Andrew Hill, 1931-2007 - Page 3

Hill learned in 2004 that he had lung cancer; fighting it every step of the way, he continued making his fantastic and ever-forward-charging music, causing NPR to note that "Hill still creates music as if his best work is ahead of him.” Despite his conviction and his deep progress with records such as Time Lines and transcendent live performances, Hill played his last live date in New York City on March 29, 2007. Less than two weeks later, the prestigious Berklee College of Music announced that it would award Hill an honorary doctorate in music at its May 12 commencement ceremony; sadly, Hill would survive only nine more days after that announcement.

I, personally, feel great loss at the departure of one of the greatest pianists and composer/arrangers of the past several decades, and will forever kick myself for having passed up an opportunity to see Hill perform in Baltimore last December. And yet I know that I will cherish his music, and continue to find more delights and surprises in it, for at least another several decades. This, I hope, is the greatest testimony to Hill's genius, and one can only hope that effusive thanks - and hope that Andrew Hill now finds himself in a better place - can cover his enormous contribution to music.

Page 1Page 2 — Page 3

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for michael-j-west

Article Author: Michael J. West

Michael J. West is a writer, editor, and dilettante jazz critic in Washington, D.C. In addition to BlogCritics, he writes for JazzTimes, Washington City Paper, and AllAboutJazz.com. He occasionally writes at Pop Musicology, too. He's very cute. …

Visit Michael J. West's author pageMichael J. West's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Black Fire Black Fire

    Alfred Lion called Andrew Hill his last great discovery and "Black Fire" was the pianist's brilliant Blue Note debut. Despite the originality and complexity of Hill's compositions, Joe Henderson, Richard ...

  • Judgment! Judgment!
  • No image found Smoke Stack

    SmokestackThis title is manufactured "on demand" when ordered from Amazon.com, using recordable media as authorized by the rights holder. Powered by CreateSpace, this on-demand program makes thousands ...

  • Passing Ships Passing Ships
  • Grass Roots [CD on Demand] Grass Roots [CD on Demand]

    This title is manufactured "on demand" when ordered from Amazon.com, using recordable media as authorized by the rights holder. Powered by CreateSpace, this on-demand program makes thousands of titles ...

  • Lift Every Voice Lift Every Voice
  • Verona Rag Verona Rag
  • Andrew!!! Andrew!!!

    The work of this unique pianist and composer is marked invention. This 1964 quintet session features John Gilmore, Bobby Hutcherson, Richard Davis and Joe Chambers, all peers who grasp his concepts perfectly. ...

  • The Day the World Stood Still The Day the World Stood Still
  • Time Lines Time Lines

    Time Lines marks the return to Blue Note of one of the label's great originals, with Hill retaining the edgy intensity that marked such '60s masterpieces as Black Fire and Judgment. ...

  • Point of Departure Point of Departure

Article comments

  • 1 - Pico

    Apr 21, 2007 at 10:59 pm

    Wow, sad news. He finally started getting his due in recent years, but perhaps still not enough. His legacy will continue to grow in the coming years, though, I feel pretty certain of that.

    Hill's works has sometimes been so dense I had a hard time absorbing it, but I could tell that it was something much more sophisticated than what could easily be understood. Recently I finally had the occasion to listen to Compulsion after being familiar with (and reviewing) Nels Cline's version of the title song and found it to be very advanced and out of the box, like much of his Blue Noters. It's not surprising that a guy like Cline admires Hill's music.

    Very nice tribute, Michael.

  • 2 - Fred Stark

    Apr 22, 2007 at 5:28 am

    I am very sad this great musician/composer has
    passed away. I first listened to his music in the late '70s with the reissues from 1970. I have been
    a teacher so I can appreciate the value of mentoring
    the students. I am a person with a physical disability as Andrew Hill was, and I know the challenges he faced dealing with those issues. I am
    grateful I was able to see him in June 2006 once again.

  • 3 - ken

    Apr 27, 2007 at 10:02 pm

    A great appreciation of Hill and far more factual and insightful than the ones circulating on the AP Wire. Hill was a great pianist and composer.

  • 4 - Leslie Bohn

    Apr 27, 2007 at 10:37 pm

    Oh, yes, Mr. West, this was well-written and shows a real in-depth knowledge of the music. Your essay gets across the idea that AH's approach to the music was thoughtful and experimental and intellectual " serious.

    That amazing flurry of five or six Blue Note albums from late 63 and 64 is just brimming with ideas, as you eloquently say. All are, as they say, "highly recommended." Your favorite seems to be Point of Departure, which only edges out IMHO Black Fire by a nose. Almost anything with Dolphy in that period is a treasure, too.

    His recent comeback was welcome; I saw him a couple years ago at Lincoln Center and he was very very sharp, picking out fast ripping runs that cut through the big room.
    What are your musical thoughts about the big comeback allbum Dusk, Mr. West and his late playing?

  • 5 - Michael J. West

    Apr 28, 2007 at 12:17 am

    Thanks for your comments, Ken and Leslie!

    Leslie, I actually prefer Black Fire myself; I've had "Subterfuge" in my head every day since I wrote the article. I focus on Point of Departure in the article because it's his best-known. Also, it features the most "all-star" lineup of his career.

    Dusk is a hard album to argue with, too. It felt like both a summation of his classic '60s Blue Note work in a lot of places, but in others as though it was thrusting forward into the future (especially "15/8"). And the unaccompanied piano stuff? Beautiful. It was the best he'd done in years...

    ...until Time Lines came out last year. That was a marvel - the songs were so beautiful, but the arrangements and the orchestrations were so--I guess "pointillistic" is the word.

    That actually might be a good way to look at his late work, Leslie, since you ask - though he'd gained such mastery over that melodic/harmonic rainbow on piano and in composition that he turned his attention to innovating the arrangements.

  • 6 - Maxim

    May 16, 2007 at 4:45 pm

    I've discovered music by Andrew Hill quite recently but almost instantly fell in love with it. Since then i've absorbed his every work I could find. "Black fire" was the first acquaintance but then there have been "Passing ships", "Andrew!!!", "Judgment", "Dance with death" and "Dusk". Some songs like "Passing ships" or "Pumpkin" from Black Fire make my eyes watery )) I know and can easily explain what makes Andrew absolutely unique even among the great. It is his superb melodic talant + distinctive piano style + ever fresh approach to arrangement. His music perfectly balances melody and improvisation without becoming cheezy or too abstract.
    I greatly regret his passing. Which is particularly sad news now as i was looking for Mr. Hill's contact info hoping to invite him to give a performance in my country.

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 11, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs