Home / Books / Book Reviews / Book Review: Fifty Shames of Earl Grey: A Parody by Fanny Merkin (aka Andrew Shaffer)

Book Review: Fifty Shames of Earl Grey: A Parody by Fanny Merkin (aka Andrew Shaffer)

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+2Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Fifty Shames of Earl Grey by Fanny Merkin (A.K.A. Andrew Shaffer) is a parody of E.L. James’s series, Fifty Shades of Grey. The debut encompasses various other aspects of pop culture, offering witty commentary from both the protagonist, Anna Steal, and her romantic interest, Earl Grey.

Shaffer is aware that Anna is not the most reliable character in his book and he plays with this revelation. Anna acts as his example when he criticizes the weak female protagonists literature has adopted, the narcissistic male billionaire characters, and the farfetched plot twists employed in recent novels.

Shaffer persuades his readers to notice the flaws in our current society. He challenges us to question who we are idolizing and what the effects of such adoration could be. He also comments on the state of the modern novel. A terrifying prediction that rings true if we continue to entertain weak protagonists and the relationships they have with other characters. Whereas humorous for the most part, this novel is a serious examination of the ludicrous fads overwhelming society.

Shaffer’s writing is fast-paced, fresh, and entertaining. This book does require some knowledge of Fifty Shades of Grey and Twilight, since the underlying dark humor isn’t always blatantly clear. A person not privy to the general plots of either books may not understand the meaning behind Shaffer’s satirical novel.

The reader must observe Shaffer’s ability to comment on the cliches of erotic and romantic literature without seeming pretentious. This can be seen when he creates a hysterical mood that shatters the illusion of romance by overusing cliched words. The word “Gaze” appears to be one of his favourites.

There are moments where the humor tends to feel a bit forced, the jokes slipping right past me. But for the greater part, I could not stop laughing. Shaffer is able to draw out humor from content that is disturbing in nature.

Andrew Shaffer’s book is a mean feat, considering he wrote it in 10 days. A satirical look at pop culture and our society, Fifty Shames of Earl Grey is a comical debut that will have you giggling until the conclusion.

Powered by

About Dayla F.M.

  • Melanie Jones

    I just released my own parody, Fifty Shades of Brown which I’d be really interested to hear your views on. I had so many problems with the original that I felt like satirizing it would be the best way to reveal them and have fun with them… It’s not the first parody to be released by any means but I think, like Shaffer’s it has more going for it than a lot of the amateur “quick cash in” ones I’ve seen.

  • Your novella looks very intriguing! I would be honored to give a gander and give you my views on it. Thanks for informing me!

    Also, thank you for reading my review. I’m very happy that it prompted you to ask me to read your novella and give you my insights on it.