Taylor Swift, the Break-Up, and the Crazy Jonas Brothers Fans - Comments Page 2

Negative commentary is surrounding Taylor Swift, when all she's doing is being a teenage girl.

“You run and hide like a scared little boy.” That is a line in Taylor Swift’s song, “Forever and Always,” available on her new CD Fearless. “Forever and Always” reflects a relationship between Taylor and her ex, Joe Jonas of the Jonas Brothers.…
Read comments below, or read this article from the beginning.

Article comments

  • 26 - tray

    Nov 16, 2008 at 8:05 pm

    Taylor forced Joe Jonas to make a statement and defend himself... anybody would in that situation, especially if what was being said wasn't true. It's funny how she hasn't defending herself after his side of the story, but I hope she doesn't because it's time to move on. They dated for what.. 4 months, with hectic schedules on both sides... how much time could they really have spent together?

  • 27 - vicky

    Nov 16, 2008 at 8:30 pm

    um have you ever thought that he could wait till hes in the country to break up with her ? and plus she didnt say anything bad about joe if u actually watched the ellen vid. she didnt just randomly brought him up and dissed him ! ELLEN brought him up ! and taylor was just hes not in my life anymore and was like when i find that person who is right for me i wont even remeber the guy that dumpped me on the phone for 27 secounds when i was 18 thats not immitrure becuase if she didnt put that out there all these press would be asking her about joe and wouldnt that be awkward if they broken up already !

  • 28 - Linda

    Nov 16, 2008 at 8:54 pm

    I couldn't even finish reading this because you got all your facts wrong! First, Camilla Belle is not from the movie Year 3000. She is from the movie 1000 B.C. Year 3000 is a song by the Jonas Brothers. Second, the only person you got your facts from was Taylor Swift. If you actually did a good job you would have heard that Joe said that the only reason the phone calls was that short was because Taylor didn't want to hear it and hung up on him. But I don't blame her b/c if I was losing a guy as amazing as Joe Jonas I would feel like crap too. So next time you write a story get your facts straight first. Thanks.

  • 29 - Tory

    Nov 16, 2008 at 9:12 pm

    #31 I think that your comment is not only biased and rude, it was completely stupid.
    Considering the fact that this article was written after Joe took his blog off his myspace (because he is a pussy) how could she have heard his side?
    And yes she probably did hang up on him and I always thought that is probably what happened, even before he wrote that blog. But if he only took 25 seconds to say 'sorry it's over' than obviously he's got some jerk issues. I mean what did he do? Just say we're done as soon as she answered. Who does that!!?!?
    I am glad that he and Taylor are over. He messed with her so much and then he just broke her heart because he found some other girl. Cause all guys are the same and yeah Jonas Brothers are even worse. Except Kevin, he's the only one I don't mind.
    Joe is not amazing, Taylor is. And she did not use this relationship or break up as publicity, she just wanted to go out there and tell her side because that's just who she is--and that's why I love her.
    So go buy Taylor's album :)
    and forget whoever this other guy is :)

  • 30 - Rach

    Nov 16, 2008 at 9:19 pm

    I couldn't agree with you more.
    The jonas brothers' fans are blind and ridiculous and immature!
    Both are born in the same year, the girl just handled things maturely and bravely;
    while the guy just handled in cowardly. What the poing of the "crafted" piece of blog, there isn't a sense of feeling sorry there. All he knows is to put the blame back to other to save his reputation and image!

  • 31 - Katie

    Nov 16, 2008 at 10:08 pm

    AMEN

  • 32 - HSMluvr

    Nov 16, 2008 at 10:32 pm

    Okay, so it sounds like someone is a little biased toward Taylor here. Which you are not supposed to be in an article.

    here is my stance on the whole thing:

    WHO CARES!

    I love taylor and the JoBros and frankly I could care less

  • 33 - tray

    Nov 16, 2008 at 10:34 pm

    For someone who's so sweet and doesn't deserve to be treated the way she was treated... she sure does have a lot of songs that trash alot of ex-boyfriends. When someone gets dumped as many times as she has and your only 18, maybe you should take a good look at yourself and quit blaming everybody else.

