As I was preparing to expose one of the big fish in this green energy scheme –– how General Electric has raked in at least $3 billion of President Obama’s “green” stimulus money –– two more government-backed renewable energy projects made headlines. Abound Solar went bust and it seems that Nevada Geothermal Power is going down the drain, both included in the Department of Energy’s excessively risky loan portfolio, adding more embarrassment to the president’s “highly touted green energy initiative.”
Last April, I began to unleash years of research starting with the “Department of Energy “Junk Loans” and Cronyism, Introduction,” setting up the first in a series of at least five topics that will prove cronyism and corruption are the driving forces behind President’s Obama’s green energy agenda, with total disregard for our economy and national debt.
As a recap: the March 2012 House Oversight Investigation revealed that 23 of 27 recipients of the loan guarantees were rated as junk status investments. And according to GAO statistics (and emphasized in the June 19th Congressional hearing), “For the 460 applications to the Loan Guarantee Program (LGP), DOE has made loan guarantees for 7 percent and committed to an additional 2 percent.”
And who were the “lucky” 7 percent? Of the 27 loans issued (26 as BrightSource was counted twice in the House Oversight report) through the 1705 LGP to 21 firms, virtually all of them have meaningful political connections (bundlers, donors, supporters) –– to either President Obama or other high-ranking Democrats — or both!
To add insult to “taxpayer injury,” in that same June 19th House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Hearing, Dr. De Rugy (a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University), had some pretty damning testimony, including how the DOE justifies the 1705 Loan Guarantee Program. She even disputed the DOE’s argument that “by investing in green technology, it would create up to 5 million green jobs.” When in reality, De Rugy continues, “the DOE’s own data shows that $16 billion in loans were guaranteed [under the 1705 LGP], and 2378 permanent green jobs were created” –– “that means that for every $6.7 million in taxpayer exposure, ONE job was created!”
Keep in mind that 1705 LGP is not the only DOE loan program to be analyzed –– there are three, and since 2009, the DOE has guaranteed a total of $34.7 billion. As you will see, there are also other government agencies and programs doling out billions more in “green” funds.
General Electric, CEO Jeffrey Immelt, Chair of Obama’s Job Council and the Billions They Raked in Through the 2009 Obama Stimulus Package
Whereas General Electric (GE) is a heavy donor to both Republicans and Democrats, and Immelt himself “plays the role of typical corporate donor who hedges his bets on both sides of the fence,” in 2008, GE gave the Obama campaign $529,855, marking them a top Obama donor. Nevertheless, GE is a major player on the clean-energy scene as well as in this green energy scheme. Even The New York Times recognized GE’s “green power,” noting that in 2009, GE lobbied Congress to help expand the “clean-energy subsidy programs, and it now profits from every aspect of the boom in renewable-power plant construction,” including “hundreds of millions in contracts to sell its turbines to wind plants built with public subsidies.” In fact, you’ll be “blown away” by the billions of “wind energy grants” that blew out of the stimulus package back in February 2010, of which GE is contracted to at least 26% of them as the “Turbine Manufacturer.”
In late 2009, it was reported that GE became “one of the newer smart meter players,” and that they “had been working with utility Oklahoma Gas & Electric on a 6,600 smart meter trial, and had procured “a contract with Pepco Holdings (PHI),” which received Smart Grid Investment Grants totaling $168 million. GE also has a big contract with Florida Power and Light,” also the recipient of a $200 million stimulus grant.
Yet, this is just the beginning of the GE “green bucks”…
While a recent “news flash” was published by the Republican National Committee, confirming via Recovery.gov that “General Electric received over $1.2 billion worth of stimulus loan guarantees, awards, contracts and grants” (the majority of which were for renewable energy projects), they missed billions more. Two large 1705 loan guarantees that I had outlined in April of this year, as well as a forthcoming $490 million cash grant and a $54.6 million loan from the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA). Add in some smaller government subsidies and awards for a multitude of green projects, programs, and through some of their “green alliances,” that I found during my 2011 research, and GE’s “green tab” exceeds $3 billion in direct (some indirectly) taxpayer cash, and counting. ;
Let’s take a look at GE’s two projects from the 1705 Loan Guarantee Program, both of which are included the DOE’s risky investment portfolio.
- 1366 Technologies Inc, Rating B by Fitch, Sept 2011 –– $150 million
- Caithness Shepherds Flat, LLC –– Rating BBB- by Fitch; Oct 2010 for $1.04 billion (or $1.3 billion)
GE sponsored the Caithness Shepherds Flat, and also supplied the project with 338 wind-turbines. On top of the $1.3 billion loan, the Caithness project is set to receive a cash grant of $490 million from the Treasury Department once those turbines start turning.
