Do you think a reviewer or site that receives payment for a review from the
author or publisher can be honest and objective?
I think it’s a bad idea in many ways to pay for reviews. There’s a potential conflict of interest that’s best avoided. Just as important, I think, it means that books are selected for review because publishers or authors can pay, not because they’ve been judged worth reviewing. And with so many books, we need to give attention to those that are worthwhile, not those that are best funded.
Do you see true good reviewers as endangered species?
I think that good reviews have always been an endangered species. But I do think the field is in transition right now. The danger is that the very concept of a good review will be lost amidst the mass of ratings and “comments.” But it seems to me that there will always be people with critical skills who will want to critique books well. And as some of our best critical magazines, bloggers, and online Web sites show, they’ll find a way to do that.
What advice would you offer aspiring reviewers?
My advice is to read widely. Read literature from the past as well as the present, to develop a feel for good writing and a context for understanding and appreciating what’s being written now. If you’re interested in a particular field, read in that field, know the background. In reviewing, I suggest reading carefully, writing precisely, and being brave as well as thoughtful. We need critics who will say they think something is good when it’s being ignored or that it’s weak when it’s being hyped as the new great thing, and that takes courage.
Article comments
1 - Kevin Eagan
Excellent interview, Gail and Mayra! Gail has a very intriguing perspective on book reviewing, and I definitely plan to check out her book.
2 - A. F. Stewart
Exceptional interview. As long as there are dedicated reviewers, I don't think good reviews will become an endangered species.
3 - c hoare
It is really beneficial to be able to read an interview with someone as long experienced in the field as Gail Pool. A coup, Mayra.
Chris H.
4 - Margay
Another great interview! I am sorry to see this series end because I have learned so much from reading it. Thank you, Gail,for all of your insights into the world of reviewing. And thank you, Mayra, for conducting this series. It's been a joy to read.