  • 34 - Jillian

    Nov 17, 2008 at 1:56 am

    Neither team is at fault...and why the hell are there teams? for starters i dont think it is anyones business for sides to be formed. its childish. people are sticking their noses in where it isnt appreciated. unless joe or taylor have asked your opinion on it, keep the opinions to yourselves.

    i was a jonas fan, but it is the fans that ruin it for everyone else. 3 1/2 years i have been one and the childishness is crazy.

    GROW UP and find something more interesting to talk about other than who is at fault....

  • 35 - JONAS CRAZYYY (:

    Nov 17, 2008 at 6:04 am

    I live over in Australia and i still hate taylor swift... she is only trying to get attention.. hello if you read the jonas brothers blog it says...
    "A phone call can only be received when the person on the other side wanted to hear what you have to say, if they dont like it they can just hang up"... HELLO SHE HUNG UP SO HOW IS THAT JOE FAULT SHE IS A SELFISH COW THAT NEEDS TO REALLY MOVE ON IN LIFE!!!

    good on joe for moving on..

    and FYI its 10000 B.C. not Year 3000...
    i hateeeeee Taylor Swift and no one can ever change that (: good on joe for dumping her haha

    P.S.......Im not crazy or Obsessive ether
    dont be so offensive

  • 36 - Krae

    Nov 17, 2008 at 7:49 am

    You have your facts wrong. I think you should do some more research for both sides of the story. Yes, the Jonas Brothers currently don't have a top 100 song. But they were thought to sell 700,000+ albums in their first week alone. They fell short with over 525,000+ being sold. I realize that you might not have found Joe Jonas' blog replying to all the rumours but you could've also stated that it's not just Jonas fans insulting Taylor. Many Taylor (and Jonas Fans) left some pretty horrible comments on the Jonas Brothers' websites (youtube, myspace, etc...)including death threats. You could have included that. Also Camille Belle was in 10,000 B.C. not Year 3000 (a jonas brothers song). I realize these are all facts about the Jonas brothers but you already have good information on taylor. I'm just trying to balance out your article.
    *On a side note I believe that this whole thing was blown out of proportion and the fans should stay out of it.*
    ** Don't you think it's interesting that we don't feel bad about analyzing the lives of famous people but we'd protest pretty strongly if everyone knew everything about our personal lives?**

  • 37 - TIFFANY

    Nov 17, 2008 at 8:32 am

    OK I HEARD FROM A FEW RELIABLE SOURCES THAT JOE CALLED TAYLOR TO TALK AND SHE WAS THE ONE TO END THE CALL AFTER ONLY 27 SECONDS. NOW I DONT KNOW WHAT PART OF ALL THIS IS FAKE AND WHICH IS REAL BUT I DO KNOW THAT PPL SHOULDNT CARE WHAT TAYLOR AND JOE DO OR DID AND WHAT JOE IS DOING NOW THEY ARE PPL JUST LIKE US AND THEY DESERVE TO HAVE LIVES, ALTHOUGH THEY ARE FAMOUS DOESNT MEAN ANYTHING, IT JUST MEANS THEY HAVE GREAT TALENTS AND THE WORLD ENJOYS HEARING THEM AND THEY GET PAID THATS ALL. SO JUST REALAX BESIDES I NEVER BELIEVE ANYTHING THE MAGAZINES OR WEB STORIES ANYWAYS I JUST WAIT TO SEE WHAT THE PEOPLE THEMSELVES SAY.

  • 38 - Joanie

    Nov 17, 2008 at 8:40 am

    Maybe Taylor should have told the truth and she wouldn't be getting so much flack herself.Half truths are just as bad as an all out lie. The phone call ended because she hung up on him. Taylor is acting like a spoiled brat of a teenager, therein lies the difference in how teens act. Joe's a nice guy and people are going to always try to make something small into something horrible. I think I will stick with Joe on this one.

  • 39 - Nick_Jonas_Lover

    Nov 17, 2008 at 8:48 am

    I think Camilla Belle is sooo stupid, I mean I like Taylor Swift but I can't believe she ended the phone call. +P I mean really, Camilla isn't that pretty... she looks like she has fake eyebrows! my friends agree, BUT I'm not making fun of Taylor. I'm making fun of Camilla, she looks weird and I really hope she would break up with Joe. Really I would break up with a younger man! :( Sorry Jonas Brothers........


