Today on Blogcritics
Home » Film » Blu-ray Review: Sherlock Jr. and Three Ages

Blu-ray Review: Sherlock Jr. and Three Ages

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

The Films

Buster Keaton’s comedic prowess and technical virtuosity are on full display in Sherlock Jr. and Three Ages, a pair of silent comedies bundled together in Kino’s latest Keaton Blu-ray release, following superb upgrades of The General and Steamboat Bill, Jr.

Of course, the real attraction here is Sherlock Jr., which is one of Keaton’s greatest accomplishments — a potent and uproariously funny deconstruction of the movie-making process that makes every one of its 44 minutes count — but the inclusion of Three Ages is a welcome one.

Sherlock Jr. stars Keaton as a movie projectionist who dreams of becoming a detective when he isn’t working to win the heart of a beautiful girl (Kathryn McGuire). He tries to win her over with chocolates and a ring, but is outshone by a richer man (Ward Crane), who presents her with nicer gifts.

When the girl’s father (Joe Keaton) discovers his watch has been stolen, the projectionist aims to put his detective knowledge to work, but ends up being framed by the perpetrator, leading to his falling out with the girl he longs for.

Later, while working at the movie theater, he falls asleep and imagines himself entering the very film that’s being projected, which Keaton pulls off with an astonishing bit of practical movie magic. Inside the world of the film, he must solve the case of a stolen string of pearls, and this time, he’ll have a little more success.

Sherlock Jr. is a breathlessly funny film that proceeds at breakneck speed, offering up sight gag after sight gag in a tightly packed ball of physical comedy. It also features some of his most elaborate stunts, including a bit with a water tower that fractured Keaton’s neck — a fact he didn’t discover until years later. In Sherlock Jr., a character’s life is transformed by his association with the movies — a fitting fate for Keaton, whose transformative influence on cinema can’t be overstated.

With Three Ages, Keaton gives us three intertwined love stories, set across the expanse of time, in a parody of D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance. In each segment, Keaton plays an underdog trying to win the heart of a girl (Margaret Leahy), but failing to measure up against the far more impressive rival (Wallace Beery). The events follow a similar pattern in the Stone Age, Ancient Rome and the present Jazz Age.

Three Ages can feel a little repetitive — after all, all three stories purport to tell essentially the same tale — but Keaton’s knack for turning pratfalls into a thing of beauty is marvelously displayed here.

The Blu-ray Disc

Both films are presented on a single disc, with a 1080p transfer for Sherlock Jr. and a 1080i transfer for Three Ages. Both are presented in their original 1.33:1 aspect ratios.

The visual presentation for Sherlock Jr. isn’t quite as impressive as Kino’s for The General or Steamboat Bill, but it’s still a very pleasing transfer, with an excellent range of grays, nice black-and-white contrast and no signs of pesky digital manipulation. The print has its share of marks and scratches, but nothing too distracting, and the image is overall infused with so much fine detail, it’s never looked better.

The interlaced transfer for Three Ages might cause some viewers to pause, but honestly, a progressive transfer probably wouldn’t have made much of a difference. The only surviving print of the film has been riddled with nitrate decomposition, which shows up fairly often here. Still, the film is very watchable, and the high def presentation does add increased clarity and black-and-white contrast.

Both films feature a variety of scores to choose from, with Sherlock Jr. receiving a wonderfully full sounding 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track from the Mont Alto Orchestra, that same track in a lossless stereo version, a stereo version of a Club Foot Orchestra score and a vintage jazz score compiled by Jay Ward.

Three Ages has a score arranged by Robert Israel in a lossless stereo track, a mono organ score by Lee Erwin and a mono piano score.

Special Features

Kino has assembled an excellent selection of extras here. For Sherlock, we get an audio commentary from historian David Kalat, a 20-minute making-of by David Pearson, who discusses the rehabilitation of the film’s reputation over the years and its technical prowess, a visual essay on the film’s shooting locations by author John Bengtson and a large collection of stills.

On the Three Ages side, a similar visual essay from Bengtson is included, along with an excerpt from D.W. Griffith’s short film Man’s Genesis, which partly inspired the film, re-edits of the three sections to make them stand-alone short films and a collection of stills.

The Bottom Line

Kino continues its winning streak of Keaton Blu-rays with this excellent package.

Powered by

About Dusty Somers

Dusty Somers is a Seattle-based editor and writer. He is a member of the Online Film Critics Society and Seattle Theater Writers.