allegedly solicited donations though his Web site by promising to help evacuate children and critically ill patients from Louisiana.


    The bulk of the cases are surfacing at state and local levels.


    In Houston, local police arrested 54 people over a six-day period last month, accusing them of illegally collecting Red Cross benefits from a Baptist church.


    "Some people were bold enough to come through three times a day," said Houston Police Lt. Craig Williams, who estimated that up to 7,000 Katrina victims -- and impostors -- collected aid at the church daily. Victims were eligible for $360 individually, or $1,565 for a family of five -- and "everybody was claiming they had five kids," he said.


    Investigators for Louisiana's attorney general are looking into more than 2,200 complaints about gas stations and hotels trying to take advantage of desperate families by raising prices, said spokeswoman Jennifer Cluck. In Mississippi, Hedgepeth said some hotel prices skyrocketed from nightly rates of $49 to $135 as evacuees searched for shelter.


    Even a Louisiana campground got into the price gouging game, Cluck said, by allowing only evacuees willing to pay $900 in monthly fees to stay.


    As the immediate emergency for evacuees subsides, authorities anticipate scammers will find new ways to defraud victims. Construction contracts are being watched closely by federal, state and local prosecutors. Roofers are under particular scrutiny in Louisiana, which has seen a spate of cases where little or no work gets done after scammers receive upfront payments.


    "We'll probably start seeing some new trends as people look to get back into heir homes and restart their lives," Cluck said.

    Rocker Neil Young for what he's worth did not send any of his fleet of Busses to pick up any Katrina victims nor have any of them been spotted on his mega miles of Prime California Country side. Looks like he don't want them round him either; however the good people of Houston have seen there Crime rates skyrocket 3 to 4 Hundred percent. Will Neil Young do a Concert to help offset the cost of Crime Fighting for the good people of Houston ? Bet not. Nope, he'll blame Bush.

  • 489 - Rubberneck

    Oct 25, 2006 at 11:11 pm

    Don't fall for the trick of letting liberals get away with lying and misrepresenting things, despite their technique of putting forth people to do this who they think should be immune from such criticism. When anybody enters the political arena, they are subject to criticism, reaction and response. Nobody is immune. Nobody

  • 490 - Rubberneck

    Oct 27, 2006 at 10:42 am

    SO MUCH FOR GLOBAL WARMING, "LIBS" NOT TO MENTION THE COLORADO ECONOMY ! THE "GARDEN IS GONE", IT'S COVERED IN SNOW NEIL YOUNG.

    By DAN ELLIOTT, Associated Press Writer

    DENVER - The biggest October snowstorm to hit Colorado in several years has dumped more than 2 feet here, grounding flights, closing highways, knocking out electricity " and jump-starting the ski season.

    IT AIN'T EVEN WINTER YET, HEYUK HEYUK HEYUK !

    GLOBAL WARMING IS A HOAX SET FORTH BY ANTI CAPITALIST AMERICA HATING COMMUNIST LIBERALS.

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 491 - Rubberneck

    Oct 29, 2006 at 12:20 pm

    If Democrats Have it in the Bag, Why Are There So Many "Hotly Contested" Races Out There?

    Hey, that James Webb Book huh ? LOL ! Go George Allen !

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 492 - Rubberneck

    Nov 01, 2006 at 4:46 am

    Those in the military are the people who undergo things that 99% of the population will not, and John Kerry sees fit to insult them by suggesting that they are only there because they're losers. John Kerry is a despicable human being and a know Traitor to the United States.

  • 493 - Rubberneck

    Nov 01, 2006 at 4:59 am

    There's so much to analyze from just this one little ten-second bite; it tells us what John Kerry himself and the Democratic Party really think about the troops and the US military.
    Is there an Amber Alert for Nancy Pelosi yet ? She cannot be found. Why ? Is she @ Howard Deans house cause no one can find him either. Now we know why ! There are a bunch of fake
    conservative "Democrats" running in House races and they can't go out there and undercut them by announcing the full-fledged, left-wing, socialist Neil Young agenda that they have in store for the American people. The Democrats are trying to muzzle themselves. They don't want their guys speaking in public, betraying who they really are. But along comes Lurch -- long-faced John Kerry -- stepping in it again. YAFUCKIN-WHOOOOOOOOOO. Keep talkin' Lurch !
    Liberals and Democrats in this country have long-held contempt for the US military. To them, it's the focus of evil in the modern world. John Kerry was in Vietnam; he knows -- he's made a career out of bashing the US military ever since he got out. By the way, John Kerry is suffering another delusion: he's under the impression that he has a legitimate shot to win the 2008 presidential nomination of the Democratic Party. This little escapade blows that out of the water. Yeah Baby Yeah !