  • 40 - Lexi

    Nov 17, 2008 at 10:40 am

    I am on both Taylor and Joe's side. First of all, I bet it is EXTREMELY hard to be famous and date, especially another famous person. So we have 2 singers who dated and no one, NO ONE, but Taylor and Joe knows why they splitted and the feelings they had for each other. Yes, if I was Taylor I would be heartbroken, but you have no idea how their relationship was and whether or not they got together GREAT.. maybe they had issues and realized they needed to cool things off.. only THEY know. Let them be and stop talking crap about either one of them. I love both the Jonas Brothers and Taylor Swift. I believe they are all great musicians with wonderful morals.

  • 41 - None

    Nov 17, 2008 at 2:09 pm

    Taylor should handle this more maturly even though Joe did do her wrong for leaving her just to date someone else.

  • 42 - Gen9109

    Nov 17, 2008 at 2:10 pm

    I hate Camilla belle!

  • 43 - Amy

    Nov 17, 2008 at 3:29 pm

    This blog is ridiculous. When your young, you date and break up and that's life. You should take one dating experience and learn from it so that you can use it for your next one. No one should break up with someone over the phone... period. I don't care if it is your lovable Jonas brother. I'm not sure if that is true, but if it is, it wasn't right for him to do that. I don't think that you would like that if you were in Taylor's shoes. Taylor is being a teenager by talking about it to the public. She is hurt. This story just proves that no matter how famous you are, you are still humans and humans make mistakes. All of you girls that are on here saying you hate Taylor and love Joe. It's never going to happen so just be content with your Jonas fan club membership. Remember there are more important things in life than talking about 2 people that you will never meet and will be lining tomorrow's trash cans! This is coming from a New Kid's on the Block generation. You will look back and realize how stupid everybody your age was!

  • 44 - emily

    Nov 17, 2008 at 5:10 pm

    I love Joe so i am glad that he broke up with her i like Taylor in all but she does need to suck it up and move on they can miss each other but Joe seems like he dose not miss her and Taylor does not wont to let it go and she is ugly she puts way to mush make up on! and she needs to grow up1

  • 45 - hi

    Nov 17, 2008 at 5:20 pm

    okay so I am hugeee jb fan, bigger than u can imagine. but I am totally on taylors side for this one. what joe did was redic and I love the song forever and always. it's great. some of taylors best songs come from her breakups

  • 46 - Meghan

    Nov 17, 2008 at 5:44 pm

    No, they're both at fault.
    I think Taylor is being a classless twit about this. She's making it seem like Joe called her said, "I'm dumping you." When in fact Miss. Swift hung up on him. She needs to grow up. She's stupid.

  • 47 - Camikins

    Nov 17, 2008 at 6:29 pm

    Taylor IS being classless. She and Joe made this big deal about not putting their private life on blast, but as soon as he dumps her it's all over the media. And did it occur to anyone that the Jonas Brothers were in EUROPE when he broke up with her? "Hmmm, I think I'll go on a 12 hour plane ride back to the U.S.A. to break up with my girlfriend for 15 minutes, and then 12 hours back! yeahhhh." Does this sound logical to you? and besides, I'm not even that big of a Jonas Brothers fan and I'm on their side. And not all teen girls act like that when they get dumped. Instead of Making the guy out to be a HUGE jerk, I kind of cover it up. Pretend it didn't happen.

  • 48 - hi =]

    Nov 17, 2008 at 7:14 pm

    I am a fan of both Taylor Swift and Joe Jonas, and while I love both of them, I do believe that both sides are at fault. True, Joe broke up with her over the phone, but the Jonas Brothers' Myspace blog said something about a phone call can go on only as long as the other person wants to talk. You also have to remember that people asked Taylor about her recent experience; she didn't just randomly bring it up on Ellen and go JOE JONAS BROKE UP WITH ME ON THE PHONE DURING A 27 SECOND CALL.

    I think they both need to move on, but Taylor is just answering questions that people ask, while Joe is avoiding the spotlight.

  • 49 - Jordan Richardson

    Nov 17, 2008 at 7:24 pm

    Those Jonas Brothers sure do get around.