Later, another close associate of, and big donor to the president invested in Caithness. As uncovered by Peter Schweizer in his book, Throw Them All Out, “Google’s CEO at the time, Eric Schmidt, served as an informal advisor to President Obama.” Still, Schmidt, Google Executive Chairman, was an Obama donor in 2008, and since April 2009, is a member of the president’s Science and Technology Advisory Council (PCAST). Interestingly, Google’s $814,540 contribution to Obama’s campaign made it the fifth largest donor in 2008. As of late, Google has aimed its “search engines” at green technology, many of which have received government “help” –– BrightSource, Solar City, Telsa Motors, and others, but we’ll stay focused on GE.
The House Oversight, March 2012 investigation reveals internal memos of concern over the fact that the Caithness Shepherds Flat project was receiving “an excessive amount of public subsidy (where grants, tax credits and loan guarantees provided 65% of the funding for the project), and that private parties did not have sufficient ‘skin in the game.’”
Further, it goes on to state, “Four months after the DOE approved the Caithness loan, President Obama named Jeff Immelt, the CEO of GE, as the Chairman of Obama’s Job Council” –– a council stacked with Democratic donors, and several Obama bundlers, both for the 2008 and 2012 campaigns.
It also discloses “General Electric’s broad access to loan guarantees,” and it gives a very illuminating account. “Since Immelt’s appointment as Chair of the Job Council, two additional government-backed transactions have occurred.” “First the poorly rated 1366 Technologies, sponsored in part by GE, received a direct $150 million loan commitment from the DOE for its solar manufacturing plant.” Second was the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) that loaned $54.6 million to Kansas City Southern Railway Company (KCSR) “to purchase thirty new General Electric ES44AC diesel-electric locomotives” –– a loan that raised red flags in the House investigation.
President Obama’s Job Council
However, Immelts’ “special entrée” to the White House started two years prior to that February 2011 “Job Czar” position, as a member of President Obama’s 2009 Economic Recovery Advisory Board (PERAB). Besides Immelt’s direct access to President Obama since 2009, GE was privy to Valerie Jarrett’s September 2009 “Clean Energy Summit,” where an array of attendees just so happened to “collectively strike gold” with over $5.3 billion in taxpayer funds from the Obama stimulus.
What’s more is that GE personnel sit on the DOE’s Electricity Advisory Committee (EAC) of which “recommendations” from their 2008 and 2009 reports made its way into “the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 and are being implemented in DOE policies and programs under the Obama administration.” Others on the EAC roster that were given DOE “green money” are American Electric Power (AEP), Austin Energy, NextEra Energy, CenterPoint Energy, to name a few.
As luck would have it, I’ve tracked at least five members of President Obama’s Job Council that are connected to firms that have cashed in on the green energyspending spree. Besides Immelt, winners include John Doerr partner at Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, Lewis Hay chairman and chief executive officer of NextEra Energy, Inc., Richard Parsons Chairman of the Board of Citigroup, Inc., and Penny Pritzker (also from the PERAB), whom wears many liberal hats, including a prominent position on Obama’s 2008 National Finance Committee.
As for billionaire Doerr, he too served on the PERAB, and in early 2009 extended his influence with Obama’s transition team and leaders in Congress, ultimately shaping what went into the energy section of the 2009 economic stimulus package. Doerr is another big winner of government clean-energy funds through his venture capital firm Kleiner Perkins, where Al Gore is also a partner. Doerr and Gore strenuously campaigned for candidate Obama, including financial donations, and in February 2011, Doerr even hosted a lavish high-profiled “tech-exec dinner” for the president, and these days, is considered “a very big-ticket Obama donor.”
Kleiner Perkins is a firm that I began to unravel in 2010, stressing that over 50 percent of their Greentech Portfolio secured all kinds of loans, grants, and special tax breaks –– placing them in an “elite green society;” yet it’s a firm to eventually revisit, because since 2010, they have tripled their “investments” and there is much more to expose.
In a twist of fate, Richard Parsons, is connected to SolarReserve and their $737 million DOE “non-investment” grade loan, of which was covered by my new ally, Marita K. Noon, Executive Director of Energy Makes America Great and columnist at Townhall.com. As I attempt to cover the entire DOE “junk bond” Portfolio, together we will be tackling the Special Seven –– those that are not only part of the DOE’s risky investments, but received millions (if not billions) from the 1603 Grant Program, both programs created by the Obama administration through the 2009 stimulus package.
It’s gonna be an hot summer…
Jeffrey Immelt and the American Energy Innovation Council
2010 was a busy year for GE –– their Energy Portfolio hit $6 billion, doubling the amount it held in 2008, and Immelt formed American Energy Innovation Council (AEIC), and called for “a tripling of U.S. federal energy research budget,” a direction the president has been taking. Coincidently, this group consists of two Obama Job Council members, John Doerr and Ursula Burns, the chairman and chief executive officer of Xerox Corporation, another one that helped fill Obama‘s 2008 campaign coffers.
