Today on Blogcritics
Home » Futon Report: Biggio’s new record probably stings a bit

Futon Report: Biggio’s new record probably stings a bit

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Don’t rub it. It’ll sting more.

Craig Biggio has heard that from commentators for 268 times, the most recent time being Wednesday when he was hit by a Byung-Hyun Kim pitch on the elbow.

Biggio is known for his arm brace to catch a few extra balls. But he’s a great hitter and now that arm brace that caught HBP #268 will go to the Hall of Fame, for that pitch broke the modern-era record for being hit the most times by a pitch in a career. The previous record of 267 was set by Don Baylor two decades ago. The overall record has yet to be broken, which is 287 held by Hall of Famer Hughie Jennings, who played from 1891-1918, and was last hit by a ball in 1903.

’88-’94: 3808 plate appearances, 36 HBP = once about every 106 AB
’95-’05: 7188 plate appearances, 232 HBP = once about every 31 AB

What happened between ’94 and ’95? The baseball strike. Clearly this had a direct impact on Biggio getting hit more. The pitchers were upset over not working for a few months and took it out on the Astro second baseman.

Or not.

Biggio’s average and power numbers also went up starting in the ’95 season.

You gotta hand it to the man. It’s even more believable that he’s taken all those hits, and yet he’s only been on the DL once his entire career. He’s also stayed with the same team his entire 17-year career, an active record.

He was a good sport when Jeff Kent came into town, so he moved from second base and played center field for a season and a half. He even moved to left field in 2004 when they traded for Carlos Beltran in midseason. And with both gone, he’s back at second base. Many other players would have demanded a trade, but Biggio stuck with Houston and has gained the respect of many baseball purists for it.

WILL HIS RECORD STAND?

As he continues on his “quest” to be hit by #288, is his record safe?

Besides Biggio, seven other players have been plunked at least 100 times. Of those, Oakland catcher Jason Kendall is the youngest and has the most at 177 HBPs and 31 years old. On average, he gets hit about 20 times a year. If he plays eight more years, he will be as old as Biggio is currently and just might surpass 300 HBPs. But if Biggio plays a couple more years, he may eclipse the 300 mark as well.

Not exactly A-Rod chasing Hank, but it’s something to watch out for in eight years.

IS BIGGIO A HALL OF FAMER?

HBP record aside, there’s a good case for and against.

For: Should reach 3,000 hits by 2007. Over 4,000 times on base. Six All-Star appearances. Four Gold Gloves. Only been on the DL once. Has played full seasons as a catcher, infielder and outfielder. When he gets 13 more doubles, he will reach 600, making him only one of five players with 600 doubles and 400 stolen bases (Tris Speaker, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner and Paul Molitor). On base average (.372) is about average for HOFers.

Against: Never in the top 3 of MVP. Career .286 hitter, only four seasons were above .300. 1,500 strikeouts; only two HOFers have 1,500+ strikeouts and fewer than 450 homers (Lou Brock and Tony Perez) and Biggio — with 244 — has far less homers than either them. Less than a career .200 postseason average*, never played in a World Series and probably never will.

Biggio might want to call Jim Rice and ask what it feels like to be a candidate on the fence with the hearts of future ballot voters.

*EDIT: Changed from “Less than a career .200 average.”

Powered by

About Suss

  • http://selfaudit.blogspot.com Aaman

    That caption is too long – spoils the formatting

  • http://sussfr.blogspot.com Matthew T. Sussman

    For some reason I can’t use tables on BC posts. Works fine on my blog though.

    Futon Report

  • http://www.docofdiets.com dietdoc

    Matt, good assessment and information. I am a fan of Biggio and Bagwell as I do believe that they play baseball the “old school way.” As for the HOF, I doubt whether he or Bags will make it. And, in some ways, that is sad – neither is flashy or attention-getting or headline-grabbing enough, probably. But they do play hard, every day and have been steady and very productive.

    Biggio is a good, solid ball player and his record will stand. No one of the next generation would get hit that much and do it for the team.

    Cheers,

    Ron

  • http://spaces.msn.com/members/dorksandlosers Tan The Man

    Sorry, I have to disagree with dietdoc, I think both Biggio and Bags will make the HOF. Biggio probably won’t be a first ballot-but he’ll eventually make it. He’s one of the most underrated second basemen ever. As for Bags, he’s been playing with an arthritic shoulder for the past 5 seasons, and it’s amazing that’s played this long. He’s almost to 500 hrs and if you take his averages before 1998, you’d have a HOFer no contest. But count the shoulder and his fortitude, and you’ll still have a HOFer. Although they are both very underrated players, the voters will notice them and should.

  • http://www.docofdiets.com dietdoc

    Tan the Man, I hope you are right, truly. They both deserve to be HOF’ers. But, as we well know, that has little to do with the ballot box.

    Come to think of it, often that is so true of life in general…

    [Turning off the “waxing philosophical” old-man switch]

    Cheers,

    Ron