Home / Culture and Society / Science and Technology / Blogcritics Way Out Front on Bayh Story

Blogcritics Way Out Front on Bayh Story

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Over the past few years, the mainstream media has tried to dismiss bloggers and other emerging media outlets as rank amateurs. It's claimed that our sources are unreliable, our investigation methods are shaky, and all in all, bloggers are considered to be an unprofessional lot who serve no useful purpose in the reporting process.

Unfortunately, these same words can easily be used to describe the mainstream media. One need only to look to the story of John Mark Karr to see a vivid example of how the media runs with a story with little or no merit. As you probably remember, John Mark Karr "confessed" to killing JonBenet Ramsey, and for weeks, he held the media spellbound with his "confession" to the murder, although evidence placed him elsewhere at the time of the killing.

Now, in many cases, it's an emerging media writer who breaks a story that is then picked up by the mainstream. A case in point is the relationship of Senator Evan Bayh (D-Indiana) and his wife Susan, who sits on the board of directors of no less than six corporations.

I broke this story in an article on Blogcritics on July 3, 2007. The article, Making Hay While the Sun Shines: How the Power of Influence Influences Power, details how the Bayh family built their fortune on Susan Bayh's ongoing role as a professional director. Of course, this creates at least the impression of a conflict of interest, since Senator Bayh sits on key committees that influence policy crucial to the success of Mrs. Bayh's companies.

On Sunday, Sylvia Smith "broke" this story in the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette. This feature article serves as a signature piece for her, since this is her first report since being elected president of the National Press Club.

This story has huge implications for the upcoming presidential election in 2008, since Senator Bayh has recently endorsed Hillary Clinton, and he is also widely regarded as being on Senator Clinton's short list of running mates.

This is yet another example of how the emerging media played a huge role by being far out in front of a story that has enough legitimacy to be picked up by a respected mainstream jounalist and have national implications.

The blogosphere was over six months ahead of the mainstream media, and this bodes well for the future of emerging media throughout the world. If the mainstream media does not embrace the blogging community and see it for the value it has, it's just a matter of time before emerging media takes over the mainstream.

Powered by

About The Insurance Guy

  • I apologise if this appears in addition to a previous comment I sent and which may have been lost as I was cutoff – possibly by God or some other deity devoted to quality control in blog comments.
    To shorten my previous ramble, I would say Alec has a very good point, but speaking from a British point of view and looking at our national press (local is often better) one is inclined to say: Well, they don’t do any better.
    Opinion and partizanship from the front page back, scare stories, sensationalism, mawkishness or ghoulishness in tragedy and horror, celebrity shite and much, much, more can be laid at the door of our national media.
    But, I don’t see why Rick shouldn’t dispute Ms Smith’s claim, for what it’s worth – albeit that she could have made that claim in ignorance of the earlier story.


  • Heloise

    Hey, I was just saying the same. These F(&(*^ are stealing from online writers and bloggers and we get NO CREDIT. The only claim to fame is that we don’t know what the hell we are talking about.

    We should revolt and shut the Internet down for a week and see how they weep!!


    Mad as hell and not going to take plaigerisers anymore….

  • This is happening more and more frequently. A blogger breaks a story (or takes a novel point of view on an issue), and then days/weeks/months later, the MSM “re-breaks” the story…and then it quickly becomes the conventional wisdom.

    The problem we face as bloggers is that the noise-to-substance ratio is still very high overall in the blogosphere. Therefore, we do not have the same level of credibility as the MSM (even though their credibility with the public is poor at best). But still, we are “scooping” them more and more, and I believe this is an overall positive development.

  • Alec

    RE: The blogosphere was over six months ahead of the mainstream media, and this bodes well for the future of emerging media throughout the world.

    Yawn. Most bloggers are not reporters, but are advocates, pundits and other uninformed purveryors of opinion, who delude themselves by inhaling their own gasses. They, heck, we, have some value as people who offer our opinions, and bloggers who are local to a story may have something useful to offer, but the idea that bloggers are some kind of alternative to the mainstream media is ludicrous.