Book Review: Down to a Sunless Sea by Mathias Freese

If there's one thing we share collectively as human beings, it is the growth and maturity experienced through childhood and early adulthood. While everyone may have different experiences, childhood has certainly been the subject for countless writers throughout the ages. Whether it's James Joyce's Stephen Daedalus or Charles Schultz's Charlie Brown, artists have tried to make sense of their childhood while explaining essential parts of human experience.

In Down to a Sunless Sea, Mathias Freese delves into the darker aspects of childhood through 15 excellent stories. Freese's protagonists share dark secrets and tragic experiences, but by the end of each story, Freese leaves the reader with a sense of empathy for his young protagonists. They all deal with the things that plague young men in the 20th century (and beyond), such as shaving, making sense of friendship, parental abuse, and sexual desire, yet Freese's stories tackle these subjects head-on, giving each character depth and perspective beyond an idealistic view of childhood.

Freese allows his characters to speak for themselves, but uses his own experiences as a social worker to shape each character. In "I'll Make it, I Think," for example, the main character is a crippled young man who tries to make sense of his teenage life by naming his body parts, his new best friends: Ralph, his "bad hand," Lon, his other hand, and David, his penis. As he makes sense of his sexual desires, he wishes he could "go out with normal girls" but his webbed hands scare them away ("unless she's into frog"). According to the introduction, the character is based in part on Freese's crippled cousin. Freese doesn't just look at the young male's teenage years and leave it at that. Instead, Freese brings us into the young man's mind, showing us his pain and realization that he's different from others. Through physical frustration, Freese shows that the character has trouble dealing with his life and imagines taking "practice slashes" at his throat with his razor.

The characters in Down to a Sunless Sea are often coping with loss, and unavoidable pain, but somehow these characters show strength. "Herbie" is a story that deals with an abusive father's control over a son who still looks up to him. After Herbie's father shows him how to shine his shoes, Herbie and a friend hope to set up a shoe shine business, but his father won't have a son who shines shoes in the street. Herbie's situation (and his mixed feelings toward his father) is a scenario that Freese reveals without judgment; he shows how feelings toward loved ones are never cut and dried, especially in adolescence.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for kevin-eagan

Article Author: Kevin Eagan

Kevin Eagan is a Blogcritics Books Editor and (occasional) freelance writer based in the Greater St. Louis, MO area. He also writes at There There Kid, a blog that focuses on literature, culture, and music.

Visit Kevin Eagan's author pageKevin Eagan's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Down to a Sunless Sea Down to a Sunless Sea

    Down to a Sunless Sea plunges the reader into uncomfortable situations and into the minds of troubled characters. Each selection is a different reading experience-poetic, journalistic, nostalgic, wryly ...

  • The i Tetralogy The i Tetralogy
  • I I
  • Short Cuts: Selected Stories Short Cuts: Selected Stories
  • Tales of Ordinary Madness Tales of Ordinary Madness

Article comments

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 10, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs