Today on Blogcritics
Home » DVD Review: His Girl Friday

DVD Review: His Girl Friday

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Perhaps the fastest-paced comedy ever made, Howard Hawks’ His Girl Friday is often credited with being the first film to use overlapping dialogue, but is best known for the machine-gun rapport between its two leads. Rosalind Russell stars as Hildy Johnson, ex-wife and former ace reporter of newspaper editor Walter Burns (Cary Grant), who’s come back to inform him that she’s marrying insurance salesman Bruce Baldwin (Ralph Bellamy) and moving – to Albany. Burns uses every trick at his disposal to keep Bruce in and out of jail and Hildy on the story of a murderer scheduled to hang in the morning. This is one of the best comedies you’ll ever see.

Although he is in retrospect listed as one of the elite directors in the history of cinema, Howard Hawks was largely ignored, or at the very least taken for granted, by his peers. His resume is one of the most prolific of all time, yet he was only nominated for one Oscar (for 1941’s Sergeant York) and three Director’s Guild Awards. According to the Internet Movie Database, the only major award he ever received was a Honorary Oscar in 1974. This is the man who started in silent films, directed the original Scarface (1932), had a career that spanned nearly fifty years, and did an uncredited rewrite on The French Connection (1971), but here he shows a deft comic touch.

Hawks encouraged his actors to ad-lib and improvise and set a frenetic pace to match the natural rhythms of both the dialogue and the newspaper world it reflected. The shots are simple, with very little editing — essential in preserving the fluidity of the scenes. The breakneck speed of the dialogue is enough to hold the audience, and the amount of editing required to film the conversations in anything other than a master shot would be distracting, so Hawks doesn’t try to force anything. He’s smart enough to put the camera on a tripod and let his actors go.

Of course, it helps to have Cary Grant at his devious best. He’s a fast-talking, conniving, egotistical, selfish bastard and no one could have played it better. This is a role he was born to play. You don’t trust him – you’d have to be foolish to – but you sure do like him a lot and he sure is convincing and in a position like that of newspaper editor, he’s more than willing to throw his considerable weight in any direction necessary to get the story. That includes getting Bruce arrested three different times in the span of a couple of hours on trumped-up charges and hiding a convicted murderer in a desk for the sole purpose of scooping his rivals.

Ralph Bellamy’s Bruce is the polar opposite. He’s a naive salesman from Albany. Clearly he hasn’t a clue what’s going on. He’s continually flabbergasted when he ends up in jail. Between this and The Awful Truth (1937), we see how Hollywood has typecast Bellamy as a well-meaning hick, dependable and dull[1]. The film even makes sly mention of this when Cary Grant, in a moment of frustration says he “looks like that film actor, Ralph Bellamy”.

Rosalind Russell has the difficult task of going toe to toe with Grant, and she’s more than up to it. She manages to strike that balance between the tough newspaperman and the compassionate female. It’s a fine performance all around. She understands this world of reporting — lives for it, actually — and while she’s able to convince Bruce that she wants to settle down, and possibly even convinces herself for a time, her fellow reporters don’t buy it, and neither do we. It’s obvious this is where she belongs. One of the reporters lays three-to-one odds that the marriage won’t last three months, but no one will take the bet. Nor would we. The only person who might is Bruce, but he’s in jail for stealing a watch.


Starring: Cary Grant, Rosalind Russell, Ralph Bellamy, and Abner Biberman
Written by: Charles Lederer, based on the play by Ben Hecht & Charles MacArthur
Directed by: Howard Hawks
NR, 92 min, 1940, USA

[1] To his credit, Bellamy would later subvert this trend and show a great deal of range. He won the 1958 Tony Award for Best Dramatic Actor and worked steadily until 1990’s Pretty Woman, his final film.

Powered by

About Lucas McNelly

  • http://nicholasstixuncensored.blogspot.com/ Nicholas Stix

    That includes getting Bruce arrested three different times in the span of a couple of hours on trumped-up charges and hiding a convicted murderer in a desk for the sole purpose of scooping his rivals….

    The only person who might is Bruce, but he’s in jail for stealing a watch.

    Giving away so much of the story detracts from the viewer’s pleasure. If you are going to do that, you need to give a “spoilers” warning from the get-go.

  • http://lmcnelly15.blogspot.com Lucas McNelly

    i worry very little about giving away spoilers in 66-year-old comedies.

    hell, it barely qualifies as a spoiler.

  • http://bacalar.blogspot.com Howard Dratch

    Let’s see. How many times have I seen this film? Lots. How many more are possible and still enjoy it?

    Lots.

  • http://nicholasstixuncensored.blogspot.com/ Nicholas Stix

    Lucas McNelly: i worry very little about giving away spoilers in 66-year-old comedies.

    I’m sorry. I was under the mistaken impression that this was a movie review. If you’re reviewing a movie, it doesn’t matter if it came out last week or 100 years ago. (After all, most people read a review because they haven’t yet seen the flick, and want a tip to help them decide.) That is, if you love movies, and want other people to enjoy them as much as you do. On the other hand, if you hate movies, and want to ruin other people’s enjoyment of them, proceed.

    hell, it barely qualifies as a spoiler.

    Gimme a break.

  • http://tonsofvisualinformation.blogspot.com Jules Alder

    I think one of the key words you overlooked, Nicholas, was “comedy.” Basically, if I may be allowed the arrogance of an interpretation:

    Ain’t much to spoil in a comedy, and you’ve had (presumably) up to 66 years in which to watch it…judging from your general crotchetiness.

    Are you getting enough sleep at night?

  • http://lmcnelly15.blogspot.com Lucas McNelly

    Nicholas,

    lighten up. giving away minor plot points in His Girl Friday is going to do less harm to the viewing experience than the average trailer does. If you’d like, I could tell you how the movie ends, but I won’t. If you can’t talk about what happens in the film, it’s going to be a much shorter review.