Today on Blogcritics
Home » Movie Review: Brokeback Mountain

Movie Review: Brokeback Mountain

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

As I type these words, Brokeback Mountain just won four Golden Globe awards including Best Drama. It’s no surprise to a lot of people, even though the film itself was every bit a surprise.

BM_1Ennis Del Mar (Ledger) and Jack Twist (Gyllenhaal), both 19 years old, are two poor ranch hands from Riverton, Wyoming. They meet one summer while seeking jobs, and Joe Aguirre (Quaid) hires them to herd sheep up in Brokeback Mountain.

Ennis is a taciturn, reserved and shy man. Jack is a charmer, a dreamer, a risk-taker. Their difficult childhoods and shared interests quickly secure a bond between them. Then one cold night, their budding friendship turns into something else: a drunken, violent sexual encounter. The next day, neither of them speaks of the incident, until Ennis tells Jack, “What happened was a one shot deal. I ain’t queer.” Jack replies, “Me neither.”

BM_2When the summer is over, Ennis and Jack go their separate ways. Ennis marries his sweetheart Elma (Williams) and they raise two daughters. Jack marries wealthy girl Lureen (Hathaway) and has a son. Everything is normal until, after four long years, Ennis receives a postcard from Jack. Something deep inside stirs up a hornet’s nest. Their reunion becomes the beginning of a 20-year secret affair. Brokeback Mountain becomes their refuge from the world to which they don’t belong.

Ledger (Casanova) is extraordinary with his portrayal of Ennis Del Mar, a man who has few words in his vocabulary, a man so repressed that he doesn’t know how to express himself or go for what he wants. Ledger reveals so much about his characters, often without saying a word. His mannerism and facial expression speak volume. He’s transformed himself realistically into a man that is so unlike the actor himself, who has mostly been known for his fluffy, light performances in the past. In contrast, Gyllenhaal (Proof) has the more lively role. His Jack Twist is the opposite of Ennis in almost every way. Jack’s longing for the man he loves is evident in Gyllenhaal’s stellar performance. The men also share immense chemistry together. You believe they’re real. You believe their feelings for each other are real.

BM_3While one can argue that it’s a character study of two men and their relationship, the women in the story add an immense appeal to the film. Williams (The Station Agent) is amazing with her heartbreaking performance as Ennis’s long-suffering wife Alma. When she witnesses something about her husband that she doesn’t fully understand, her reaction is incredibly real and painful to watch. Hathaway (Havoc) has a relatively minor role as Jack’s indifferent wife Lureen. But her final scene is mesmerizing – Hathaway has matured into a fine actress.

BM_4Brokeback Mountain unfolds slowly and, under the direction of Lee (Hulk), the pacing is deliberate and leisurely. At more than two hours, the film feels slow sometimes, but it is far from being boring. While the plot is simplistic, the acting is exceptional and there is so much going on at the thematic and emotional levels that one can’t help but feel spellbound by the story.

The script by awarding-winning writers McMurtry (Terms of Endearment) and Ossana (Dead Man’s Walk) expands Proulx’s short story into a languid character study that holds on to your heart and doesn’t let go. The dialogue is real and to the point – nothing too poetic or out of character. Mostly episodic, there are many fine moments in the film that are emotionally raw and powerful. The ending will haunt you.

BM_5Lee’s direction is masterful, and it clearly demonstrates his versatility as a director. It’s even more impressive when you consider Lee’s heritage as a Chinese immigrant, and how he so deftly captures Americana in Brokeback Mountains. The cinematography by Rodgrigo Prieto (21 Grams) is breathtaking. The editing is crisp. Gustavo Santaolalla’s (Motorcycle Diaries) score is subdue but poignant.

[ADBLOCKHERE]Some say this is a “gay cowboy” movie. I say this is a story about love and betrayal and life. Homosexuality is only part of it – the heterosexual aspects of the story are just as strong. If you have ever loved and lost before, you will feel the impact of this story. The film is like fine wine – it delicately lingers on your palate and seeps into your vein. Brokeback Mountain is destined to become an American classic.

Stars: Heath Ledger, Jake Gyllenhaal, Randy Quaid, Anne Hathaway, Michelle Williams
Director: Ang Lee
Writers: Larry McMurtry, Diana Ossana (based on short story by E. Annie Proulx)
Distributor: Focus
MPAA Rating: R for sexuality, nudity, language and some violence
Running time: 134 minutes

Script – 9
Performance – 9
Direction – 8
Cinematography – 9
Music/Sound– 8
Editing – 8
Production – 9

Total Score – 8.7 out of 10

Powered by

About Ray Wong

  • Paint

    Most excellent Ray. I have put the script and CD on my Amazon wishlist. I can’t wait to see the movie. I love Annie Proulx–“Shipping News” is one of my all time favorite books and movie.

  • Ray

    Thanks, Paint. The soundtrack of Brokeback is impressive (I love the score he did for Motorcycle Diaries). I can’t wait to read Proulx’s short and compare it with the screenplay.

  • James

    Great review. I love this movie. It IS a classic.

  • Vince Chan

    Very nice review! I’m hoping maybe you can do a companion or follow up review of some of Ang Lee’s previous Hollywood endeavours.

    I’m sad that most people remember him for “The Hulk”. Everybody knows his Asian movies, but I doubt few have watched and judged his Western movie portfolio such as “The Ice Storm” starring heavyweights like Kevin Kline, Sigourney Weaver, Tobey Maguire, Chsitina Ricci, Elijah Wood and Katie Holmes.

    “Brokeback Mountains” is certainly redemption for an excellent director!

  • Ray

    Good idea. Thanks.

  • LangdonArt

    Watching daily Brokeback Mountain, I believe it to be my life and of others. As an artist painter, I aim to create more and more paintings with such panaramas. Would like also to have a second Brokeback Mountain film done with a happy ending this time, and am asking anyone interested to contact me… for such possibilities. Be happy also to share ideas, etc., of what you think about this film and what you would like in a next one. LangdonArt