Additionally, principals of AEIC include Microsoft tycoon Bill Gates (along with other business bigwigs), another carbon tax pusher in cahoots with Secretary Chu, and an investor in Sapphire Energy that received a $54.4 million loan guarantee from the Department of Agriculture and $50 million grant from the DOE.
Topping the AEIC is Chad Holiday, the Chairman of the Board at Bank of America. Besides the fact that Bank of America/Merrill Lynch were both “top Obama contributors from 2003 to 2008,” they also, along with NRG Energy, are investors in the San Francisco-based Prologis project that in June of 2011 secured a $1.4 billion DOE loan guarantee, which was considered non-investment grade. It’s no surprise that Big Banks are not immune to the green corruption scandal, and there is much to say on that matter, yet we’ll save that for later.
Nevertheless, in Schweizer’s book –– a must read by the way, naming a lengthy list of “Obama Contributors and the Stimulus Scandal” (yet, I’ve found more) –– Sapphire Energy has another Democrat tie, ARCH Venture Partners is a major investor, and Bob Nelson, the founding partner, served on President Obama’s National Finance Committee during the 2008 campaign. However it’s worth noting that Schweizer divulges that at least ten members are connected to companies that received billions of green energy money.
Obama’s 2008 National Finance Committee
- Bruce Heyman (Goldman Sachs): Gogentrix ($90 million –– Colorado), First Solar ($4.7 billion –– California), and U.S. Geothermal (96.8 million –– Oregon)
- David Heller (Goldman Sachs): Gogentrix, First Solar, and U.S. Geothermal
- Ian Cumming: Leucadia ($260 million –– Louisiana, $1.6 billion –– Indiana, and $1.6 billion –– Illinois)
- Frank M. Clark and John Rogers: Peco Energy ($200 million –– Pennsylvania)
- Daniel Weiss and Zeb Rice: Power Span ($100 million –– N. Dakota)
- Bob Nelson: Sapphire Energy ($135 million –– New Mexico)
- Louis Susman: Solar Trust of America ($2.1 billion –– California)
- Steve Westly: Telsa, EdenIq, RecycleBank, and Amyris Biotechnologies, however, there is much more to tell about the “Green bundler with the golden touch” in another series.
General Electric Lobbying Power and “Green Alliances”: United States Climate Action Partnership, Advanced Metering Partners, Energy Technology Ventures, and Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) pilot program
GE also used lobbying power to “green” their pockets. According to OpenSecrets.org, in December 2010, Immelt was part of an “Obama Business Summit,” noting that GE had spent more than $32 million on lobbying, ranking them as the number three lobbying spender of 2010. Moreover, GE was extremely active in lobbying the 2009 economic stimulus package –– the “number one lobbied” piece of legislation since 2005.
In addition, GE is part of the United States Climate Action Partnership (USCAP), a cap-and-trade lobbying group comprised of more politically connected big “green” money winners –– AES, Duke Energy, Exelon Corp, NextEra Energy, NRG Energy, and PG&E, some of which GE is in cahoots with.
While cap-and-trade has yet to become law, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), along with Administrator Lisa Jackson and her “environmental justice” mantra , has been on a regulatory rampage. As of late, the EPA issued the First Carbon Pollution Standard, an extremely relevant area because the Obama administration’s energy policies will ensure that GE and many of these well-connected green firms, and their investors, gain more wealth at the expense of our economy and all Americans.
Not only is GE active in clean-energy advocacy and lobbying, they have joined forces with others that have benefited from Obama’s alternative-energy taxpayer funds. Two in particular –– the Advanced Metering Partners, another John Doerr “venture” via Silver Spring Networks, as well as Energy Technology Ventures formed in 2011 with NRG Energy and ConocoPhillips.
Silver Spring Networks is one of Kleiner Perkins shining green companies, and they cashed in big time in 2009, when the DOE starting handing out $4 billion in Smart Grid grants, while NRG Energy –– also found in the House investigation –– is another politically connected energy company. As Schweizer’s Throw Them All Out book reveals, billionaire George Soros (another 2008 Obama donor), “gave advice and direction on how President Obama should allocate so-called stimulus money,” and then went on a “stock buying spree in companies that ultimately benefited from the federal stimulus,” including NRG Energy.
