Home / Culture and Society / Japan Openly Abuses Foreigner Rights

Japan Openly Abuses Foreigner Rights

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Back when I was a child watching old afternoon movies, I’d see a black and white World War II film where a Nazi soldier would say to the hero, “your papers, please.” This was used to promote tension as we waited to see if the fraudulent paperwork would allow the intrepid hero to pass the checkpoint and move on to freedom. The larger message, however, was that the times were such that people could not move freely without having their identity and purpose checked.

In Japan, foreigners are seeing a situation not unlike this unfold for them. In the past few months, there has been a surprising new sequence of rights violations targeted in an omnidirectional fashion at foreign residents. For decades, there have been targeted identification checks and scrutiny when it comes to bicycle theft leveled against foreign residents in Japan. If you are riding a bike in Tokyo, there’s a pretty good chance that you will be suspected of stealing your ride merely because of the look of your face and the color of your hair and eyes.

It is not the least bit unusual for the police to take down your bicycle’s serial number and check it against their list of stolen bikes. They do this to foreigners at whim. They only do it to Japanese people if their bicycles’ serial numbers have been removed or defaced so that they have reason to believe that someone is trying to cover up a theft.

The bicycle checks have been a long-standing part of the unwarranted scrutiny leveled at foreigners and are a minor nuisance. Though they are clearly racially motivated, they are non-invasive and brief. More troubling tides of change have been splashing about as of late. First, the Japanese parliament has recently voted changes in the foreign registration laws that require foreign residents to carry cards with a computer chip in them. If you do not have your card on you and it is requested by a person in authority, you will be fined up to $2,000 (200,000 yen). The cards will allow the Japanese government to encode a wide variety of biometric data and personal information about everything from tax payments to hair color in order to keep tabs on you.

These cards purportedly are being used to help ensure that foreigners in Japan integrate with the system. For instance, they want to be sure everyone is signed up for the socialized health insurance system and paying into the pension system. However, this is all smoke and mirrors for the truth. The truth is that the cards will allow the police to scan you and extract personal information at will. It’s also a way of getting more foreign residents to pay into systems from which they almost certainly will never be eligible to collect benefits. To collect from the Japanese pension system, you have to pay in for at least 25 years, or your government must have a reciprocal arrangement with the Japanese government. Very few countries have such arrangements and few foreigners remain in Japan for 25 years. Essentially, this is a way of having people pay into the struggling Japanese social services systems without collecting anything on the other end.

This new system had been proposed for Japanese citizens as well, but they roundly rejected being tracked in this manner. Many of them are currently avoiding payments into various social service systems (including the pension system) and they are no happier about biometric data being encoded into ID chips than we foreigners are. They don’t want their privacy compromised or to be opened up to identity theft. We don’t want it either, but we have no power to stop the Japanese government’s efforts to tighten the leash around our necks.

If this recently passed legislation is not a strong enough indication of the increasingly hostile posture of the Japanese government toward foreigners living and working in Japan, the fact that the police are now subjecting foreigners to random and unwarranted urinalysis to test for drug use shows that they have no respect for our rights as human beings. Foreign folks leaving nightclubs or simply looking “suspicious” in the eyes of the police are being asked to pee in a cup for no reason other than not being Japanese. Similarly, people are being asked to allow the police to check their bags for weapons or drugs in high traffic areas of Tokyo for absolutely no reason.

The police refuse to reveal what they will do if a person refuses, but Japan has no writ of habeas corpus and can hold “suspects” for up to 21 days without charge if they choose to do so. During that time, they can subject you to intense interrogation and deprive you of food, water, and sleep in order to coerce confessions.If they believe you refused to submit to illegal searches because you are guilty, they will certainly place such pressure upon you. There is a very strong sense that only the guilty refuse to cooperate in Japan. The notion of privacy rights is not nearly as strong here as it is in America. It is clearly illegal in Japan to conduct searches of any kind without a warrant, but given the liberal powers afforded the police, they can coerce you into agreeing to any sort of search. The mere threat of being hauled into jail for three weeks and being held simply for refusing to cooperate is very real.

The poor economy has fueled social difficulties in Japan such as random mass stabbings, increased drug use among Japanese college students, and tax revenue shortfalls. None of these problems have involved foreigners, but the police and the government have taken “measures” to correct the problems that mainly or entirely target foreigners. They clearly seek to give the appearance of solving these problems at the expense of the civil rights and liberties of those who are not Japanese.

Powered by

About Shari

  • Japan, If I remember correctly, is the country that forbde foreigners to enter for 3 centuries or so until the 1850’s.

    This is not th first article you have written about Japanes intolerance of foreigners and xenophobia. One from quite a while ago still generates comments, albeit of the stupidest kind…. It might be time to consider flipping the Japanese and their bigotry the bird, and finding a friendlier place to call home.

  • Glenn Contrarian

    Okay…now let’s look at the other side of the story.

    Back in 2000 I was in a three-day port visit in Sasebo, Japan – I was excited because that was the only time I’d ever had the chance to visit there.

    While I was on the American base in Sasebo (at the enlisted club called the ‘Triple Play’), my camera was stolen. Frankly, I wasn’t surprised – I’d taken my eyes off it for a couple and it was gone…and I knew that it was my fault for not keeping a closer eye on it.

    There’s a longstanding reputation about the way the Japanese viewed Americans at our military bases there – if there was a crime committed, they’d look at us first, and for good reason.

    This sounds prejudicial against us, but I saw the reason why in a one-day tour to Nagasaki.

    The first place we went was to a ‘Sea Tortoise Shell Shop’, a tourist trap where everything for sale was made out of sea tortoise shell. In the front display window was a clipper ship made completely out of sea tortoise shell, and its price was 10,000,000 yen – or about $100,000. I looked around – the store was on a side street, no night lights were evident, and there was no apparent alarm system on the window. That begged the question – just how long would this $100K item have stayed safe in a similar spot in America?

    Later I and two shipmates were trolling downtown looking for a place to eat. It was early afternoon and we were finding that many places were closed between lunch and dinner. The thing is, these restaurants didn’t lock their doors. We only found out they were closed when we’d walk inside and see no one – not even any employees to keep an eye on things.

    Yes, there’s corruption in Japan like anywhere else, and it will get worse as time goes on; and YES, they’ve got their own problems like those who deny the Rape of Nanking or their culpability in WWII, and YES the Japanese are perhaps the most racist first-world culture (which racism would be a good subject for a whole ‘nother article)…

    …but overall compared to America, it’s a FAR safer place, a far LESS corrupt place to live.

    And they’ve got a FAR better and cheaper (!) health care system – you know, that really evil socialistic communist fascist Universal Health Care (they go to the doctor on average three times as much as Americans do, and pay FAR less). Sorry…couldn’t resist.

    Sayonara for now!

  • Nick Kemp

    Japanese is a wonderful country with an amazing culture. It is very unfortunate that policy makers make it so hard for foreigners to live there and be treated equally. I lived their for 10 years and could never go back to living there.
    Now when I visit I will have my finger prints scanned and photo taken at the airport to be checked through a data base of “terrorists”. Japan has never had a terrorist attacked committed by a non-Japanese on its soil.