Of Frank Miller’s Year One and subsequent comics based on its Catwoman origin, all that any enlightened reader need do is look at the body of Miller’s work. The sheer number of prostitutes, rapes, and castrations paint a vivid portrait of the man doing the writing and his attitudes, but just in case anyone doubts, Rob Bricken has taken the trouble to map it all out in 6 Hints that Frank Miller Might Have Issues with Women. What all this says about Miller is—well, it’s Miller. It doesn’t have to represent the rest of us. We don’t have to be the generation that was so terrified of women’s sexuality they had to demonize it. It was DC who let this guy with obvious issues about women’s sexuality define a women’s icon. It is DC Comics who refuses to remedy or even admit that error. It falls to other media to do so.
Mr. Nolan, I’m looking at you. The 21st century is eagerly waiting to see what “our” Catwoman will be.
Article comments
1 - Greg Huneryager
A pretty good article but Carol Ferris didn't turn into Star Sapphire for five days every month. She would always be back to normal by the end of an issue and not show up for months or years with two exceptions. One was a two-issue story and the other was in the '80s when she turned into Sapphire 'permanently.'
2 - Bill
Hmm... who is the submissive Asian villain? Could not have been a recurring character or I assume I'd know who it was.
Anyway, we already do have the 21st century Catwoman, and it was, I think, pretty well done. Ed Brubaker and Darwyn Cooke relaunched Catwoman's solo series in 2001. It was forced by continuity to give her the prostitution backstory, but her costume was redesigned to be much more practical: ditch the purple for black, lose the tail, and add night vision goggles. Her hooker boots were replaced by the sort of boots one might actually wear for jumping around rooftops. Selina's ridiculous Jim Balent bustline was replaced by a still sexy but fairly normal figure.
Character-wise, she became a sort of antihero, protecting a neglected area of Gotham, going after a murderer of prostitutes (because the police don't consider working girls worth protecting).
Her runaway child prostitute friend from Miller's Year One gets out of the street life, grows up and runs a bakery (I think) and is in a happy, non-exploitative lesbian relationship.
I'm no expert in gender politics or whatever, but I think it reflected a pretty positive attitude towards women (and was quite entertaining too).
3 - Bart
Shocking...a comic book writer has problems with women. Duh.
4 - Darla
Someone drank the Kool-aid bigtime on Brubaker, Bill. Someone always does.
Thank you for the reminder that Talia al Ghul was a way of telling girls to sit down and shut up. I remember that "good company when she was quiet" bit. My first WTF moment in comics.
5 - The Zug
The Balent costume was the best. I hope it comes back.
6 - WandersNowhere
Mmm. I don't know. If a story is about an ex-prostitute whose best friend is an ex-child-prostitute who defends a seedy neighbourhood from murderers of prostitutes is completely positive and pro-feminist and not in any way exploitative, I'll eat my own face.
Catwoman isn't supposed to be 'normal looking'...or 'broken' or 'damaged'. She's supposed to be CATWOMAN. She's supposed to embody playful, can't-touch-this-stud sexuality and put a bee down Batman's bat-briefs every time she locks eyes with him. THAT isn't exploitative, that's a powerful free-spirited woman using her god given gifts to get exactly what she wants. Usually, the jewels. Bravo, Chris, for once again pointing it out - and Cleopatra is an excellent parallel.
A generation of comic book writers that finds the idea of a playful, saucy, confident catburglar who doesn't have any major psychological issues (except maybe kleptomania) so disturbing they have to saddle her with the exact same tired background of angst, abuse and sexual exploitation they force on just about every 'strong female character'...is saying something about itself. It's a generation of Octavians that don't even have the excuse of political gain to justify their character assassination.
Let's hope Nolan and Hathaway bring the depth to their new Catwoman that the previous films brought to Batman himself, Joker, and Harvey Dent, and finally rid us of this pointless ugliness.
7 - Bill
I never said pro-feminist, nor did I say completely positive. Please don't eat your own face.
Your complaints about the lack of playfulness are in some ways true, but that is a trend of comics as a whole. "Grim and Gritty" has been the dominant tone in superhero comics for 20+ years. This is not a gender issue at all.
We're talking about a character who suffered through 15 years of being portrayed as either a prostitute/dominatrix or a walking pair of breasts (or both). Then a series comes along and tries to treat her like a real person, and a strong and intelligent one at that, I say it's a good thing.
I'm certain it's not perfect, but when virtual every female character in comics has giant breasts and wears a ridiculously skimpy costume, is constantly posed for cleavage or ass shots, and is sometimes given "o-face" by artists tracing from pornography, or when the rape, torture, and murder of women is a frequent plot device used to motivate male protagonists... if you're complaining about not the "right kind" of strong female character, I think your priorities are in the wrong place.
8 - WandersNowhere
Relax, Bill, I think we're on the same side ;)
I'm just trying to say I - like a lot of people - have never been uncomfortable with the whole prostitute backstory, which was an invention of Frank "I've never written a female character who wasn't a stripper, a hooker, a rape victim, or all three" Miller. I'd prefer to see it politely buried, forgotten, never dug up again, rather than awkwardly written around.
If the original Catwoman was a classy high-society lady with a penchant for theft who was ALSO witty, confident and strong, WITHOUT needing an angsty backstory where she was exploited and abused by men, why can't we have that back?
9 - WandersNowhere
Er. Never been COMFORTABLE. I should not post while feverish ^^;; Gomen.
10 - Bill
Technically, Miller has also written women who are essentially men with breasts. But I get what you mean.