Theoretically, smart, sophisticated fans of rock music are strongly opposed to crass commercial pop music. The Monkees were widely denounced by all supposedly "cool" or "hip" music listeners- despite the fact that they made some really good records. Nonetheless, they were an artificial construct put together by business interests just to [gasp!] make money. The bastards! A decade later, this anti-commercialism was codified by the punk rockers, as symbolized by their particularly virulent hatred of Rod Stewart- the disco sellout.
Then there is Bruce Springsteen.
At one time, Bruce Springsteen was an important artist. Born to Run and Greetings from Asbury Park are two of the best albums in the rock music tradition.
Glory days will pass you by, though. By the time he got to the 1980s, the muse had left the one-time boss. As the quality of his inspiration diminished, however, the pure commercial determination of the man took over. The interesting artistic flourishes and colors of his early work got dumbed down- dumbed way the hell down.
Born in the USA was Springsteen's biggest album, and a huge corporate sellout. By this, I mean that it was designed as a commercial product much more than as an artistic statement. Instead of passionate individual artistic expression, the songs came out more like calculated Madison Avenue jingles. The title song "Born in the USA" in particular is just a stupid politically correct liberal's version of the cheap jingoism of Lee Greenwood's "God Bless the USA." It's just a mindless and trite piece of [anti] American sloganeering.
Now generally, I don't mind crass commercialism. Give me a good catchy pop song, and I'll cheerfully fork over the dough. Hey, there's only so much of the intensity of Robert Johnson and Kurt Cobain one man can take before he needs a break. ABBA has gotten some of my money, and surely the Monkees, Duran Duran and Michael Jackson have gotten their fair share of my pocket change. I've got no problem with someone wanting to make a buck.
Article comments
1 - Sean Hackbarth
Ouch! I'm not a Springsteen fan, yet I'm not that cynical. I bought The Rising and found some of the songs great.
2 - George Partington
Man, you could not be more wrong about The River.
3 - johnson
The Guardian described the incident that brought about the conception of 'the Rising' in a story dated July 21:
A few days after 11 September, Bruce Springsteen was pulling out of a beach parking lot in the Jersey Shore town of Sea Bright when a fan rode by. The man rolled down his window, shouted ‘We need you!’ and drove on. It was the kind of moment, Springsteen says, that made his career worthwhile. ‘That’s part of my job. It’s an honour to find that place in the audience’s life.’Springsteen heavily researched and helped the Widows and people who were affected by 9/11 as well as sending proceeds from his Rising tour concerts to various 9/11 related charities.
4 - lena
the ultimate depository of Springsteen review: