Today on Blogcritics
Home » Books » Book Reviews » Book Review: ‘True Hollywood Noir: Filmland Mysteries and Murders’ by Dina Di Mambro

Book Review: ‘True Hollywood Noir: Filmland Mysteries and Murders’ by Dina Di Mambro

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

0021With the return of The Backstreet Boys and Jenny McCarthy, the ’90s are back in a big way. I could not think of a better time for A.J. “Fame…ain’t it a bitch” Benza to stage his comeback. If you were not watching the E! Mysteries and Scandals show back in the late ’90s, you need to YouTube it. I forgot how much I loved that show until I read the new True Hollywood Noir: Filmland Mysteries and Murders by Dina Di Mambro.

In today’s TMZ-dominated gossip culture, the bar has been lowered so far that a misplaced pout from one of the Kardashians qualifies as an outrage. With True Hollywood Noir, Di Mambro delivers the goods. She details 11 Hollywood murders, spanning the years 1922-2001, plus a twelfth chapter celebrating the life of gangster Mickey Cohen (1913-1976). Benza would be proud, if not a little jealous.

The books begins with the unsolved murder of director William Desmond Tyler in 1922. I like the fact that the author chose an opening case that was not quite as well-known as some of the others here, as it makes things more interesting. Besides the fact that all of these murders occurred in Hollywood, and involved prominent people, there are also multiple possible suspects.

Tyler may not have been as famous as D.W. Griffith, but as a three-term president of the Motion Picture Directors Association, he was a serious player in the business. When he was found shot in the back on February 22, 1922, the industry’s first reaction was to try and cover it up. Scandals were already a major problem in movie-land, thanks to the Fatty Arbuckle case. It appears that there are two main possibilities in the Tyler murder. He was very anti-drug, and could have stepped on some toes with his stance. And of course, there is the jilted-lover angle, of which there appears to have been numerous candidates as well.

A woman by the name of Margaret Gibson actually made a death-bed confession to the murder in 1964, and it seems pretty plausible. She was a former prostitute, opium-addict, and silent film actress, who knew him. They are all gone now though, and the case certainly offers an intriguing set of “what-if’s”.

I mentioned that I was impressed with Di Mambro’s choice of a lesser known scandal to open with, but she also includes a couple of well-known ones that I never tire of. The most recent case dates back to 2001, the same year that A.J. Benza was (hilariously) banned for life from the Howard Stern show.

For those who may not remember, Robert Blake was accused of murdering his wife, Bonny Lee Bakley that year. One of the things that set that case apart was just how bizarre the whole situation was. Blake was found innocent, but after reading about how Bakley tricked him into marrying her, one has to wonder if the jury just agreed that she needed to go.

My favorite chapter in the book has to be “The Secret Life of Bob Crane (1978).” This is another fairly well-known case, but it is a wild one. Crane starred as Colonel Robert Hogan on Hogan’s Heroes from 1965-1971. How they ever sold a situation comedy set in a Nazi prison camp is beyond me, but they did. It was hilarious and made him a star.

Although he was married, Crane used his status as a high-profile TV star to pick up women. Lots of women, as it turned out. In fact, he had what you could call an over-flow of willing women, who his buddy John Carpenter was all too willing to help him out with. In today’s world, with sexting all the rage, and the admission of being a “sex addict” enough to clear a guy of major repercussions, it is hard to believe the Crane scenario. Yet it happened.

Carpenter was his friend because he had video equipment. Very few people outside of the studios owned such expensive toys, but Carpenter did. So they videotaped their antics. Crane and Carpenter may not have been the first to do this, but in the early ‘70s, they were members of a very exclusive club. For various reasons though, Crane cut Carpenter out of the picture in 1978. He was found dead on June 29, two days after the two of them had been seen arguing in a bar. Although Carpenter was always the main suspect, he was never convicted of the grisly murder. Di Mambro details it all, and it is quite a story.

All of these cases are fascinating, as a matter of fact. It is not only the gossip factor at play in the deaths of people such as Natalie Wood, George Reeves, and the others. The author has chosen to describe situations that are incredibly unusual in and of themselves. The situations make for fascinating reading whether the people were famous or not.

The strangest chapter is the final one, “The Real Mickey Cohen.” It is the lengthiest chapter in the book, double the space of most of the others, and written as something of a tribute. Di Mambro talks about all sorts of good things that Mickey Cohen did in his life, including an incident with a young, female child in Las Vegas. She credits Cohen’s help in saving this girl’s life, and states that the girl would have surely died without it. She never says who the now-grown woman is, only that she is eternally grateful for Cohen’s help.

I bet even A.J. Benza could connect the dots on that one. Meanwhile, Dina Di Mambro does an excellent job of presenting the cases for us to connect the dots ourselves, in some of the strangest Hollywood murder mysteries of all time. True Hollywood Noir is an excellent read.

Powered by

About Greg Barbrick

  • Jim Beaver

    That first guy IS pretty well known to serious film buffs. His name is William Desmond Taylor, not Tyler, and there have been a number of fascinating books about his murder.

  • Jon Ponder

    Agree with Jim Beaver. The William Desmond TAYLOR case is one of the most notorious and written-about unsolved crimes in Hollywood. One reason it has been hard to crack is that studio executives got there first and tampered with evidence before police were called.

  • m. c.

    I think anyone believing a deathbed confession of the murder of Taylor, is not very well-versed in the history of this case. There have been hundreds of confessions over the years in this case, each one as looney as the next one. Charlotte Shelby, Mary Miles Minter’s mother, killed Taylor, as everyone with the smallest knowledge of Hollywood knows but it was never proven, because the DA at the time was blackmailing her…
    end of story. I read this guy’s book and it’s lame and so full of mistakes and facts made to fit theories, and “witnesses” no one has ever heard of that I think this book belong in the clearance bin at WALMART…