Music Review: B.B. King - One Kind Favor
Published August 29, 2008
Innovation can be overrated. Change for change's sake is just that, neither inherently good nor bad. You have to read the fine print. Don't ever bet things can't get worse, that there's nowhere further to fall. That's a sucker's bet, one that many have lost. There's a lot to be said for knowing who you are, what you do, and where you live.
I've always preferred the traditional to the modern when it comes to the blues. I know there are some who argue for the genre to flourish it must grow. Doesn't it get stale if you never venture outside the comfort zone? Isn't experimentation vital to an artist, a genre? It's debatable. To quote Springsteen, "What if what you do to survive kills the things you love?" As with most things, balance is key. It's good to venture out there a ways as long as you're tethered to something to bring you back or you leave a trail of breadcrumbs if you lose your way.
I scoffed a little when I heard B.B. King was going to make a "back to basics" record of blues standards. The idea felt a little gimmicky to me. It's not as though King's discography is littered with wild variations. He's the King of the Blues and a National Treasure. How far is that journey back to the basics? Will we notice the difference? Is it one worth taking?
King considered some of these things when the idea was pitched to him by producer T Bone Burnett. Could the B.B. King of today get back into the mind, mode, and sound of the B.B. King of the '50s? Even if the idea of back to basics seemed gimmicky on the surface, that question is an intriguing one, made all the more tantalizing by the group of people he surrounded himself with to answer it. With producer Burnett to guide, King, legendary pianist Dr. John, bassist Nathan East (Eric Clapton), and drummer Jim Keltner, followed a course to find the answer with 12 carefully selected songs.
Josh Hathaway is a Senior Editor for BC Magazine. He is formerly an award-winning journalist and broadcaster and publishes the BC Network site Confessions of a Fanboy.
- Music Review: B.B. King - One Kind Favor
- Published: August 29, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Review, Music: Blues
- Writer: Josh Hathaway
- Josh Hathaway's BC Writer page
- Josh Hathaway's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments on this articleComments
Thanks, Mark. Yeah, I think you'll love this one. I have "See That My Grave Is Kept Clean" permanently etched in my head. It's a fabulous performance of that song.
This has such a vintage feel. Voice and guitar are mixed up front, live in the studio, vintage equipment, no fuckin' ProTools (you hear me, Mr. Clapton??)! The horns are arranged in that same sort of style, too. I risk talking out of my ass as I'm not a real student of jazz, but I hear such a jazz and swing influence on this record.
T Bone Burnett for President.
"I risk talking out of my ass as I'm not a real student of jazz, but I hear such a jazz and swing influence on this record."
No sir, you're not talking out your ass; parts of this record reminds me of the jazzy, swinging blues of another T-Bone: Walker.
Well thanks, Pico, but I believe the official BC party line is that I do in fact speak from my gluteus. :-)
Johnny Winter did much the same thing when he first recorded Muddy Waters. He put all the players back into one studio and all that sound feeding through amps and mics and such added to the depth of the recording. Seems like Burnett learned the lesson well.
Personally, I'm tired of all the overproduced slickness. I want the music to sound like a bunch of friends getting together to make good music, y'know?
I just got a copy of this CD, Josh. I'm likin' it, too.
Yes, excellent, the Johnny Winters/Muddy Waters albums are very good points of reference. Burnett and King took it one step further in trying to go "back to the future" if you will but both are great examples. One Kind Favor isn't quite as awesome as Hard Again, but it sits nicely with I'm Ready.
Add your comment, speak your mind
(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/80602)
great review josh. i just have to get this cd.
you know, it's interesting how effective this back to basics kind of thing can be. heck, it even works in the realm of modern country. well ok, the modern country artist. i'm talking about Martina McBride. when she put out that truly traditional record, it really pointed out that neo-country shares the same set of problems as pop and rock music: no "air" in the music.
...and it got me to thinking: what would happen if a modern rock band tried to recreate the sound of a good mid-70's recording?
anyway, this one's on my gotta have list.