Home / Books / Book Reviews / Book Review: Georg Letham: Physician and Murderer by Ernst Weiss, Joel Rotenberg (Translator)

Book Review: Georg Letham: Physician and Murderer by Ernst Weiss, Joel Rotenberg (Translator)

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Georg Letham: Physician and Murderer by Ernst Weiss, a German-speaking Austrian Jew, is a fictional book and a German classic. The book has been recently translated to English.

Georg Letham is unhappy in his marriage but happy in his research. When the opportunity knocks he injects his older, wealthier, and well-insured wife with the lethal poison Agent Y. However, as good as a physician as Georg is he botches up the cover-up. Not only does he leave the syringe at the crime scene but also confesses to his father, an official in the Austrian bureaucracy.

Letham gets sentenced to a penal colony and continues to research yellow fever, being allowed to use methods he would never have been able to use in civilian life.

I was recommended Georg Letham by a fellow book blogger, Amy from The Black Sheep Dances. I have great respect for Amy — her taste is similar to mine. When you combine that with the fact that the book was published by Archipelago Books and praised by giants of literature, it’s a no brainer.

However, I have to admit that I had trouble getting through the second quarter of the book. I even had to put it down for a bit, read another book and get back to Georg Letham. I have been trying to figure out why – maybe my mind wasn’t into it, maybe it was the disquieting narrative, the prose — I have no idea why. I could only read this book in small sections. It was interesting for 75-100 pages or so and then I simply had to put it down. This book is disturbing. But, ultimately, I couldn’t stop reading it.

After I finished the book, I didn’t sit down and write my thoughts immediately. I rarely do that anyway, but I let the novel sink in and then it dawned on me – Georg Letham is psychological horror at its best. Not the horror novels one thinks about these days, but psychological-gothic horror which could hold its own against such masters as Poe and Kafka.

I am not a big fan of horror or gore. I’ve seen enough in the army to last me a lifetime — but this kind of horror is different. It’s the unease of revulsion and shock which accompanies the internal thoughts and conflicts of a murderous man — not a mad man, mind you — but a calculating, smart person whose first and foremost thought is to benefit mankind, which, coincidentally, he doesn’t even like and acknowledges his lack of sensitivity to. If one could write a book about the internal feelings of Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, or any other man who brings nightmares to life – this would be it.

Mr. Weiss’ vision of his narrator is social critique at its best, a looking glass into the transformation of the soul of a man who believes he cannot win over nature, that he is simply an experiment as are all of us; we are no better than the rats he talks so much about. The author understood the concept of “herd mentality” and it’s certainly something to keep in mind this time of year when you rush through the doors of your favorite store to buy some idiotic toy.

Georg Letham: Physician and Murderer, while long, is actually a series of short stories with some very disturbing scenes involving dogs and mainly rats, and rats, and some more rats. The writing style, which involves stories within stories, when done right, could be brilliant. However, the construction of the story (not the translation) is clunky but that could be on purpose due to the skeptical and ironic relationship Georg Letham has with himself. As the subtitle suggests, he’s a complex character, a cold, calculating man (imagine House or Holmes without the sidekicks that keep them grounded) who convinces himself that he is in the right committing crimes using passion as his logic instead of reason and intellect for which he justifies everything else.

Powered by

About manoflabook