  • 494 - Rubberneck

    Nov 01, 2006 at 10:48 pm

    So it turns out that Neil Young's "Lets Impeach the President" Video is Factually Wrong about the President hiring "All the Criminals" .

    It turns out that Dick Cheney, Karl Rove, and Scooter Libby had absolutely nothing to do with revealing VALERIE PLAME'S (outing a C.I.A. agents Indentity) just like they said they didn't.

    Dear Neil Young,

    Acusing someone of being a Criminal is lible. But putting their images on a Permanent Musical Video is far beyond that, especially when it's proven to be a Lie. So what the fuck are you going to do about it Neil Fucking Communist Lover Young ? YOU FUCKIN LIED ! YOU ARE THE FUCKING LIAR. A democrat ADMITS to being the Criminal ! So now are you going to revise your Piece of Shit home movie Video to show the true admitted Criminal ? Ol' Barrel Chested Former Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage.

    [Edited]

    Rubberneck

  • 495 - Rubberneck

    Nov 01, 2006 at 10:58 pm

    Diplomacy didn't win the Cold War, Mrs. Clinton. Diplomacy didn't win World War II. Diplomacy didn't win World War I. Diplomacy hasn't won any war because diplomacy prevents the engagement of the enemy -- it just appeases and prolongs what has to ultimately be done anyway.

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 496 - Rubberneck

    Nov 02, 2006 at 5:31 am

    John Kerry

    "I agree Completely with this Administration's Goal of Regime Change in Iraq" (7/29/02)

    Now watch him Lie through his fuckin' Herman Munster teeth.


    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 497 - Rubberneck

    Nov 02, 2006 at 2:05 pm

    From # (475)
    I see your boy Bush has as almost completed his trifecta along the axis of evil. 2 more years of this madman and we will all be living in bunkers. I'm sure yours is all carved out and ready. I'm living with war and ignorance everyday and everyday we get in deeper, when will we wake up?

    Grow a set of nuts Girly-man Martina. Stop being a little Bitch like Neil Young. Bunkers ? Do you even know we have the ability to wipe any and all from the face of the Earth ? The reason our guys are falling is not GWB or RC it's you faggot loving Communists insisting we be careful when we blow shit up. Fight a War carefully ? Fucking Absurd !

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 498 - Brian aka Guppusmaximus

    Nov 02, 2006 at 2:27 pm

    Rubberneck's Speaking The Truth & No one can stop him!!

    Keep up the Good Work & F*ck the useless chowderheads that don't do sh!t for this country
    You know who you are: Hillary,John,Neil,Deval

  • 499 - Rubberneck

    Nov 03, 2006 at 5:44 am

    John Kerry

    "I agree Completely with this Administration's Goal of Regime Change in Iraq" (7/29/02)

    Now watch him Lie through his fuckin' Herman Munster teeth.

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

    [Edited. Nobody edited the link, Rubberneck]]

    Let the People know what a true Democrat is.

  • 500 - Rubberneck

    Nov 03, 2006 at 11:47 am

    John Kerry

    "I agree Completely with this Administration's Goal of Regime Change in Iraq" (7/29/02)

    Now watch him Lie through his fuckin' Herman Munster teeth.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXwCrpMHkYc

    Your Pal,

    Rubberneck

  • 501 - DJRadiohead

    Nov 03, 2006 at 2:45 pm

    Rubberneck, I would like to politely appeal to you to take your political discussion to the politics area of the site.

    I recognize Neil Young's record has overt political tones to it, but your recent comments have had nothing to do with Young or the record but are rather instances of you making your political opinions known. This is a very fine line and I am counting on your ability to see the nuance.

    Understand, I do not wish to censor you and am not asking you to not speak your mind. I am simply asking -- not demanding or ordering or anything of the kind -- you to consider making your comments on this and other threads more topical.

  • 502 - Glen Boyd

    Nov 03, 2006 at 3:07 pm

    Amen DJR. And thank you. This has gone on just about long enough.

