Home / It’s the policy, stupid

It’s the policy, stupid

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Hmm…let’s see. People the world over hate and fear America. Why is that? They seem to take issue with a preventive war doctrine that allows the U.S. to attack anybody it likes based on what it sees (or claims to see) in its crystal ball. They seem not to enjoy it when our President not only pulls out of international treaties but also makes a point of displaying utter contempt while he does it. And while the Bush Administration enthusiastically flouts international law, at the same time it cries foul when others break it.

And the rest of the world seems to have some kind of problem with that. I know–go figure.

So, obviously the cure for the low standing of the United States in world opinion is…a public relations campaign! Jack Tapper of Salon points out the cluelessness of the Bush Administration propaganda:

    When the State Department launched a propaganda TV campaign in the Arab and Muslim world last year, two of its Muslim-American stars were Rawia Ismail, a public school teacher born in Lebanon, and Abdul Hammuda, a bakery owner originally from Libya. Both live in Toledo, Ohio, and spoke lovingly of their adopted country in the ads, part of the “Shared Values Initiative.”

    “I wear a hijab in the classroom where I teach. I have never had any child that thought it was weird or anything like that,” Ismail says in the TV spot. “Islam in the United States could be followed just as well as I can follow it in my village where I was raised.” Adds Hammuda in the commercial: “Religious freedom here is something very important, and no one ever bothered us. Since 9/11, we’ve had an overwhelming sense of support from our customers and clients.”

    But Hammuda and Ismail, America’s goodwill ambassadors to the Arab world, have little good to say about the U.S. war with Iraq. “Everyone knew ahead of time that so many people were going to die, so no, I didn’t want it to happen,” Ismail tells Salon. While she opposes Saddam Hussein, she says the loss of life — whether of U.S. soldiers or Iraqis — was not worth the price. Through her satellite dish, she sees Arab news reports of the war: “All the locals and all the kids that died. And it hurts.”

    “I don’t think war was the answer,” seconds Hammuda, speaking on the phone while serving baklava to his customers. “America has to do more positive steps to build bridges. Now they say, ‘You guys don’t care about us, you’re just here to kill us and take our oil,’ especially since we haven’t found any weapons of mass destruction, any chemicals.”

    Asked if the negative opinion of the U.S. throughout the Muslim world is unfair, Hammuda says, “I had one view before the Iraq war. Now I have another.”

    However much they love their adopted country, neither Hammuda nor Ismail would probably make good spokespeople in the U.S.’s elaborate planned media campaign in Iraq. But their criticisms offer an insight into America’s image problem as officials at the White House and State Department try to sell the benefits of democracy to the Muslim and Arab world. The American instinct is to try to sell it like a brand. But that approach — maybe best captured by a frustrated Rep. Henry Hyde, R-Ill., who asked a House International Relations Committee panel on Oct. 10, 2001, “How is it that the country that invented Hollywood and Madison Avenue has such trouble promoting a positive image of itself overseas?” — misses the point. The problem isn’t that the United States is misunderstood; it’s that we’re understood quite well. Diplomacy can only be as effective as the policies it’s trying to sell — and there are some fundamental policy differences between America and the world that no spin can gloss over. By not acknowledging that, America’s international P.R. campaign hasn’t helped our image in the Middle East and elsewhere ? it may actually have hurt it.

Duh. TV shows aren’t gonna do it. It’s the policy, stupid.

Powered by

About Brian Flemming

  • SlackMFer

    Brian, i know you were quoting, but the fact that you chose to quote, “The problem isn’t that the United States is misunderstood; it’s that we’re understood quite well.” shows your true intentions. as i have said before, it’s seems to me that you are not simply voicing dissent about specific policies, but rather that you dislike our system in general. otherwise, why would you choose to quote that the rest of the world, that according to you, hates us, is right on the money??

  • In the rest of the world, “United States foreign policy” is equal to “the United States.”

    However, “United States foreign policy” is not equal to “our system in general.”

    If I had a problem with “our system in general,” I would have written, “I have a problem with our system in general.”

    But I don’t have a problem with our system in general. In fact, between now and the next election, I will be using our system in general to oust a dangerous President who has given the world such good reason to hate the United States of America.

  • SlackMFer

    yeah, because 9/11 was a direct result of Bush. oh yeah, so was the USS Cole,’93 WTC bombing and the attacks on our African embasies. those were because they KNEW bush was gonna be elected eventually.

    people hated us a long time before bush took office, and if they fear us now? GOOD!! it’s about goddam time the rest of the world knows were not gonna respond to their attacks with half-hearted Clinton missle attacks that were aimed at taking attention away from his numerous scandals. just look at that north korea nut. after iraq he’s singin’ a different tune and the rest of the world that “hates” us better follow his lead.

  • SlackMFer

    OK, now he’s bragging about his nukes, so i take that back, we better go kick his ass now.

  • jadester

    this is why there is so much hassle in the world. Violence just causes more violence.