Today on Blogcritics
Home » DVD Review: Doctor Who 2005 – The Complete First Series

DVD Review: Doctor Who 2005 – The Complete First Series

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Sixteen years after its original run ended, The BBC recommissioned Doctor Who back onto the airwaves. The series, which deals with the adventures of a time traveler known as The Doctor, was reborn through the vision of Queer As Folk creator Russell T. Davies. For the most part, his version of the series works when his scripts aren’t used and the other writers are able to focus on their stories.

This box set contains all 13 episodes of Series 1 and the subsequent Doctor Who Confidential programs that followed. Included on each disc are a series of mini-features detailing the making of the new Who and some of the ways the special effects were achieved. Considering many might not be familiar with the show in, I would avoid these until you become familiar with the new series. The Doctor Who Confidentals would be a good start for people interested in the classic series and how it’s tied to the latest version. Unfortunately, due to legal issues, the classic series footage was removed and a “cut-down” version of the Confidential series was included instead. There’s also a behind-the-scenes special for the “Christmas Invasion” episode, which takes place after Series 1 – avoid this one as well.

The show boasted its newness by casting a well-known actor in the role of The Doctor with Christopher Eccleston, who was known for playing edgy roles in such shows as Cracker and The Second Coming (also created by Russell T. Davies). Along for the ride is former pop singer Billie Piper, who plays companion Rose Tyler. To give a better earth-feel to the series, Rose’s family is featured throughout in the form of her mother Jackie (Camile Coduri) and her boyfriend Mickey (Noel Clarke). While everyone else stuck around for another season, Eccleston was signed on for only one year – that’s bound to jar people when they see his Doctor suddenly regenerate into David Tennant in the last episode of Series 1.

In general, a lot of the episodes still carry some of the same problems the original series had. Sometimes the scripts try to do too much and change genres midstory. That must have been frustrating for Eccleston, considering he was used to a tighter style of writing, not to mention he couldn’t really seal the character of The Doctor due to lack of focus. Eccleston wanted a more dramatic Doctor, which was often canceled out by the wild nature of the scripts – one part comedy, one part drama. I suspect it would have turned off families if it had been tailored to Eccleston’s previous works. His performance improved in “Father’s Day,” “The Unquiet Dead,” and “The Parting Of The Ways,” which makes this set of episodes not a complete wash.

In my opinion, it would be good idea to rent some of the classic series episodes before  viewing the new series. You can familiarize yourself with the character of The Doctor, his many lives, and his often very strange adventures with his companions. If you don’t care for a show’s history, then forgo the classic series and watch this instead. Just be prepared for an unusual ride when you do.

Powered by

About Matthew Milam

  • Scott Butki

    Excellent piece, Matthew.
    Even I, a non-Dr.Who watcher, am able to understand why the show is so interesting after reading your article. I particularly appreciate the pointers to better places to start for a Who virgin like me.

  • http://zomboscloset.blogspot.com Iloz Zoc

    I find the Tom Baker episodes the most fun. While the effects are really cheesy, even for yesterday’s standards, the series is amazingly long-lived due to its novel, and often whacky approach to telling a story. This new season’s shows are exemplary. Not perfect, but still very exciting. Long live the Doctor!

  • Mayzee

    Christopher Eccleston, gritty actor that he is, indicated in interviews that he looked forward to playing the doctor because he wanted people to see him and realize that he can do comedy as well as drama. He also was very moved by the amazing response he got from children and put many of the pictures they drew of him and the daleks on his wall and fridge in his home.
    Chris never said in any interviews that he wanted a more dramatic doctor. He said that he wanted to work with Russell T Davies again because he likes his writing. He quit for personal reasons, which he has never fully disclosed. There has been much speculation, but the truth about his departure remains as elusive as the Loch Ness Monster… all myths and fuzzy photos.
    I love the new Who… all of it… the campiness, the drama… just all of it. I think it was very well done… remember… this was aimed to be family viewing, accessible to children and adults on multiple levels. It’s a British show, therefore it will have a more European feel to it, and that is refreshing. I think it succeeded and that there were layers to the stories. I appreciated it on so many levels. Kudos to Chris and to Russell and to Billie and to all who contributed to the rebirth of one of the craziest, yet most beloved shows of all time.

  • Courtney

    Im 13 years old and i seriously am in love with this show. but i was extreamly sad when they quit on Rose. i dont know but i really liked her but the newest girl is good to and i liked the first doctor. it took me like 2 episodes to get used to the new doctor but its still really good. i would reccommend this show to everybody. i talk about at my school and they all look at me weird like im sutpid but i tell you if they acutally watched the show they would get hooked on it like i did.