Book Review: I, robot by Howard S. Smith

I’ll admit it straight out. I haven’t read Isaac Asimov’s novel or seen the similar movie staring Will Smith. So I’ll tell you now that if you haven’t either, don’t worry. Although Howard S. Smith re-used the title (supposedly different because “robot” isn’t capitalized), his novel is not similar to the 1940s version.

Howard S. Smith is an MIT-trained engineer and artificial intelligence expert. He even helped create the self-checkout lanes I get stuck in at Wal-Mart! So you’d think with such experience and knowledge, Smith would have some input about the robotics field. Well, he does. But here it is unfortunately in the form of a fiction novel. 

When I picked up I, robot, I sincerely thought I’d be reading a non-fiction piece about the current artificial intelligence and robotic developments being used in military applications. I was pretty excited, especially considering Dr. Smith’s biography. However, I, robot follows fictional Japanese police investigator Haruto Suzuki, a man obsessed with following rules. When he investigates the mysterious death of a business man staying in one of Tokyo’s hotels, Haruto stumbles into a much bigger murderous plot. Japan is exchanging artificially intelligent robots for nuclear weapons from Israel.

Dr. Smith is not a bad fiction writer. His main character Haruto is an interesting man who, in contrast to the ever-learning and growing robots, has trouble escaping from his regiment of rules. Along with characters, Dr. Smith creates great action sequences that, for the most part, are an intense plot filler.

Altogether, I, robot is a global story woven right along the lines of our modern theologies and technologies (that is as long as your political views don’t distract you). And Dr. Smith uses his extensive knowledge of current military robots, which should have been the most excited part. But this is where the unfortunate part begins.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for Janica Unruh

Article Author: Janica Unruh

Janica Unruh has her Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from the college of Professional Writing at the University of Oklahoma. She is happily married to a very nerdy engineer and enjoys writing more than breathing, but refuses to give up the latter.

Visit Janica Unruh's author pageJanica Unruh's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • I,robot  (Howard S. Smith's I,robot) (Howard S. Smith's I,robot) I,robot (Howard S. Smith's I,robot) (Howard S. Smith's I,robot)

    A Whole New Story. "Innovative, fast-paced, and superbly written, this I,robot is honestly better than both of those stories [Isaac Asimov's book or Will Smith's movie] put together.” – ForeWord Magazine ...

Article comments

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.

blogcritics lists for Jul 03, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for June

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs