Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Music Review: St. Vincent – Actor

Music Review: St. Vincent – Actor

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

In her second outing, St. Vincent’s Annie Clark says she’s making “a metaphor for the whole artistic mindset.” Through the telling of what she calls “little meta moments” Clark presents the image of an artist’s desperate endeavor. These “meta moments” are little more than an admirable attempt at this theme as the record never quite grasps the struggling artist message. Yet an alluring album gradually comes into full bloom as the quirky turns and oddball moods become more and more homey.

After one trip through Actor it is painfully obvious that this album was written in Apple’s GarageBand. The drum beats are generic, reeking of rotten Apple Loops. This gives many of the songs the effect of feeling small rather than spacious. It sounds like Clark is trapped inside a laptop. It would be easy to attribute this sound to her desire to convey the cage of artistic endeavor, or perhaps the anxiety of suburban life as imparted in “Black Rainbow.” However this feels like a manufactured causal relationship. There’s more evidence to support Clark’s use of strings pads and orchestra samples as the foundation to Actor, with the melodies and lyrics following behind. To ascribe a deeper meaning to the use of a laptop orchestra would be a distortion of the process.

Within the small space of these songs there still blossoms something far-reaching. In “The Neighbors” and the aforementioned “Black Rainbow” Clark connects with a tale of a G-rated Pleasantville. Through the former’s disorderly meter jumping and the latter’s climax of evil Disney witch soundtrack, she succeeds in communicating a feeling of social unrest. The quintessential neighborhood is at odds with the “bird fighting it’s own reflection.”

Expanding on the antithetical Disney theme is “The Strangers” with its slight dementia that eventually falls down a rabbit hole of fairytale nightmares. The use of sulking clarinet samples throughout, most notably on “The Bed”, contributes to the blemished princess motif. On “The Party”, a highly memorable track with time signature shifts, the downside of Clark’s sample use comes to full frame. The orchestra in the final third of the song sounds so fake it actually kills the evolution of the track. No doubt it would’ve been ideal to use a real orchestra here, with it’s lush, flowing, sweeping dynamics instead of the conspicuous pressing of keys to simulate string changes.

In addition to her heavy reliance on Apple’s GarageBand, it also appears Clark had her iTunes set on repeat of Radiohead circa ’00-’01. She evokes Thom Yorke in “Just The Same But Brand New” with the line “I might be wrong, I might be wrong” and mimics drummer Phil Selway’s trip roll snare of Kid A’s “Morning Bell” in “Laughing With A Mouth Of Blood.”

Interestingly, on the vinyl release in the UK the track listing has "The Sequel" following "Black Rainbow", leaving "Just The Same But Brand New" as the album’s closer.  With "The Sequel" as the last track of the album it gives the ending a sense of being reborn, a sequel, a start anew.  Moving it to the middle of the album causes it to come across as more of a transitional track — while it does have the affect of a new morning or sun break after the pounding rainstorm that was "Black Rainbow", "Laughing With A Mouth Of Blood" fills that role just fine on its own. What this alternate track order does however, is allow "Just The Same But Brand New" to be the unearthly, dark closer that it feels like it should be.

At various turns it would be nice to hear a little more power in Clark’s vocal, specifically on “Marrow” which borrows residual aggression from Björk’s Volta. Clark gets buried underneath the distortion and a few lessons in dynamics from the Icelandic soprano would have suited her well in Actor’s eerie ventures.

Wading through the thematic haze of Actor progressively reveals an album with loads of beauty and turns of fright, often times simultaneous. While it’s carriage is not nearly perfect, the road it chooses to travel isn’t either, and the potholes and ruts are a welcome part of the experience.

Powered by

About Jonathan Kroening

  • Westfolk

    If you’re going to make accusations, you might want to do some research first. Although there might be slight sample use on the record, most of the orchestral instruments were played by ACTUAL musicians with ACTUAL instruments. As for the Radiohead lyrical comparison…really? “I might be wrong” is a common expression. I doubt it was even an afterthought. Last but not least, if you want to hear a bit more power in the vocal then maybe you’re listening for the wrong things. No, she is not Bjork, she’s Annie Clark. The power lies in the lyric and spirited tonality. Its hard to disagree that these things don’t have as much to do with the strength of a voice as the dynamic.

  • http://itsjustmusic.net Jonathan Kroening

    i challenge you to prove to me that the strings at the end of “The Party” are ACTUAL instruments. as far as i’ve seen, the credits only list one violin player. that’s not nearly a full orchestra. if you’re familiar with sampled strings you would recognize the sound immediately and know what i’m referring to. and if your comment is an attempt at defending St. Vincent, please note that i gave the album 4 stars. it’s a great record.

  • Westfolk

    I was merely stating that there were actual, organic instruments on this record, which you failed to mention at all in your review. You made it seem as if the whole record was accompanied by some sort of processed symphony. And yes, I am defending St. Vincent. I just found your criticism to be a bit lacking on key bits of information. The flutes and saxophones were all played by Hideaki Aomori, whom is a very accomplished and instrumentalist. I did note that you gave the album four stars, but from reading your your review, one would not know it. Even to say it is a great record would be an understatement.

  • Dan

    Great record! But a very negitive review?? I’m shocked at your rating? it’s almost like you got scared of what you wrote so you gave it 4 stars.
    So why such a high rating if you have nothing good to say about it??