Moreover, who benefits [the most] from the DOE’s Loan Guarantee Program? “The recipient of the most 1705 loans was NRG Energy Inc., which received $3.8 billion (23.7 percent of the overall amount guaranteed under the 1705). Overall, just four companies received 64 percent, or $10.3 billion, of the total amount guaranteed under the 1705 program,” states Veronique de Rugy’s June 19, 2012 assessment and subsequent testimony, mentioned earlier in this article. However, there is much more astonishing data worthy of attention, but at a later time.
Meanwhile Energy Technology Ventures has its own energy tech portfolio, of which in 2009, Foro Energy “received one of the largest of the Department of Energy’s coveted ARPA-E grants with $9.1 million.” Amongst others that stand out besides 1366 Technologies, is Hara, “a company that sells software to help businesses measure and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions,” which is not only another Doerr investment (profiled in my 2010 Green Corruption series), but like many of these green firms, their massive payoff will come once mandates and regulations –– like cap-and-trade or a carbon tax –– are in place.
Further in 2009, Silver Spring Networks and GE joined forces with ComEd, a subsidiary of Chicago-based Exelon Corp., for the Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) pilot program. In October 2009, ComEd was up for a $5 million DOE stimulus grant, and had applied for $175 million in ARRA federal stimulus for their AMI pilot project. It was confirmed that the AMI project was “initially funded by [the] $5 million DOE stimulus grant” and that additional federal funding was also received; yet the exact amount is unknown at this time.
Besides Exelon making it on that “top Obama contributors list,” in August of 2011, they were the recipient of a $656 million loan for the Antelope Valley Solar Ranch, one of the non-investment grade loans listed in the House investigation. It must be a Chicago thing, because as of July 2011, Frank Clark then CEO of the ComEd unit (their chief state lobbyist) had raised between $50,000 and $100,000 for President Obama and the DNC for 2012, marking Mr. Clark as an Obama bundler for both campaigns. However there is an even more complex Obama, Exelon story to share that includes Clark, Exelon CEO John Rowe as well as other high-profiled Democrats –– Obama’s former chief of staff, Rahm Emanuel and chief political strategist, David Axelrod –– uh, and more stimulus money. But again, I digress…
More GE “Green” Awards
Now, if you spend some time at energy.gov or snooping around any of the energy-trade magazines and news, you’ll find more taxpayer funded GE “green awards.” However, with a team of investigators, I’m confident much more would be discovered.
- June 2010: South Carolina Recovery Act Memo –– “General Electric Gas Turbines, LLC, based in Greenville, was awarded a clean energy tax credit for $26.9 million to manufacture heavy-duty gas turbines.”
- July 16, 2009: “DOE Announces Nearly $14 Million to go to 28 New Wind Energy Projects, including $12.8 million in Recovery Act funds” and General Electric’s Wind Turbine Manufacturing Process Monitoring (Niskayuna, NY) was awarded $697,769.
- July 20, 2010: “DOE Announces $30 Million for Energy-Efficient Housing
Partnerships…and the following is a brief description of the selected teams, of which will each receive between $500,000 and $2.5 million depending on their performance.” General Electric is on the Building Industry Research Alliance (BIRA) team.
- July 29, 2009: “DOE Announces Awards for up to $11 Million for New Solar Energy Grid Integration Systems (PVPowered will partner with Portland General Electric),” and the DOE cost share is up to $3 million.
- October 2010: “Department of Energy Announces Third Grant for U.S.-China Clean Energy Research Center,” whereas “$12.5 million will be given over the next five years to lead a consortium on energy-efficient building technologies under the U.S.-China Clean Energy Research Center (CERC),” of which GE is part of.
- August 2011: GE won $1.3 million DOE funding for Carbon Capture R&D
- December 2011: GE won $10 million in DOE funding for a smart grid project in the town of Lessburg Florida
- December 2011: GE Global Research in Niskayna, New York was awarded $1.36 million grant to improve the efficiency of EV’s
- And so on…
Yep, GE is making bank off “green” –– over $3 billion, and counting, adding them to that “elite green society,” along with some of their co-conspirators and cohorts like NRG Energy, Kleiner Perkins, The Westly Group, Google, VantagePoint Ventures, Goldman Sachs, Big Oil, Big Banks, and others.
Moreover, as this scandal is unfolded, GE can also be placed into two more categories: “Five Obama Job Council Members” as wells as those “Stimulus Authors” that have cashed in on the president’s “green” agenda, including the $800 billion stimulus package where over ten percent –– $80 billion taxpayer dollars –– was earmarked for renewable energy, which was meant to stimulate the economy and create jobs.
However, it is only stimulating the pockets of President Obama and high-ranking Democrat cronies. Oh, as for “those jobs”…that’s another story. Still, those invited to this “green” table are the ultra-rich willing to “pay to play,” even catapulting them into more wealth, while we the taxpayers are only allowed to pay the tab. That should anger all Americans.