Yes, on occasion. I respond to the author and/or publisher and explain that we strive for honest reviews of books, but realize that reviews are subjective. While one reader or reviewer may love a book, another one may not for various reasons. My stance is if you don't want an honest review of your book by a reviewer, then perhaps you shouldn't send us a copy for review. Also, keep in mind that one reviewer's take on a book does not necessarily reflect how I personally would view that book, nor is it the end-all, be-all review of the book.
What does your site offer readers?
We offer articles, interviews, columns and book reviews about all aspects of writing, authors and publishing. We also occasionally publish fiction and poetry, so there's a smorgasbord of available 'treats' for people who love to read.
What promotional opportunities does your site offer authors?
Authors may send us press releases about their upcoming book releases and we'll run them in our e-zine for no charge. In addition, if an author is launching a promotional tour, we'll run announcements on that as well. Finally, we do offer paid text ads and banners for more lengthy and concentrated exposure.
What is the most rewarding aspect of being a reviewer? The most challenging?
The most rewarding is, of course, discovering new authors and books that you may not have otherwise discovered. The most challenging is balancing the commitment to both readers and authors/publishers when it comes to a fair and honest assessment of a book.
Is there anything else you would like to say about you or Scribe & Quill?
I'd also like to invite readers to also visit a couple of my other sites they may find of interest: Sun Signs for Writers, Int'l Order of Horror Professionals site and my own website with links and information on my nonfiction and fiction books. Thanks for giving me this opportunity!
Thank you, Bev!
Article comments
1 - Joy Delgado
Mayra and Bev,
Thank you for another great interview. I like how you handle not totally positive reviews, the authors and/or publishers of those books. Very helpful information.
Joy
2 - A. F. Stewart
Terrific observations. I love that you post author press releases on your site; a great idea.
3 - Margot Finke
Mayra, I love Scribe and Quill. Your interview of Bev Walton-Porter shows how multi-talented one lady can be. WHEW! Enjoyed every word, mate.
Margot Finke
"Rattlesnake Jam"
Crazy rhyming fun with Gra,
Pa, and making rattler jam.
4 - Lesa Holstine
Mayra,
What a wonderful job you do with the interviews! Each interview is unique and brings out the flavor of the review site. Thank you.
5 - Diana
Thanks for such an informative interview!
6 - Pauline Jones
Also interesting! I'm learning so much, many thanks!
7 - Margay
Bev, I admire you for your take on reviewers and the question of ethics regarding paid reviews, etc. I think it is important for writers to get that kind of honest review - how else will they learn what appeals/doesn't appeal to the audience? How else will they grow as writers? I enjoyed your interview.