DVD Review: Supernatural - Season Three
Published September 12, 2008
There’s no greater feeling of excitement than opening the mailbox and seeing a large cushioned mailer stuffed tightly in there, delivering something that I’ve been eagerly anticipating since pre-ordering in May. After skipping inside and tearing open the package in delight, the contents slide out, revealing in full glossy colors the Winchester brothers. My day just got happy.
Yes, Supernatural - Season 3 on DVD has arrived from Amazon, all ready for my critical review and intense examination. It knows that I’ll be nitpicking every detail, and it’s ready. Granted, I’m not an experienced DVD reviewer, but the way I see it, DVDs are judged on packaging, bonus materials, and of course the season itself. This set manages to do all that well, even though it was one DVD short due to the abbreviated season.
The packaging looks great to me, probably because it’s exactly like the other two seasons. They didn’t change what wasn’t broken, so that earns points. This year’s cover is a perfect reflection of the season’s mood, more so than the other two (especially season two). Sam is in front this time, giving us his standard moody and pensive glare, while Dean is behind him looking down. Throw in the Impala in the background standing watch (the way it should be) and a picture of the crossroads where this season’s mess all began, and it’s all good. Very good.
The extras are a little lacking, but even season two was light. Only season one had the truly exceptional extras. What we were given is decent. This year, there are small scene commentaries for various episodes. Granted, I never liked full episode commentaries, so I like this idea. Most full episode commentaries seem like filler and usually only a couple of interesting tidbits are revealed. It’s much better to have Eric Kripke, Kim Manners, Sera Gamble, and Ben Edlund come on and explain in a few minutes what went into that episode. The only trouble is I wanted to see that for all the episodes. “Mystery Spot” is one of the most intriguing and wildly creative episodes of the season, yet there’s no commentary. None for the finale either. Even "Red Sky At Morning" had something. Come on!
Having said that, the true gem of the extras is the feature on special and visual effects. Seeing what goes into the process is fascinating, and it certainly points out all the little things we take for granted when watching the episodes. What they give us is detailed and long too, and it’s a delight to see how everyone works so well behind the scenes. For example, when Kim Manners says he wants lots of blood, the visual effects guys go all out, working tirelessly to get the right consistency, the most effective trajectory, and the perfect amount to splat on the wall. Great stuff. Also, generating black smoke on a computer is some really intense work, and it’s really fun to watch how excited these guys get over beheadings.
- DVD Review: Supernatural - Season Three
- Published: September 12, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Cult, Video: Drama, Video: Horror, Video: Television
- Part of a feature: The Winchester Family Business: Supernatural
- Writer: Alice Jester
- Alice Jester's BC Writer page
- Alice Jester's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
I don't know. I heard a tons of "ehs" hanging around Sault Ste. Marie and parts of southern Ontario. Then again, "yoopers" in Northern Michigan talk that way too, so it could be a regional thing, like "y'all" in Texas. For the record, I absolutely love the way Canadians talk.
Thanks for the clarification, and the comment!
Alice, I agree with you wholeheartedly! For all its shortened length and interrupted arc, it brought much to treasure. Jensen, Jared, and Jim all left me aching to be able to hug their characters and somehow make them feel better: their emotions were all so raw and so real, and the grief and the loss so pervasive, that they came right out of the television set.
I really missed getting some kind of commentary and insight on all the episodes that didn't have little commentary featurettes. I like episode commentary when it's done well for all the things I can learn from it, but you have a point; most commentary is pretty empty, while these little focused snippets gave us spotlight detail. If only they'd been offered on ALL the episodes! And I really would have loved to have seen a behind-the-scenes look at No Rest For the Wicked and the crafting of those final two scenes.
Finally, I was disappointed in the gag reel. Gag reels are MUCH funnier when they're comprised of actual flubs rather than of self-aware clowning around. Trying to slam the car doors in unison in season one? Hysterical! Getting slightly irritable doing multiple takes where the lines and the props just don't combine in season two, and then realizing that you've broken the prop? To die for! I would have given a lot to see the flubbed takes of simultaneous diner dialogue in Mystery Spot. Sigh.
But season four beckons, and from everything I've heard, promises to be wicked good! Now if only we could get rid of those annoying network advertising bugs ... could we start an extermination campaign?
Yep, the bloopers are better than mugging for the camera. I loved the bloopers where Jared could not get the window latch opened with the knife (from season 2?) even though it was totally unlocked, and when Jensen broke the chair when he was tied up in Hunted.
The Impala segment was good, though too short. The VFX segment was just right in length. I agree it would have been better if they had gone through the entire season. Both of those segments showed how much the crew loves their jobs though which was awesome.
Some of the best episodes didn't have enough (particularly Mystery Spot and NRFW). Maybe they will add more extras when they do the series boxset eventually.
The best part of the DVDs though is being able to see the full story unfold like a movie. Of course the downside is that it's very difficult to watch just one episode at a time.
I adore your 'important lessons' list. *snerk* And one of my favorite scenes is one that you've already touched upon: the Dean vs. Dean scene. I still get chills no matter that I've watched the episode at least half a dozen times.
Oh and the finale is so NOT easier to watch the second time around. I still burst into tears at the end.
Sault Ste. Marie hey - well ya, that's Eastern Canada - us West Coasters, we sound completely different! GRIN
There is definitely a difference in slang and pronunciation from province to province. Those of us who were born in the Pacific Northwest generally have the least amount of decernable accent in Canada.
I don't live that far from Vancouver actually. I am, however on an island so even though I'd love to wander over to Vancouver for the day and see if I could see the set, it's cost prohibitive to ride the ferry over just for that. :(
As for the Season 3 box set - I was a bit disappointed that there were no commentaries. And I also don't get why there were no bloopers included from Mystery Spot, etc. I would loved to have seen more about that episode and agree that there should have been a ton of footage from that scene with Jared and Jensen talking at the same time. Hmmm, well, perhaps we'll get it eventually??





So the crew sounds real Canadian eh? Well that might be because most of them are. LOL. They hire locally for those jobs because it would cost them way to much of their budget to bring everyone in they needed from the US.
And just for the record, many of us Canadians rarely, if ever, say eh?. GRIN
I love your reviews. I think you have a great talent. Thanks for writing.