Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Reviews music » Concert Reviews » DVD Review: Collective Soul – Home

DVD Review: Collective Soul – Home

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Collective Soul is one of the few shining lights on the post-grunge, radio-friendly rock scene, which also includes such contemporaries as Live, Train, and Our Lady Peace. Collective Soul‘s music is driven by hook-laden guitar anthems and heavily orchestrated power-ballads that can satisfy both the hard-rockers and Top 40-pop fans alike. They are essentially the bastard child of Bon Jovi and The Beatles. I am not such a fan of the band as to run out and buy every album they release, as their music can be a little too derivative and inconsistent at times. Then again, whose isn’t? One thing is for sure, you wont be disappointed picking up a "best of", or live collection from these guys, because when they are on, they can churn out some of the catchiest rock & roll in the business.

I recently re-assessed my opinion of Collective Soul, after I gave their Music In High Places video a second look last year. I had only skimmed through it once when it was first released in 2001, and then it got buried away amongst the rest of my collection. One day I was looking for something a little mellow and acoustic-based to chill out to, and I decided to gave the thing another chance. It is now one of my favorite videos of its kind. Music In High Places featured the band performing completely acoustic arrangements of their songs in exotic Moroccan locals, but you still got a good sense of how great these guys must be in a true live concert setting. The Home video answers that question in spades.

Home was recorded over a two night stand in April of 2005, in the band’s hometown of Atlanta, Georgia. Hence the title. These shows were performed with the Atlanta Symphony Asian, err, I mean, Youth Orchestra. Just got a little confused there, seeing that about 75 percent of this "Atlanta" orchestra is made up of Asian-American kids. I guess scoring that cello scholarship to Berkeley or Julliard is not as enticing to most other ethnicities, as scoring the next big Def Jam record deal is. Then again, I wanted to be Ace Frehley when I was that age.

All kidding aside, these high school kids sounded as good as any professional orchestra I have heard recently. More importantly, they sounded good with Collective Soul. Obviously, an orchestra-backed Collective Soul is much easier to swallow than, say, an orchestra-backed Metallica. Much of their music is already heavily orchestrated, or is backed by orchestra-like keyboard arrangements. Surprisingly, the grittier rockers such as "Precious Declaration" and "Gel" did not lose any of their punch as the symphonic arrangements provided just the right amount of accompaniment without smoothing out the rough edges too much. The already orchestra-dominated epics like "December" and "The World I Know" sounded that much more majestic with a real 100-person orchestra propelling them.

Several acoustic ballads, such as "Needs", "Run", "Youth", and "Satellite" were dug up for this show and had the potential to drag things down a bit, but in this case, the orchestra was given their chance to really shine, often steeling your focus away from Roland strumming his guitar. The band had no problem sharing the spotlight with these talented kids, and no more so than during the Hints Allegations And Things Left Unsaid instrumental "Pretty Donna", where a string quartet was positioned at the front of the stage to perform the song while the band took a much deserved short break.

The band performed brilliantly throughout this show especially Ed Roland. He has become one of the most dynamic frontmen in the business. His vocals were strong and dripping with passion and soul on every single song. New lead guitarist, Joel Kosche, who came on board just in time for 2004’s Youth album, played admirably and looks to become this band’s very own Ritchie Sambora. Steady as a rock, and with just enough flash to keep you coming back for more.

Speaking of Youth, this most recent album by the band featured the most songs in the set with six. They kicked off the show with the hit single "Counting The Days" and then heavily stacked the second half of the show with five more of its songs. The absolute highlight of the show came from the rousing performance of the album’s other hit single, "Better Days", which had the entire crowd, orchestra, and orchestra conductor, on their feet, dancing, clapping, and chanting the chorus "the world’s done shaking, the world’s done shaking, the world’s done shaking me down". The band leaves the stage, as the chanting continues, and when they return for their encore, the chanting picks back up again even louder. The band seemed genuinely moved by this overwhelming show of appreciation.

The encore begins with the new ballad, "Satellite", which the single-dad, Roland, explains is a song he wrote for his then three year old son. It is one of his best ballads. Of course the final song of the night had to be the surprise smash hit from their first album, "Shine". If you thought that the original album cut of this song sounded a little thin, like myself, then hold on to your hats when you hear this awesome version. With the string section matching every power chord radiating from Kosch and Roland’s guitars, and Roland singing his frigging heart out, this version simply embarrassed the original. It was an incredible end to an incredible show.

