Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Reviews music » Music Review: Bee Gees – 1st

Music Review: Bee Gees – 1st

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

T'was Matthew Sweet who first got me reconsidering the Brothers Gibb: covering one of the Aussie sibs' sixties hits, "Come to Me," with Under the Covers collaborator Susannah Hoffs, he had me listening to a song I hadn't thought about in years – and, in so doing, made me hear the pop craftiness that had gone into that particular 45.

"The Bee Gees don't get enough respect," Sweet went on to write in Cover's liner notes, and the guy had a point. These skilled concocters of wispy sixties pop-rock had largely been supplanted in public memory by the bell-bottomed disco dorks of the late seventies. To be sure, the boys themselves had helped to create this lamentable situation (cf., a 1979 Bee Gees Greatest collection that ignored the band's sixties output entirely), but other pop idols have attempted similar acts of pop revisionism without abandoning their past completely.

Fact is, in their youth, the Bee Gees could be about as sharp a group of sixties popsters as ever got a crowd of teen girls weeping en masse and rending their blouses. Perhaps it's their misfortune to've first come into prominence during a particularly fecund pop era; maybe it's just the dreaded Wimp Factor. But despite a slew of both keen and soggy Top 40 AM radio hits, the early Bee Gees catalog has long been criminally under-repped in the U.S. Thankfully, this situation is now being redressed by the pop addicts at Rhino Records, who late last year released a boxed set of deluxe editions of the first three Bee Gees' releases – and even more recently put out single packages of each one of these albums (1st, Horizontal and Idea) for those of us without the disposable income to buy a six-disc boxed set on spec.

Recently picked up the first of these releases, 1967's 1st, and I was surprised by how tunefully eclectic the darn thing was. In addition to its trio of Sensitive Guy hit singles (elegantly schlocky "Holiday," quiet desperation classic "New York Mining Disaster 1941" and the Motown-indebted "To Love Somebody," which would also be a British hit for Nina Simone), the album is a veritable fruit basket of sweet stuff: from the chamber psychedelia of "Red Chair, Fade Away" to the Moody Blues-driven chant-work of "Every Christian Lion Hearted Man Will Show You" to a surprisingly garage-stained nugget like "In My Own Time" (check out that "Taxman"-driven guitar), plus several risible slips of veddy veddy swingin' sixties whimsy ("Craise Finton Kirk Academy of Art," "Turn of the Century"). And for those who simply must have their unabashed Gibbian wimpiness, there's "One Minute Woman," which features Barry Gee getting down on his knees for a fickle and ungrateful lass.

So tell Matt Sweet the news: 1st is a prime piece of period pop-rockiness that deserves to be better appreciated. On more than one track I found myself thinking of the Hollies, another harmonic band of hitmakers who struggled to hold onto an audience as the seventies encroached and FM heaviness prevailed in the rock-and-pop universe. Perhaps I should've gotten out the coin jar and sprung for the full boxed set, after all?

Rhino's reissue contains two discs: first features 1st in both mono and stereo versions (my sound system's too crappy for me to be able to tell the dif); number two has the usual dee-luxe bells 'n' whistles: alternate takes of album tracks (e.g., a much more orchestrated version of the folk-rocky "Mining Disaster") plus some previously unreleased tracks (the most amusing of which is the lightly satirical "House of Lords"). The cuts sound more polished than the usual bonuses: even at their "roughest" the Singers Gibb maintain their engaging pop plasticity.

Final verdict: definitely worth respect.

Powered by

About Bill Sherman

Bill Sherman is a Books editor for Blogcritics. With his lovely wife Rebecca Fox, he has co-authored a light-hearted fat acceptance romance entitled Measure By Measure.
  • Mark Saleski

    nice review. it IS too bad that the Bee Gees seem to be known only for their disco-era output.

    i’ve been looking for these early reissue in the store to no avail. gotta get them soon.

  • http://oakhaus.blogspot.com Bill Sherman

    I picked up 1st at a locally-run Champaign, IL, record store, but I have seen copies of all three separate reissues at Best Buy . . .

    (And, of course, I’d be a Totally Bad Blogcritic if I didn’t remind the world at large that all three of these discs are available thru Amazon . . .)

  • Vern Halen

    To Love Somebody – as fine a gem as you’ll find in the 60’s pop hit single diamond mine – valuable enough to let you forgive them for the part they played in discofying the 70’s.

  • http://www.thesonginmyheadtoday.blogspot.com Holly Hughes

    I had this LP back in 1967, but I think it was absorbed into my brother’s record collection instead of mine somewhere along the way. It was a seriously fine record. I couldn’t believe these were the same guys when Saturday Night Fever came out, and I absolutely refused to give them any attention (though of course I found myself singing Stayin’ Alive whether I wanted to or not). “Holiday” in particular was a gem, just flirting with psychedelic effects while hewing pretty close to the folk-rock formula.

  • http://theBeeGees Evan

    the Bee Gees are much better then Hilary Duff i like jive talkin