    -Glen

  • 503 - Rubberneck

    Nov 04, 2006 at 4:41 am

    Oh, I'm sorry. Am I being a Bother ?

    Rubberneck signing Off

    Roger and Out !

    Rubberneck.

  • 504 - Glen Boyd

    Nov 04, 2006 at 6:05 am

    Which means what exactly? The return of "Mookey"?

    I mean you "two guys" are like Clark Kent and Superman. One leaves, the other returns. Never in the same place at the same time. And promises made mean absolutely nothing.

    Look, I've tried to be nice. I really have. But enough is enough. I'm asking we give this a rest, and if DJR's polite request is any indication, I now have some official BC editor muscle behind it.

    We have a politics section for this sort of thing. Go there Mr. NeckMook. Knock thyself out. I suspect you'll find a very active, receptive audience waiting too.

    But my Neil Young review---Hello?---is played out. Unless you were planning to take this into the next century or something. But like I said, its done here. You wont be getting that opportunity.

    500 posts to state your case that you are a card carrying Republican is plenty enough. You have made your point and then some.

    Its over. Deal with it.

    Or better yet move on to a place where you can debate the night away. The politics section is calling your name Mr. Mook Neck.

    I'm actually going to ask, as the original writer of this article, that this thread be closed to future comments.

    In fact, I just did.

    -Glen

  • 505 - Christopher Rose

    Nov 04, 2006 at 6:58 am

    It's beyond my reach to close an article to comments and also not a practice I'm fond of.

    I can however invoke Emergency Regulation "Latex 1" which requires all further comments to this page to be music related until further notice. Any non-compliant comments will simply be deleted.

    Kind Regards,

    The Comments Editor

  • 506 - Glen Boyd

    Nov 04, 2006 at 7:26 am

    Music related works Chris. And thanx!

    I'm just glad someone (namely DJR) finally recognized the problem here today.

    Mr. MookNeck--it's time to take your Lib/Kerry/Hilary/Democrat/Commie/Rush/etc/etc/etc/ vitriol to where it belongs.

    Its called the politics section bro.

    We are done here.

    Capiche?

    -Glen

  • 507 - Martin Lav

    Nov 06, 2006 at 1:32 pm

    Please, please don't close this off, I'm enjoying the the Rubber Monkey's meltdown too much! He's literally talking to himself, while wrestling with his desire to love Neil Young's music. It's an obvious inner struggle of unbelievable proportions. Rush vs. Young.....

    By the way, does the re-release of Living With War get a new review? It's a different mix, so doesn't it warrant?

    Please advise.......


    Album of the Year......just wait.
    Incredible stuff!

  • 508 - Spanky

    Nov 11, 2006 at 7:14 am

    History was made this week! For the first time in four election cycles, Democrats are not attacking the Diebold Corp. the day after the election, accusing it of rigging its voting machines. I guess Diebold has finally been vindicated. Not a word out of Neil Young either. Wasn't there fraud during this election other than the Voter Registration Fraud by the Liberal Advocacy Group (ACORN)? Neil help us on this we know there was fraud !

    Thanks Neil,

    Spanky

  • 509 - Ruboookey

    Nov 21, 2006 at 8:10 pm

    In the past week, there are 476 documents on Nexis heralding the magnificent achievement of Nancy Pelosi becoming the FIRST WOMAN speaker of the House. I thought we had moved beyond such multicultural milestones.

    The media yawned when Condoleezza Rice became the first black woman secretary of state (and when Lincoln Chaffee became the first developmentally disabled senator).

    There were only 77 documents noting that Rice was the first black woman to be the secretary of state, and half of them were issues of Jet, Essence, Ebony or Black Entrepreneur magazine.

  • 510 - Spanky

    Nov 29, 2006 at 8:09 pm

    So Neil,

    Did Howard Dean see any fraud this election ? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO of course fucking not ! Because Democrats won and that's the natural order of things ain't it Neil Young ? Back to the Communist White North TRAITOR.

    Spanky.

  • 511 - Spanky

    Dec 05, 2006 at 1:20 pm

    Would you Anti-American Communists agree that War is worthless ? (Except for ending slavery, Nazism, fascism, and communism) Other than that, war is pointless huh ? Well I guess we didn't totally wipe out the latter, did we ?

    Spanky

  • 512 - Spanky

    Dec 06, 2006 at 11:40 am

    By HOPE YEN, Associated Press Writer

    WASHINGTON - One year after Katrina, the government is still squandering tens of millions of dollars in wasted disaster aid, including $17 million in bogus rental payments to people who had already received free trailers and apartments, federal investigators said Wednesday.

