The fact is that the whole world of books is a living ecosystem. Whereas nature moves toward a greater diversity in order to protect life—all her eggs are not in the same gene pool—the corporate hierarchical structure of the book business pushes toward consolidation, less diversity, and greater exposure to calamity. Many years ago the publishers made most of their sales on the midlist books, which allowed for greater diversity. Now everything hangs on blockbusters and clones of blockbusters with fewer and fewer viable publishers. It is a system with no flexibility, adaptability, dynamism, or life.
Within the ecosystem of a colony of ants, their organizing principle is to promote ant life. In the present ecosystem of the corporate book world, the organizing principle is not the promotion of book life, but rather to extract money. Books are not viewed as or promoted as repositories of cultural symbols and wisdom as much as they are viewed as a means for extraction of profit. As such any shit can do.
A rediversification of the book world needs to happen in order for some new vigor to come to the fore. I could see a larger publisher creating a great web of relationships with quality small independent publishers. The larger publisher would limit their exposure while the smaller publishers, who usually occupy their own niche, would probably take more risks to find quality writing. The small publisher would have the benefit of the larger publishers clout in marketing and connections. I could even envision a sort of network on the web as a source for analyzing new work and funneling the best work to the appropriate small publisher. Maybe there could be a bounty, a finder’s fee, for the good work. Of course a referring source’s reputation would begin to count for everything, so those sources would have to become literate and intelligent. What we would have is a nutrient network that begins to feed the whole system. I know there can be other solutions, but I hope to stimulate some real thinking.
I’d like to skip to the other end of the spectrum, to the writer. For writers of fiction, narrative non-fiction, and poetry their ancient roots lie in the storytelling mystery at the fire. Most of us don’t treat writing with awe any longer, don’t treat it as a means to contact one of the muses and tell a story with roots in the other side. If writing is held in awe, then language becomes a living delight that threatens to part the veil of existence. These moments of living delight fall within the realm of art. Bringing them to the world involves craft.








Article comments
1 - Elvira Black
Though i don't know a lot about book publishing, I do think that larger publishers such as (I believe) Random House do have smaller subsidiaries which focus on certain sub-genres--though again these may be mostly commercially driven. I think the internet may begin to reinvent the way books are recognized and marketed however, which may indicate a ray of hope.
2 - gypsyman
What he said!!! Yes and yes again to all that you said in this post John. Thank goodness there are writers more articulate than me to make these points, or at least to elaborate on them.
gypsyman
3 - John Spivey
Elvira-
My thought is to have a web of small independent publishers that stand by themselves, but are also connected through a larger publisher. The subsidiaries still answer to the same corporate logic and pressures as the parent.
gypsyman-thanks
js
4 - Victor Lana
This series keeps getting better and better, John. While I'm hoping things will change for the better in publishing, I think it will take a much longer time. There is hope in the online world and a new kind of publishing (that is a more equitable system) hopefully awaits.
5 - John Spivey
Victor-
Thanks for the compliment. i hope I can contribute a little in that direction.
js
6 - Mark Saleski
great as usual john. seriously.
7 - A.L. Harper
Wow very insightful piece John.
8 - John Spivey
Mark and A.L.-many thanks. seriously.
Wait till I get to the next part about the responsibilities of the reader.
9 - Mark Saleski
looking forward to it.
this is fun. i get to read about writing without adding to my poor, sagging bookshelf holding my writing about writing books.