  • 50 - ddddd

    Nov 17, 2008 at 7:54 pm

    wow this is written by someone who definitely doesn't like the jonas brothers. joe can do wayyy better than taylor swift.

  • 51 - someone

    Nov 17, 2008 at 8:41 pm

    i think that they shouldnt of broken up

  • 52 - lover

    Nov 17, 2008 at 9:16 pm

    i love taylor AND joe and nobody really knows what exactly happened except them so i love both eof them dearly and wish them the best

  • 53 - Elizabeth

    Nov 18, 2008 at 1:26 am

    1) Ellen brought up Joe on her show. Taylor did not. Actually watch what happened before saying anything... and it's a comedy show, they made it more of a joke then a real break-up talk.
    2) Taylor never once implied that Joe cheated on her. Taylor said that when he met the new girl, he then left Taylor for her... That means he broke up with her for another girl, that does not imply that he cheated.
    3) She is acting like any normal teenager would. When my ex broke up with me, and I was her age, I spoke to whoever wanted to hear about it because I WAS HURT! You vent to anyone when you are hurt! Little Jonas fans, one day, when you have a real relationship, instead of obsessing of the Jonas Brothers who will never even know your name, you will do the exact same thing when you get your heart broken some day, and I mean a real heart break, not a 9th grade relationship!
    4) Yeah, they were in different places in the country (So we assume, but they could have easily both been in LA or anywhere, we don't know this.) ... but they managed to see eachother every week over the summer and after? (I say this because it was posted everywhere how they randomly showed up at eachother's shows.) So he couldn't bother to wait a week to see her again? If he couldn't wait, that's fine too, but 27 seconds? There isn't even enough time in 27 seconds for him to have asked, "How is your day?" ... That would have taken 27 seconds alone. He cut right to chase instead of being a "gentleman."

    I don't hate Joe Jonas, because their relationship wasn't working and so he broke up with her, and to be blunt, I just don't care enough to hate him. I keep updated on this stuff for my cousin, to be able to have conversations with her, because she a normal teenager who is in love with the Jonas Brothers... but HE ALSO could have been more mature about how he broke up with her. No matter what all of you say, 27 seconds is just a disrespectful gesture. No one would want to stay on the phone after being broken up with, so to say "she ended the call"... OF COURSE SHE DID... but maybe if he would have taken the time just to say HI before saying "Hey uh this wont work." ... then it wouldn't have been 27 seconds. And to further try to contact her? WHY?... You broke up with her, you broke her heart, MOVE ON & LET HER TRY AND HEAL. Further contact doesn't allow a girl time to heal.

    Have your heart broken, and you'd understand why Taylor acted this way... and it won't bother you, but you'll almost find it humorous and laugh at the memories of when you went through this exactly. I'm just defending Taylor because the poor girl had her heart broken and was handeling this the way most girls do, and just because shes in the public eye, she is getting torn apart

    PS: Joe Jonas, when you want to bring some "enlightment" to your fans, try to make it more personal then having your publicist type it for you. Getting their help, of course, you pay them to be there! But it would be more believable that you're a good guy if you seemed sincere & not like a robot in your blog.

  • 54 - patricia

    Nov 18, 2008 at 2:28 am

    Thank you elizabeth! I'm a huge jonas brothers and taylor swift fan, but seriously, 27 secs...I completely agree that taylor is just doing what any other girl would do if she was broken up with in 27 secs over the phone..it doesn't matter who's right bc no one, including joe, denied that that he broke up with her in 27 secs..since taylor became famous, she's always said that if a boy hurts her it's gonna be in a song bc that's what she does..some girls get revenge, Taylor writes songs..I commend her for being real and not being one of those "no comment" celebrities. I ABSOLUTELY love taylor and the jobros, but I definately lost some respect for Joe..this shouldn't matter when it comes to their music though..FEARLESS is AMAZING including the song "forever and always" about joe, and "a little bit longer" is also an AWESOME cd..fans need to learn how to seperate these celebrities' personal lives from their professional lives