As much as I have praised the performance on this DVD, the production quality deserves even more praise. Quite simply, it is possibly the finest overall production quality for a rock concert DVD that I have seen to date. The widescreen video presentation is flawless, and easily handles the intensely bright and colorful stage show. Two outstanding audio options are provided; the first is a powerful PCM stereo mix that gives me high hopes for the CD version of this concert. The Dolby Digital 5.1 surround mix is the definite option of choice if you have the setup. If you close your eyes and turn it up loud, on a decent surround sound system, you are literally transported into the middle of the theater. The camera work was perfect, providing every possible angle, but never jumping around too quickly. You got a wonderful sense of being there.

The extra features were substantial including plenty of behind-the-scenes footage, the making of the "Better Now" video, Ed Roland singing "Georgia Girl" in his dressing room while playing acoustic guitar, and a short documentary called "Home". This is all packaged in a thick plastic DVD case, appropriately called a "super jewel box", which includes a 25-page color booklet. This is the first I’ve purchased of this type of DVD case, and I hope it is not a new trend. It seems like it might break too easily, just like half of my damn CD cases.

I can only imagine how incredible it was to be at this Atlanta performance, and to actually FEEL the energy of this performance. This outstanding DVD gives you the next best thing, and with a decent enough home theater system, you, and your neighbors, will be able to feel it too. Although it is still only February, Collective Soul‘s Home is going to be a bitch to bump off the top of my best of 2006 list.

Set List
Counting The Days
Listen
December
Compliment
Precious Declaration
Needs

Heavy
Run
The World I Know
Pretty Donna
Youth
Crown
Under Heaven Skies
She Said
Home
Gel
How Do You Love
Better Now
Satellite
Shine

Performance 10/10
Production 10/10

Read all of my DVD concert reviews at Roy’s Reviews

Powered by

About Paul Roy

  • http://draven99.blogspot.com Chris Beaumont

    I may have to check this out! I have liked their music for some time now. I saw them live last year and it was a lot better than I was expecting. I tend towards heavier music, but these guys know how to construct a fun pop song.

  • http://bb.collectivesoul.com/index.php Mimi

    If you haven’t had a chance, you really need to check out Collective Soul live in concert sometime. It’s an experience you’ll never forget. I truly believe Ed is one of the best frontmen out there today. They’re truly an inspired, talented band!

  • Barry

    Great review. I was at the taping of this show on
    both nights and they really did capture the majesty of the whole thing.
    It’s nice to read a review who can give credit
    to perhaps pop/rock music’s most underrated band.

  • Becca

    This band is definatly someone to see live, they put on a great show everytime! Lead singer Ed Roland radiates energy to the crowd. They have so many great songs, and the live DVD is a must have for everyone to experience the magic of those night with the orchestra.

  • nomad19

    Give it for Roy….what an oustanding review.I can’t help but wonder how many new fans Collective Soul has gained from the Direct t.v. exposure of the “Home” video. While being an avid fan of the band , I too am amazed at every show I see them play. They are awesome live and Ed has great interactions with his fans and so rock out!

    I love the dvd and was there for both nights with the ASYO and I honestly get tingles when watching the Better Now segment , I was one of those fans chanting “the world’s done shakin…etc.

    The double cd discs are also available of this performance and are great for anyone just beginning to appreciate theses guys and their true talent for writing lyrics and kick ass rock that the whole family can enjoy.

    If you have never seen Collective Soul live..you have no idea what your missing.

  • gb

    Excellent review of an excellent concert and dvd! People on the CS board are puzzling over the ‘bastard child of the Beatles and Bon Jovi’ description but I love it!
    Get the word out!

  • Paul Roy

    The “bastard child” reference was certainly a big complement to the band. They combine the best qualities of both bands.

  • jeff

    I am a longtime Collective Soul Fan. I have seen many live shows and agree that the energy and power of their live shows overshadow their studio work. Thanks for the blog.

  • asyo violinist

    hey, thanks for the wonderful review. we really loved playing, and i’m glad you enjoyed the dvd. :D i’d like to note, though, that though we do have a considerable amount of asian-americans (mostly in the strings), we are still very much an atlanta orchestra. :D

  • Kellie

    As for your review: Exactly what I was thinking. I was lucky enough to attend the “Home” concert and without a doubt it was the best live show I have ever seen. I would not have wanted to miss this show. Luckily enough for those that did, the follow up DVD is supurb. In regards to the production quality of the DVD, I agree with the reviewer, it is flawless, and will be hard to top. Collective Soul should be very proud of this one; Very High Quality.

  • Pete

    You said it, brother!

  • dman

    Spot on! Collective Soul overall is one of the best groups out there! Ed Rollins is a Genius song writer! Get This DVD! Even if your not a fan, by the third time you watch it, you’ll be hooked!

  • Nick

    Collective Soul is one of the worst bands I ever seen in concert. I don’t think I need a DVD to remind me how lame they are live.

  • http://buzzedition.net Susan (@BuzzEdition)

    Nice blog! Are you aware of the Collective Soul blog contest? You should enter ;)