REVIEW

Gear Review: Pelican PS2-to-PS3 Controller Adapter

Written by Mark Buckingham
Published July 27, 2008

You'll see these things marketed a variety of ways, from a dance pad adapter to a guitar controller converter, but they all do the same thing: make PS2 controllers work with your PS3. This has a few distinct advantages, from saving battery life in the cordless PS3 controllers to reusing controllers yo've already invested in. It also has a few disadvantages. Let's take a closer look.

When I bought my PS3 over a year ago, dropping about $500 for a console was asking a bit much, and when you throw in a couple games with that, its enough to wipe your savings out quick. The system came with one wireless controller and a two-foot USB charging cable, hardly long enough to play from the couch if your batteries are low. On top of that, you can't swap out the batteries should the controller wear out down the road, and at $50 each, I'm not eager to buy more PS3 controllers. I was in need of a better solution.

Enter these controller adapters. Granted, the one mentioned in the title is one of the first, and I don't think it's actually in production anymore, but several other manufacturers have stepped in to pick up the slack. Most of the complaints I've heard about these things are leveled at the fact that Guitar Hero 2 doesn't work properly with them. It does work, just not exactly how it should. You can't properly execute hammer-ons and pull-offs for some reason. The controller doesn't register buttons until and unless the strum bar is plucked. However, this was explained pretty clearly in the documentation that came with the adapter. I don't see how people can be that upset when they put it right on the box.

Also, don't people play anything besides GH2? What about God of War or Need for Speed or any of a thousand other excellent games? When the adapter works for all but one or two games among hundreds, I have a hard time feeling that bad for those who fall down crying about it. Of course, being able to play any of these PS2 games on your PS3 depends on which model of the hardware you got. I have a 60GB, which was the last model to include the original full hardware backward compatibility. From what I understand, the 40GB model doesn't feature hardware or software compatibility for PS2 games, and once the 80GB is phased out, word is that unfortunately PS2 backward compatibility will be nixed from all future PS3 SKUs.

This begs the question: does the adapter allow you to use PS2 controllers to play PS3-specific games? The answer is yes, most of the time. The main thing missing is Sixaxis support since PS2 controllers simply don't have the built-in hardware to do that, and fortunately, not many games rely on it heavily (I'm looking at you, Lair and flOw).

The other thing you'll run into is rumble, or a lack thereof. In both PS2 and PS3 games, rumble has not worked yet through these adapters. However, with rumble being included from now on with the Dual Shock 3, a firmware upgrade may make it work. As it stands, on a 60GB PS3 with firmware v2.41, I get no rumble with a PS2 controller running through one of these adapters playing The Incredible Hulk. If ever there was a game that cried out for rumble, that was it. It's supported in the game according to the Options Menu, and probably works with a standard $60 Dual Shock 3. But hey, you could get three PS2 controllers for that much, and just live without force feedback.

page 1 | 2
Mark Buckingham (not to be mistaken for the comic book artist) is an avid freelance writer, gamer, techhead, reader, movie watcher, pianist, and hockey player. Try to keep up.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Gear Review: Pelican PS2-to-PS3 Controller Adapter
Published: July 27, 2008
Type: Review
Section: Gaming
Filed Under: Gaming: Gear, Gaming: Computer, Gaming: PlayStation 2, Gaming: PlayStation 3, Review
Writer: Mark Buckingham
Mark Buckingham's BC Writer page
Mark Buckingham's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Mark Buckingham
Gaming: Gear
Gaming: Computer
Gaming: PlayStation 2
Gaming: PlayStation 3
Review
All Gaming Articles
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — July 28, 2008 @ 02:41AM — Brad

I wonder if any PS2 to USB adapter would work on the PS3? I bought a dual one off of ebay for my PC; would be nice if it worked on the PS3.

#2 — July 28, 2008 @ 03:49AM — Yo

do u know the ps2 controller adpater for ps2 does it work on the ps2 to ps3 adapter ?

#3 — July 28, 2008 @ 07:57AM — VinTheDean

Nice article, but I wanted to let you and your reader know that the you can change the battery on the PS3 controller. The instructions are in the owner's manual. [Edited]

#4 — July 28, 2008 @ 16:32PM — Frank [URL]

A nice useful article/review. Thanks.
How do the shoulder buttons perform though? The L1 and L2 'triggers' are used a lot in PS3 racing games for acceleration but they have a much smaller range of movement on PS2 controllers. I am a little worried you might have a lot less control over speed. Just out of interest, have you had a chance to test them?

#5 — July 31, 2008 @ 08:30AM — Mark Buckingham

@Vin, thanks for the tip. I caught the bit in the manual on how to replace the hard drive; must have missed the info on batteries. It's certainly not well publicized. They'd make more off selling another controller. :)

@ Frank, thanks for the compliment. Personally, I always loved simply using the right analog stick for gas/brake in racing games, and no modern games seem to embrace that, or even allow it in many cases. The range of motion in the L2 and R2 triggers is also a little bothersome for games like R6 Vegas, where it's mapped to throwing grenades and bringing up the map, things I'd rather just click to get. However, the PS2 controller buttons were all analog as well; they made a bunch of noise about this when the PS2 came out, then nobody used it for much. So the triggers are still pressure-sensitive, but obviously if you're well attuned to the amount of play you get in the PS3 triggers now, it won't feel the same, though you still have some range of control between just all or nothing with them being natively analog.

#6 — August 3, 2008 @ 21:47PM — NEO

I'm looking forward for this, i have a Hori Arcade Stick for the PS2, and now I just bought Soul Calibur IV for the PS3 and want to use my old Hori... i hope it works flawless...

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/79404)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments