Today on Blogcritics
Home » DVD Review: V for Vendetta

DVD Review: V for Vendetta

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Scathing political views, a guy in a mask, a few pieces of pyrotechnic work, a bald Natalie Portman, and one evil government later, V for Vendetta comes to a close. You'll either leave enlightened by someone else's views or wonder why you wasted the time. This graphic-novel based yawner falls flat since it's not an original concept and the main character is lifeless.

It's hard to act behind a mask and Hugo Weaving does what he can behind the smiling face of V. This masked madman has had enough of an oppressive government, and decides to dismantle it one person at a time. The focus is certainly split between V and the government trying to stop him, neither bringing much to the film.

To say the film has a message is an understatement, one that boils down to a typical cliché-ridden "government = bad/people = free." It stuffs that message into the viewer as often as possible, also dabbling in corruption and a manipulative media. It's been done countless times before, leaving V himself as the only original concept in the film.

Weaving, also known for playing a few thousand characters in the Matrix series as Agent Smith, plays an enthusiastic V. Dialogue is sharp, meaningful, and entertaining. His early speech, using almost nothing but words that start with the letter V, is priceless, and leads into the character's sometimes on, sometimes off sanity.

Sadly, it doesn't amount to much as a predictable ending finishes things off in a blaze. A few fight scenes offer some nice style, gore, and choreography, though that's one of the minor highlights. Natalie Portman plays a regular citizen slowly and violently brought over to V's side with only a little flair.

If tyrannical governments are a fixture of your movie watching, you can view numerous other Hollywood efforts like the upcoming Logan's Run remake, Soylent Green, or, of course, Nineteen Eighty Four. V for Vendetta adds little to the genre aside from a slight super hero angle and extensive preaching. Fiction movies are about entertainment, not constant political bashing.

Surprisingly, this is an awful DVD transfer. Film grain is worse here than it is in some movies 30 years old. Flat colored backdrops compound this issue with compression artifacts. There is some decent focus on details, flesh tones come together nicely, and black levels are perfect. The grain, however, mutes any positives.

Thankfully, the audio picks things up. With two major sequences involving heavy explosions, the full effect of 5.1 audio comes through. Small pieces of destroyed structures find their way into every channel and bass provides a powerful kick. Fight scenes showcase subtle audio, and dialogue is mixed nicely as not to be overpowered.

A two-disc edition of the film is available, though the version reviewed is a single disc affair. The sole feature is "Freedom! Forever!" It's a 15-minute making-of piece that is surprisingly deep, discussing the novels, the proper way to bring them to the screen, adjustments, the politics, and the characters. Fans of extras should obviously veer past this disc and go straight for the double disc collection.

V's rant early in the film, when he first discovers Natalie Portman's character, contains 55 different uses of "V" words. It was intentional, given the film's other references to the number five. If you sit there and count them though, you should probably start looking for better ways to spend your time.

Powered by

About Matt Paprocki

Matt Paprocki has critiqued home media and video games for 13 years and is the reviews editor for Pulp365.com. His current passion project is the technically minded DoBlu.com. You can read Matt's body of work via his personal WordPress blog, and follow him on Twitter @Matt_Paprocki.
  • http://www.breakingwindows.com/ Ken Edwards

    You clearly missed the point of this wonderful movie — the message of the film is not “government = bad.” Try “don’t follow blind faith.”

    I am beginning to question your judgement Matt, really. *shakes head*

    V is an excellent thrill ride, with great acting by hoth Weaving and Portman.

    Weaving acted quite well with only a mask, but I get the feeling you could not get past the fact that he never took it off.

    The features on the second disc make it worth picking it up. Great stuff there.

    We need to see more graphic novels turned into movies like V, and most recently, Batman Begins and of course Sin City.

    You should more closely consider the source material. While the movie might have just came out, the novels were written in the early 80s. Britain was quite different then.

    Was V political? Yes. Was it over-the-top shove-it-down-your-throat? Not when considering the source novels.

    But even without the knowledge of the original writings, the movie stands quite well on its own.

  • http://www.breakingwindows.com Matt Paprocki

    “Weaving acted quite well with only a mask, but I get the feeling you could not get past the fact that he never took it off”

    Loved it. How many movies like this do you get that ‘slow reveal’ as the hero finally reveals himself? It’s about time someone changed that up.

    “You should more closely consider the source material.”

    Hell no. There should be no reason to read the novel(s). The movie should stand completely on its own. If it doesn’t, it fails.

    “Not when considering the source novels.”

    Nuff said. It’s not ok to shove the message as often as possible because the books did it. If the graphic novels were this bad, I would have hated them too. I watch movies to be entertained, not to be preached at.

  • JonnyO2

    I just want to second the bad DVD transfer… A low contrast, bluish tint bugged me in a bunch of the scenes (rooftop scene at the beginning – Nat and Hugo look very obviously “pasted” in.)

  • http://www.breakingwindows.com Matt Paprocki

    Well, the “pasted in” look is a special effects thing/flaw, not the transfers fault.