Home / Blogcritics Pick the Best Song of 2005

Blogcritics Pick the Best Song of 2005

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

The second installment in our Best of 2005, here is a small sampling of the regular music reviewers on Blogcritics picking the best song of 2005. Everyone is invited and encouraged to share their choices in the comment section.

1. Matthew Freelove

“Upon This Tidal Wave Of Young Blood” — Clap Your Hands Say Yeah

The self-released debut album from this Brooklyn/Philly five piece is an exhilarating indie pop romp that demands multiple listens. The gem of the album, though, is its closer, and my choice for song of the year, “Upon This Tidal Wave Of Young Blood”. The frantic guitar strumming is led by lead singer Alec Ounsworth’s biting commentary on post-9/11 Bush war policy. When seeing CYHSY live this is the song the indie kids want to hear. In a perfect world this song would be top 40.

2. Robert Burke

“Blood Machine” — Chad VanGaalen

My pick for best song took some time as there were so many great songs created this year. I had a pool of hundreds that could have made the cut. In the end however, I chose the song “Blood Machine” by Chad VanGaalen. Chad was discovered by Sub Pop Records up in Canada where he was quietly recording song after song in his bedroom. His debut album Infiniheart includes the very best of his self-produced work. “Blood Machine” is a beautiful, melancholy track complete with cello. It tells the story of a community of people living underground who are all connected to a central “blood machine” that keeps them alive.

“The people had their hearts plugged into a giant machine that could circulate blood. Please, please, please help us escape from the blood machine.”

Far out, creative stuff.

3. gypseyman

“I Ain’t Going Nowhere” — Rick Moranis from the album The Agoraphobic Cowboy

Yes, that’s right, the same Rick Moranis of Bob and Doug Mackenzie and Honey I Shrunk The Kids fame released an album this year. An album that will fly so far under the radar that it will run into parked cars, but one of the best collections of satirical songs published since the hay days of Tom Lerher.

“I Ain’t Going Nowhere” appropriates the tune from the old Tom T. Hall song “I’ve Been Everywhere” and replaces the lyrics with ones that keep the tenor of our times. A peon to the joys of staying at home and all our fears of leaving the house, “I Ain’t Going Nowhere” is side splittingly funny and painfully true all at once.

From the high-speed itemization of the drugs, gadgets, and simple comforts that make a man’s home his bunker to the absolute perfection of the musicianship (this album has some of the best country picking I have heard in a long time) it’s not only funny but musically a great song.

Satire is difficult to master most of the time, musical satire even harder. “I Ain’t Going Nowhere” gets my nod for song of the year for its successful accomplishment of both goals. For a full review of Agoraphobic Cowboy go here

4. duke de mondo

“Welcome To Jamrock” — Damian Marley

First time I heard “Welcome To Jamrock”, it’s fair to say, I shat half my body weight out my face. “The hell is this wonder?” I got to screechin, this brilliant, socially-conscious, insanely intoxicatin burst a reggae / hip-hop / punk abandon? Turns out it was the work of this Damian “Jnr. Gong” Marley, one a Bob’s youngsters, and the very first to not only be listenable, but also to produce a track that is easily as good as even the best a the old fella’s work. It’s incendiary, reekin a anger an rebellion, an it makes the The Duke bop in the sortsa ways should by all rights be illegal.

5. Al Barger

“You Like My Song” — Geoff Reacher

This dude from Athens, GA that no one ever heard of made the best record all year. This electronic folk song comes out sounding like sugar coated pop music. The freaky stuff he’s doing with the guitars by the end almost would qualify this song for the Dr Demento show.

But the meditation on mortality is quite serious. He’s got a really cute promo poster for this with the grim reaper conspiring against him. Still, “Hearses circling your house.” That rings real.

Perhaps the author will disabuse my interpretations of his art, but I take it to be a “life’s too short” theme addressed to an ex. “The world broke your heart baby, I’m just chimin’ in”.

Geoff Reacher conjured up a rootsy electronic novelty that is just the prettiest, cleverest pop treat going- with some real spiritual substance.

Let’s conclude with this interesting note from his website describing the careful and specific artistic discipline that served him very well here. ” ‘You Like My Song’ sounds live because it is: a heretofore unrealized amalgam of raw country folk with the DJ arts, sequenced and variously twisted in real time using a foot pedal rig”

6. Zach Hoskins of the Modern Pea Pod

“Fistful of Love” — Antony & The Johnsons from the album I am a Bird Now

To record a breakthrough album with a bevy of guest stars and still end up with one of the most riveting personal records in recent memory takes a great artist indeed. Case in point: Antony has the balls to open “Fistful of Love” with a spoken-word poem by no less a personage than Lou Fucking Reed – and damned if we don’t all but ignore the old guy the moment our heroine’s unmistakable voice thrusts itself firmly into the mix. With its Southern soul flavorings and Antony’s passionate vocals, “Fistful” is a genuinely affecting song. But pay close attention to the lyrics, an unsettling mix of black humor and heartfelt confessional where fists take the place of lips and bruises are “symbols of devotion,” and the effect is just devastating. Is this a paean to sadomasochism, domestic abuse, or something else entirely? At the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter. What matters is this emotionally intense, thrilling love song, about the same kind of frightening love that made Sada Abe strangle and castrate Ishida Kichizou. A remarkable song from a truly remarkable record.

7. Mark Saleski

“Poor Little Rich Boy” – Regina Spektor

Probably flying beneath most people’s radar, Regina Spektor fairly well dropped me to my knees with the crystalline pop goodness of Soviet Kitsch.