  • 513 - Martin Lav

    Dec 07, 2006 at 6:36 pm

    Neil Young nominated for three Grammy's!
    Told you RubberMonkeySpanker.

    Album of the year.......you wait.

    This is one fine album and the American people are waking up.

    Let the Impeachment proceedings begin.

  • 514 - Rubberneck

    Dec 08, 2006 at 2:41 am

    [Edited]

    P.S. Album of the year my ASS ! An album that has sold roughly 150,000 Copies !

    Yours,

    Mr. Freeze

  • 515 - Martin Lav

    Dec 08, 2006 at 6:16 pm

    Spank your ass RubberMonkeySpanker!
    This album that sold virtually nothing, will go down in history. The Shammies will reward Neil because they love a good liberal agenda and your boy George will have to give Neil Young his due.
    Neil Young do you remember?

  • 516 - RogerMDillon

    Dec 08, 2006 at 9:06 pm

    Rubberbrain, the grammys are not about album sales, but then why should you know what you are talking about at this point.

    Go idle in the garage and spare the gene pool.

  • 517 - Spankmonkbberneck

    Dec 10, 2006 at 12:55 am

    I know it's not about sales. But really, what else can we measure by ? If nobody buys it, what's it worth ? Certainly nothing to the record company. In fact a piece of crap like this costs them money. A statement ? Why won't even Libs throw their hero a friggin' bone and buy these re-written 40 timesover songs if they think his "statement" is so great ? Surely there are 500,000 Hippy Hold overs around, I know most of them are on oxygen and in re-hab from all the smoking and Drugs but at least they could send someone to the store to trade their Government food stamps for some cash and then buy the CD. I know something can be worked out.

    Try Harder and lets sell some albums for Neil, after all, he needs that 2 hundred and fiftyfirst Car for his collection.

    Your Pal,

    Spankmonkbberneck

  • 518 - Spankmonkbberneck

    Dec 11, 2006 at 5:43 am

    Ohhhhhhhhh Marty Boy,

    Stadium Arcadium (RHCP)is in the Rock Album Category. You and Neil can FORGETTTTABOUTTTTTIT

    LOL "Living with War" LOL

    Spankmonkbberneck

    Too bad there's no Communist Propaganda Section. Even I would vote for it then.

  • 519 - Rubberspankmookneck

    Dec 28, 2006 at 10:05 am

    I HOPE NEIL YOUNG WILL REMEMBER THE UNITED STATES DON'T NEED HIM AROUND ANYHOW !

    SWEET HOME AMERICA WHERE THE SKIES ARE SO BLUE !

  • 520 - Chuck

    Jan 19, 2007 at 3:33 am

    Pelosi is going to announce her global warming panel. It's 37 degrees in Frisco, 36 in Santa Barbara, 43 in San Diego, and 37 in Houston. Maybe she should wear earmuffs !

  • 521 - Chuck

    Jan 26, 2007 at 4:36 am

    The American people do not want defeat. They do not want to cut-and-run. They want to kick the crap out of the enemy and get out of there.

  • 522 - Chuck

    Jan 30, 2007 at 12:03 pm

    The American left is now building up the notion that we're not really at great risk: 'Yeah, a lot of people are threatening us, but they can't really do anything, so we're just really overreacting here.' So their conclusion is we have to wait until they can pull it off to deal with them.

  • 523 - Martin Lav

    Jan 30, 2007 at 12:07 pm

    What's up Chuck?

    Bored with your other names?

    Talking to yourself again?

    Album of the Year you wait!

  • 524 - Chuck

    Feb 03, 2007 at 3:00 am

    Album of the year my ASS. YOU Watch ! RHCP will win that hands down and Neil will burn out as he always does. Either way, Anti-American Communists win and that in and of it self should make you happy Marvy. Congrats !

    Global Warming is a Hoax,

    Yours,

    Chuck

  • 525 - Chuck

    Feb 03, 2007 at 3:09 am

    We're going to have to rev up the entire merchandise line now that RUSH LIMBAUGH is a Nobel Peace Prize nominee. We're going to have to make t-shirts with pictures of him on the Nobel Peace Prize underneath the phrase, 'Give peace a chance. All hail Limbaugh !

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 30, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs