What is your opinion about critique groups? What words of advice would you offer a novice writer who is joining one? Do you think the wrong critique group can ‘crush’ a fledgling writer?
I know that I would never have matured enough as a writer to be able to write publishable novels without my seven years participation in NovelPro. Of course that group is not for novice writers and everyone there is tough enough to take criticism that completely crushes a novel. I junked one when it finally penetrate my thick skull that there was no way to resuscitate it. I have one more in a coma, waiting for my fiction craft to arrive at a level at which I can produce a draft that works.
I’d suggest that every writer should join a critique group — a gentler one if they really are writing virgins. I belong to another one that I value for the insights of some of the members but would never submit anything there for criticism. I previously belonged to one that had members who delighted in stomping on any perceived weaknesses. You must learn to evaluate criticism, not succumb to it.
Technically speaking, what do you have to struggle the most with when writing? How do you tackle it?
I continually struggle with my long out of fashion English education and reading habits. I have come to believe that formerly I only ever read books written in passive voice. If I slacken my vigilance I immediately revert to flocks of passives and land myself an hour or two of unneeded work to excise them.
I also fight bitterly against the ugly corruption of the English language that has been inspired by Webster spelling, and business and educators’ jargon. Kidnaped – sliping – I ask you! Just the other day I caught a really excellent writer with a short sentence of crass American newspaper jargon in an ethnic novel set in an Eastern country – no doubt spam from her day job.
How was your experience in looking for a publisher? What words of advice would you offer those novice authors who are in search of one?
Unless you have been advised by an established writer to approach an agent or publisher of their acquaintance, with at least a good word if not an outright recommendation, don’t waste your time. There are hundreds of small presses out there who publish the bulk of the books put out each year and they will treat your work with far more consideration than will any New York house or agent. New York really has no time or patience to deal with a writer who has no track record. Perhaps a cheque for $5000 tucked in the cover letter might do it, but they are all slaves to commercial rather than artistic or entertainment values.







Article comments
1 - c hoare
Thanks for the interview, Mayra.
I hope it generates its share of notice for your upcoming release, the Slippery Art of Book Reviewing. I shall look for the book, since I started reviewing last year, and usually find myself in rather slippery stuff.
Chris.
2 - Mayra Calvani
Thanks for your good wishes and for the great interview. Good luck with your book!
3 - Donna McDine
Hi Mayra...another great interview. Chris your insight on critique groups in my opinion was right on target..it made me chuckle out loud. Also, your repsonse to publishers is very informative.
Thanks,
Donna