When records like this come along, I have the urge to buy up a bunch of copies and hand them out on the street. Comparisons to Tori Amos are too easy (and a little bit unfair) but if you take the power of Little Earthquakes and add a high degree of quirk, you’re on your way.

“Poor Little Rich Boy” shows off Spektor’s vocal charms as well as her penchant for the unusual, in this case it’s the added element of percussion via a board whacked with a stick.

Read my Review here.

8. Jon Sobel

(Jon made all of his choices from Indie releases as it is his “stomping ground” on Blogcritics)

“I Don’t Know” — Nicola from the album What’s the Point

In addition to putting on a killer stage show, Nicola writes some of the most captivating songs out there. This one rocks, it has passion, and it’s super-catchy.

9. Connie Phillips

“Clyde” – Eric Himan, from the album Dark Horse

This category was the hardest one for me to pick. There are so many great songs out there, but I kept coming back to “Clyde” over and over.
Himan is a young independent artist who caters to the college audience, but this offering is that of an aged soul. It’s a poetic masterpiece, full of metaphoric language and backed up with a beautifully orchestrated piano. Singing of a painful break-up, he delivers the lyrics with a wailing that is in perfect pitch and enough to leave me awestruck.

“I have been waiting here,
For you to fetch the getaway car,
You took the money and the jewels,
I’m thinking I’m no prize at all,
Cause I’ve been replaced.”

My review of Dark Horse, done earlier this year, can be found here.

10. Katharine Donelson

“15 Beers Ago” – The Deaf Pedestrians

Mostly, I read these things and song of the year is always something that everyone else absolutely adored and that I’ve heard so many times it makes me want to stick sharp, pointy things in my ears. So, instead of picking something that is technically flawless and the work of angels or that was at the very least popular, I’ve picked something that makes me smile every time I hear it. The Deaf Pedestrian’s 15 Beers Ago is straight forward “I hate you, you fucked me over” rock. It’s bitter, it’s cynical, and it’s funny. I dig it.

11. Temple Stark

Paul McCartney – This Never Happened Before, from the album Chaos and Creation in the Backyard.

I didn’t want to pick anything off this album. I’m not really a McCartney music fan. I liked CACITB, wouldn’t have bought it myself though (and would have been disappointed if someone had bought it for me). But I’ve listened to it and I still love how its chords and depth fills a room.

It’s stuck with me and if there was a Top 25 list I had the time to create the album would be somewhere in there. But this song, in particular, has embedded itself in my conscience. It keeps on popping up and I find myself whisper-singing it under my breath in moments of stress. It’s a gentle tune about love. But because the song seems to be lifting and moving towards a big flourish, it also seems to hint at missed opportunity, somewhere, somehow because it doesn’t quite get there, and ends in plucked harp strings.

Of course, that could just be me waiting for the big bass drums and the shredding guitar riff to kick in.

I’m ve-ry sure, this never happ-ened to me before.

See also Nina Gordon’s acoustic Straight Outta Compton (I would have picked this but from what I could tell it was released at the end of 2004.)

Here are the Blogcritics picks for the Best Album of 2005, and Best Group/Duo..

In the coming days, look for Blogcritics choices for Best Artist of 2005.

Wondering what Blogcritics are picking in the other catagories? Read about Blogcritics on ’05’s Best

Powered by

About Connie Phillips

  • bestsong

    Wings of a BUtterfly, by HIM

  • Because of You.

  • It’s like I figured when I set out on this venture, we’d all end up picking stuff that I’d have heard of. Even Temple’s pick was new to me. Of course since I don’t listen to the radio, almost all songs that I don’t have on my personal play list are new to me.

    Going through these selections and the best song and group selections makes me think I need to broaden my playlist. Anything that makes Duke shit his face off has to be worth listening to.

  • Baronius

    JP, I admire GW Bush and support most of his policies, but “When The President Talks To God” is a heck of a song. Emotionally powerful and musically interesting. I’d like to punch the guy who sings it in the nose, then get his autograph.

  • Ok, my song of the year choice for today is “Publish my Love” by Rogue Wave.

  • J. P. Spencer

    My vote is for “When The President Talks To God” by Bright Eyes. These times we live call for voices brave enough to address the horrid situation we find ourselves in in this country. This song was the only one I realy came across that tackled the problem head on, instead of looking for excuses to turn our collective heads.

  • picking the best song of the year is hard, and with too much deliberation i’d never be able to do it. but when i just allowed a single song to pop into my head and then stopped deliberating, the song that came up was “land locked blues” by bright eyes. the lyrics and delivery blow me away.

  • Thanks. I absolutely love the whole album; such a unique voice, in more ways than one.

  • Zach—great choice with “Fistful of Love”–fucking brilliant song.

  • Nice to see that Chad VanGaalen song…I’ve been discovering more things to love about his album each time I listen to it. So much better than the usual indie singer/songwriter flavor of the month stuff.

  • zingzing

    “banshee beat” by the animal collective (it’s on feels).

  • Temple Stark

    Reading the entire selection from everyone is is pretty fascinating.

    >>Mostly, I read these things and song of the year is always something that everyone else absolutely adored and that I’ve heard so many times it makes me want to stick sharp, pointy things in my ears

    Yep, couldn’t agree more.

    Still, my pick could be consdered fairly mainstream but I gotta be truthful; it stuck.

  • wow…best song of the year. How on earth can you pick only one?

    If I had to make an on the spot decision, I’d say “These are the Fables” by The New Pornographers because I’ve been listening to it all day.

    But it’ll probably change by tomorrow.

  • “My So-Called Celibate Life” by The Pernice Brothers.

    My list is coming, and that right soon.