Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Reviews music » Music Review: Queensrÿche – American Soldier

Music Review: Queensrÿche – American Soldier

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

It can't be easy being Queensrÿche. Whatever you do is always going to be compared to either the Operation: Mindcrime concept album or their finest release, Empire, from back in the olden days, and when you try something new like Hear In The Now Frontier, you get roundly castigated. Fairly, in that instance, because it was a bit rubbish. So what do you do? Well in Queensrÿches case, you bung out a dodgy covers album, then try (and fail) to recreate past glories with Operation: Mindcrime 2. However, no-one can ever accuse Queensrÿche of giving up easily, and so they're back for another bash, this time with a new concept album in the shape of American Soldier.

It's an album dedicated to the titular American soldier, and comes packed with true stories of the soldiers’ lives, replete with voice-overs and spoken passages, as Queensrÿche attempt to bring their tales to life. Vocalist Geoff Tate even went to the bother of researching and interviewing veterans, to try and gain a better understanding of what it's like to serve your country in battle. However, it's an attempt that fails quite dismally on the opening numbers "Sliver" and "Unafraid", two songs devoid of anything of note. Fortunately, I persevered, wisely it seems, and from "Hundred Mile Stare" onwards, it's almost as if an entirely different band had taken over, such is the increase in quality.

Now, I saw Queensrÿche live a couple of years back. They put in a tepid performance; the low point of which was vocalist Geoff Tate struggling to hit anything resembling a note. So, it is worth noting that this album sees an awful lot of "treated" vocals on display.  Don't come here looking for those grandiose operatic vocals of yore. However, in the context of the stories being told, with the aforementioned spoken word parts, it actually fits quite well. Musically, the band is still sticking to the basic prog-metal crossover that they've been peddling for two decades, but there seems to be a return of some of the passion of their youth in the performances.

Most of the material is dark and mid-paced, sombre and reflective. As it should be. And it's when they stick to that formula that it all works best, as it does on "If I Were King", "At 30,000 Ft" and, best of all, on "Home Again"; a song that takes its words from real letters between a frontline soldier and his wife, and which overcomes the cheese factor involved in Tate duetting with his 10 year old daughter. The other highlight sees them stepping into Michael Schenker Group, "Desert Song" territory on the fantastic "A Dead Man’s Words". Of course, some will say that they're simply revisiting their own Promised Land album, but I'm being charitable for a change.

In the main, this is a very good album and Queensrÿche are to be commended for making the effort to push forward their own musical vision. It doesn't all work, but in a world of small minds, it's nice to see that someone is still trying to reach out and grow.

Powered by

About Stuart A Hamilton

  • Vex

    I’ve not heard the album yet but I look forward to it. Just read an interview with Geoff Tate of Queensryche that was posted on Twitter. You might want to check it out cause he talks about the album.

  • Paul

    I thoroughly recommend anyone who likes interesting music to give this 5 or 6 listens as it’s an album that can really appeal and impress or will leave you indifferent or unengaged, but if you dig it you will be rewarded. It’s very rich. Opinions vary, especially with music, but fact is that Queensryche’s music is varied enough that one album may not appeal but the next could. I’m a fan but this is the first album I’ve recommended most music fans try. They don’t appeal to metal fans much, as they are not that any more. One note on the vocals. Tate is not what he was but after 30 years (10 of REAL throat punishing quality) can that be expected? He still sings stuff most can’t, and here pulls out some good stuff (just not all the time).

  • Bill Cosby

    I suprisingly liked this album even though I thought it would be quite the opposite. This album stands out compared to other major releases this year in my mind anyway. There are some weak moments noticeably 2 of the last 3 songs (Remember Me and Home Again), otherwise it is an excellent release musically. Spiritually, I believe this was an album that Geoff Tate wanted to dedicate to his family, most noticeably his father. The family overtone is further strengthened by the use of daughter Emily Tate on “Home Again”. She has no form of musical training and her performance isn’t all that great to begin with, but Geoff Tate felt the need to include her on the disc. The album is almost written entirely between Geoff Tate, producer Jason Slater, and engineer Kelly Gray. Drummer Scott Rockenfield co-contributes to 2 songs but is non-existent on the rest of the songwriting for the album. Those 2 tracks, Home Again and Middle of Hell, are purpotedly Slave to The System songs that we’re modified as Queensryche songs. Slave to the System is a side project/band that includes Rockenfield, Gray, and guitarist/singer Damon Johnson. Johnson and Gray both contributed guitars to the album as well.