Some things point us to God in rather direct ways, others more indirectly, and still others show us divine truths by opposition and contrast rather than by similarity. Superman is a figure who is striking not so much for his similarity to Christ, but rather for his dissimilarity. We might say that the typological relation between Jesus and Superman is that of Christ and anti-Christ. Indeed, those looking for a more direct analogue to the comic hero Superman would do well to look at the writings of the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, whose intellectual influence was in full bloom on both sides of the Atlantic in the 1930s, the decade when the Superman comic was born.
Many Christians embraced the Superman hero when a trailer for the new movie was released using the words of Superman’s father Jor-El, voiced by Marlon Brando: “Even though you’ve been raised as a human being you’re not one of them. They can be a great people, Kal-El. They wish to be. They only lack the light to show the way. For this reason above all, their capacity for good, I sent them you... my only son.”
The superficial similarities between Jesus and Superman are clear. Both are sons sent to Earth to save humankind. But it is here that the likeness ends and the more fundamental differences appear. What the preceding quote illustrates is that Superman is supposed to lead humankind into a future in which we realize our own innate potential.
The title character in Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra teaches the people about the coming of the Superman, and speaks of this potential: “It is time for man to fix his goal. It is time for man to plant the germ of his highest hope.” Humans are “something that is to be surpassed,” and “a rope stretched between the animal and the Superman.”
This goal is the Superman, who is “the sense of their existence” and “the lightning out of the dark cloud.” In a posthumously published book, aptly titled The Anti-Christ, Nietzsche makes the explicit case for his opposition of the Superman to the Christian, whom he calls “the sick human animal.”
Article comments
1 - Baronius
There's definitely conflict between the Gospel image of Christ and Nietzsche's image of the Superman. But the modern Superman of movies and cartoons doesn't follow Nietzsche. He's bound by a moral code that seems out-of-step with the contemporary world. At least, that's the way he's usually been. I don't know about the new movie (although I haven't heard anything about him becoming immoral).
2 - superman fan
Superman was in no way modeled on Jesus. His creators have more than once explained precisely the origin and representative myths he arose from. Even the language and place names of his home and family reveal this. He was modeled after the Kabbalistic myth of Rabbi Loew's Golem stories of Prague, who was used to save Jews from blood libel stories and persecutions from Christians.
In that respect, he is a savior figure, but not in the manner of the Christian dogma. But this is nothing new to take a concept of Jews based on Jewish themes and to impose meaning on it that the authors have stated did not exist.
3 - The History of Superman
You may go to that link to read a brief history of Superman. That one does not mention the Rabbi Loew Golem stories which may have played a part, but Nazi Germany most certainly loomed large in the minds of the two young Jewish men who created a hero who was saved from a Holocaust of his own people, sent to live with others with a changed name and belief system. HMM..sound familiar to immigrant jewish familiy stories? Superman himself was raised in a Methodist house with human parents who would have instilled their beliefs and practice. That does not diminish that his character's origins were clearly Jewish in symbolism and not Jesus oriented. His Kryptonite name is a Hebrew name meaning voice of God. There are many web sites on the internet that tell the story of Superman and many other comic book heroes who also were created by Jewish authors with references to Jewish themes often missed by the non Jew who read them.
4 - Scarlett
Hey, the similarities ARE startling! Jesus too was sent to our Earth after his homeplanet was destroyed! Jesus could also fly, and he had heat vision, and he obtained his power from the Sun... Wow, these Christians need to stop reinterpreting things to fit their beliefs. That's all they've been doing for the past 2 thousand years. I got a kick out of this when certain church-goers I know started making the connections.
5 - Jordan
From a Christian perspective, the linkage with the Moses story would be a way to get at the similarities with Christ, since as I noted for Christians Moses is understood as a type of Christ. Thus, a Jewish origin for the Superman story wouldn't necessarily preclude a Christological interpretation.
Of course, Nietzsche also used such imagery, esp. with the Zarathustra character, named for the prominent Zoro-Astrian figure, who comes down from the mountain to share his enlightenment with the world.
There's also some confusion about what Nietzsche was really all about. He wasn't against morality, so to speak, but wanted people to create their own moralities, to breka the old and make new "tablets" of law.
6 - Ray Ellis
Superman falls into the category of what Jung loosely coined "the Christ mythos," which can be cited in virtually every culture since the beginning of time: the hero born of humble origins who rises to great power only to be smitten by overpowering forces, who journeys to hell and emerges resurrected as an eternal hero, god-like in stature. It's part of the collective unconsciousness, which may explain why acomic book character can become a focus of controversy.
7 - chaplainandrews
Or...youcan simply enjoy Superman as a Comic Book character...maybe itis just entertaining to read a story about a man who can fly and not have to think to hard about it.
8 - thinkoutsidethebox
I grew up reading 1960's Superman, Superboy, Lois Lane stories. And grew up reading my Sunday School take home paper which had a cartoon version of Jesus and basic Bible stories... Later, I worked at David C. Cook, a Christian publisher which sought to communicate the Gospel in current cultural language(which published the still in print comic book version of the Bible---drawn by a man who also had drawn 1960's Lois Lane comics!!!)
*****
Superman is a Jewish hero created by Jewish men who elsewhere said they drew on Jewish hero sourses... (tho surely later Gentile Christian influenced writers have added some Jesus-influenced nuances).Lest some forget, Jesus is Jewish, tho some of us Gentiles have forgotten that. Our knowledgeable Jewish friends would probably recognize and understand Jesus's words (in some New Testament accounts) better than us Gentiles...!
And when I saw pics of the two young Jewish men who created him, I saw "Clark Kent" types of quiet even slightly nerdy nice young guys...and I honor their great cultural contribution. I (as a child) always knew Superman was fictional, but I recognized traits of some real Jewish heroes in him!
I agree with commentators---I do not see the nasty Nietschean side to Superman. Yet I also agree with the article writer---the analogy to Jesus is limited. The limits should be defined clearly to students!
*****
Incidentally, a superhero challenge for the classroom:
Ask if any student can even INVENT a rescue scenario story greater than the Jewish Man/God's eternal rescue of all who will believe...by His death on the cross & resurrection??? (Certainly Superman's physical rescues of persons fall FAR SHORT of Jesus' eternal rescue for those who believe and accept Him...!)
9 - Dr Dreadful
One of the best theories I've heard as to the origins of Superman is that he's... Indian.
The classic BBC comedy show Goodness Gracious Me had a character called Mr Everything Comes From India - an über-patriotic man who could seize on just about any characteristic to 'prove' to his sceptical British-born son that someone or something impressive had Indian origins.
His reasoning as regards Superman went something like, "I mean, think about it, yah? Has two jobs - respects his parents - can't get a girlfriend. Indian!" LOL.
Seriously, this is an interesting, thought-provoking article, albeit a bit old. Kudos!