The strengths of this album are the musicianship and the songwriting. Slim demonstrates a rare mastery of slide guitar, harp, and dobro. The Workers provide solid, subtle, sonic scenery. They never overpower the songs, nor do they miss a beat. The warm production smooths some of the rough edges which some people might consider a negative for a blues album. Fortunately, Watermelon Slim & The Workers is warm and smooth without giving in to slickness. Think of it as a good sipping whiskey for the ears.
The weaknesses are few, but should be noted. It took some time to get used to Slim's voice and delivery. He has a decent, but not powerful blues voice. His delivery is sometimes grandfatherly and is not as effective on some songs as it is on others. At 14 songs and 52 minutes, the album might have been better served were it a song or two shorter. I would probably trim the French language “Eau De Boue,” for starters, but that is just me.
As a newly-minted member of The Blues Foundation, I will have the opportunity to participate in the voting for the 2007 BMAs. I am not sure I will mark my ballot all six times for him, but I sure as hell will not shut Slim out, either. I may always think first of Muddy, Otis, and Buddy when I think of the blues, but I no longer think of contemporary artists recording traditional blues as an oxymoron.
Article comments
1 - Connie Phillips
Congrats! This article has been forwarded to the Advance.net websites.
2 - Pico
Even his stage name tells you that this is some good blues! But with six nominations, I'm gonna have to see what the fuss is all about. The Blues Foundation does a good job at awarding the deserving.
Oh, and thanks a lot for the "Black Water" reference. I had a hard enough time getting that song out of my cranium after writing about the album it came on. Now it's back stronger than ever. Arghh!!! ;&)
3 - DJRadiohead
It popped into my head almost immediately the first time I listened to "Folding Dollar Blues." In fact, last night when I was putting the finishing touches on the review I went and listened to clips of "Black Water" on iTunes because I have no DBs CDs in my collection.
By all means, get yourself a copy of this album. It took a couple of spins for me to really digest it but now these songs have gotten under my skin.
4 - Strumming Sam
Very nicely written review. I feel the same way about most modern blues artists - with very few exceptions.
One such exception is a D.C. artist by the name of Ben Andrews. He has two albums with Mapleshade Records ('Preaching The Blues', and 'harp, steel, and guts'). When he recorded with Mapleshade he did so as The Blue Rider Trio.
The Blue Rider Trio sports some incredible Harp playing (Mark Wenner), as well as a slap bassist. While slap bass is not my favorite instrument, it's still vastly better than the accordion! OK, it's a technique used with the bass, and not just an instrument. Nonetheless, it fails to give that deep percussion sound you need to back up some guy pluckin' away on a Dobro resonator. The harmonica really does wonders to warm up those sweet blues tones.
Regarding the harmonica playing, I'm not kidding when I say that Mark Wenner is incredible. He adds such texture to the music that you often forget that it is really just three guys playing! How many trios have you heard that don't sound thin? Plus, he's making up for a rather thin bass section.
Ben is currently touring all over Europe, and has had multiple invites to blues festivals all over the world. So, why is he so popular? Once you hear his virtuoso Piedmont pickin' you'll know why!
And his voice? There are plenty of great blues musicians (e.g. Leo Kottke, Harlem Slim, John Mayhall) that don't have the kind of voice needed to make you "feel" the blues that they play. Ben Andrews suffers from no such ailment. His voice has the kind of rich, down-low blues grit that most people would have to gargle gasoline to get.
To happen upon such a multi-faceted blues musician is a pleasant surprise indeed. What is even more surprising is that Ben Andrews remains one of the blues world's best kept secrets. Apparently he has recorded a BBC session, as well recording several albums in Brittan (four I think). Yet, those various recorded events and albums are apparently not available in the US.
If you care to hear him YouTube has a clip of The Blue Rider Trio doing Blind Willie McTell's famous Statesboro Blues:
The YouTube version of the Blue Rider Trio is not made up of the same three gentleman. This trio uses a real drummer to provide the percussion. The harmonica is a hyper, if not irritating, reed blower. He's no Mark Wenner, but he's certainly talented - If you could just get him to quit bouncing around the stage (and nowhere in sync' with the rhythm either!).
Thanks for your great review, I hope you like mine,
-Sam
5 - Tim Jarvis
Hugh Feeley's rhythm was never effected by his enthusiasm for playing the tune. This version of Statesboro was played to a near empty house; he's certainly not grandstanding, Ben and I were not distracted. That his physical demeanor could fairly be described as 'hyper', might be balanced against the fact that he not "playing to the crowd", it's not histrionics ...he was just enjoying playing the groove.
Also to be taken into account: Hugh is about 10 years younger than Mark Wenner. Most notable in explaining Hugh's performances reflecting experience above the elders': Mark did not have Hugh's dozens of gigs worth of, years worth of, and many hundreds of hours experience of, playing Ben's repetoire as a duo.
The youtube clips are, of course, live, club performances. They weren't selected from multiple studio takes, to give THE best performances. To add my opinion,that those sessions come from a studio with a dry, and rather sterile sound.
The Blue Riders 40, highly rated, clips are here.
Cheers,
Tim Jarvis
The Blue Riders, drums and percussion