  • 55 - Zoe

    Nov 18, 2008 at 3:01 am

    tbh; you're acting like you know all about it; did you read Joe's blog? Yeh she hung up on him. I do still like her music but I've lost all respect for her because she's tried to twist the truth and tried to make everyone feel sorry for her!
    Yes, I am obsessed with JB and I think it's stupid that you think we're crazy cause we're really not, basically you just slated Joe but you're saying it's wrong for people to slate Taylor :/
    Yeh well anyone that agrees or wants to argue...add me!
    Love Zoe x

  • 56 - steve

    Nov 18, 2008 at 11:31 am

    ok this whole thing will blow over and taylor will continue on and make several more cds and become one of the greatest of all time while the jonas brothers make one or two more albums before they fall off the side of the earth just like all the other disney singers out there. taylor has a real career going and it will continue. whats wrong with her telling the truth? all of you were wondering anyways! for it to take 27 seconds he just flat out told her and thats messed up. break it to her slowly or something and try doing it IN PERSON!!!

  • 57 - Taylor Renee hearts Nick J!

    Nov 18, 2008 at 5:23 pm

    I do not think that Taylor handeled there break up maturely. I mean maybe things were not going the way Joe wanted them to. Just because Joe broke up with her does not mean that he would never talk to her again. It is Taylor that is acting so inmature. She is going around making videos about them breaking up. How mature is that? ITS NOT!!!!!! Maybe Taylor was not the right girl for Joe.If it was the other way around Joe would understand but she has to be so immature and make videos about him! BABY!!!!

  • 58 - Hilda

    Nov 20, 2008 at 11:21 am

    I'm neautral right now. I mean, Joe Jonas, is my celebrity crush. and TAylor Swift is one of my insperations. I mean, it was a little bogus he broke up with her threw the phone. But maybe he didnt want to tell her face-to-face because he might feel bad. But whatever. I mean, Taylor, talking about her break-up in all those talk shows, sorta bogus, its stupid. its just one guy. there are millions of guyz that LOVE you. Just get over it. Teenage relationships dont last forever. When ur an adult, you might find the won. Just leave Taylor alone, and stop talking trash about Joe Jonas. Im not an obesssive fan. But i am a fan. and TORY, love how you wrote ur thought. its awsome. peace out.

  • 59 - luvJJ

    Nov 20, 2008 at 5:47 pm

    If anything Joe handled this the right way. She attacked first might i add on national television. Joe followed up afterwards in a polite manner. It's her fault for not hearing the reason and for not responding to any of his calls. The video was a complete immature move by far. I think it's just petty jealousy on her part. I'm sick of her and the way she's acting complete immaturity

  • 60 - megan

    Nov 22, 2008 at 9:37 pm

    I think they shoult levea joe and taylor break up alone and get on whith there lift.It is there bisniss and not there.GUST LEVED THAM BE.

  • 61 - zz

    Dec 04, 2008 at 2:03 pm

    10,000 B.C , and Year 3000
    whats the difference? haha

    I love them both, and this will all blow over in a matter of minutes

  • 62 - April

    Dec 06, 2008 at 2:14 pm

    I love Taylor Swift. And personally I dont think it matters how they broke up or why. She was obviously hurt by what happened. Everyone was wandering about it anyway so she just let it out in the open. Joe, on the other hand, obviously had no intention of working things out otherwise he wouldn't have jumped into a new girls arms within such a short period of time. Bottomline we should just let them live their lives and not be so judgemental. We all go through bad breaks ups and it doesn't help when alot of other people get involved. And besides, I can't wait to hear what amazing songs Tay will write about it. Lets face it, when things like this happen she writes more and we all love listening to her new songs. She is an amazing song writer, singer, and an overall really outstanding person. Before you start disliking her, maybe you should find out more about her.

  • 63 - JCstar

    Dec 09, 2008 at 3:45 pm

    You know, it's so weird how we get so caught up in celebs lives. Ok, it was cool for Taylor to right a song about the breakup, but I feel she didn't need to air things so publicly. And Joe could've let her down softer, cause if she hung up after 27secs, he must have been quite brutal. I am an obsessive JB fan, but if we judge the celebs, we gotta look at both sides. If you just judge on who you like, then you might as well stay out of it. Coz honestly, what's the point of passing a comment when you're so obviously biased. Taylor, stay strong. Joe, watch yourself baby boy, be careful how you say things.

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 23, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs