Wie-ping on the Outside
Published July 19, 2008
Usually I like golf, but this really is rather absurd. She didn't get penalized for not signing her scorecard, for walking away and forgetting about it, but rather for walking too far before she realized it and returned. I personally think this is a ridiculous rule. I mean, if she just takes off, sure, but she found out she had made a mistake, came back to fix it, and did so before she played any more golf - heck, before she even left the general vicinity of the scorer's tent. I see no reason why that shouldn't be a forgivable error.
Then, to add insult to injury, they let her spend a whole day out on the course thinking that nothing is wrong, let her play her third consecutive great round and get into serious contention, and then tell her, "Oh, by the way, your score today doesn't count. Or the one from yesterday. Yeah." If that were me, I think I would definitely be tossing some f-bombs and "Why'd you wait to tell me"s.
This seems like one of those letter-vs-intent of the law situations. Sure, the rule is the rule, but if the infraction was so specific that it took you until the following afternoon to catch it, was it absolutely necessary to enforce it? Then you add insult to injury by waiting until the player posts another good score and gets into the final pairing to break the bad news? The only word I can think to describe it is 'unnecessary.'
So instead of spending her Sunday afternoon competing side-by-side against Yani Tseng for what might be her first ever LPGA title, she's forced to sit at home and watch the final round, all because of another one of golf's goofy rules.
- Wie-ping on the Outside
- Published: July 19, 2008
- Type: News
- Section: Sports
- Filed Under: Sports: Golf
- Writer: Geeves
- Geeves's BC Writer page
- Geeves's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Good summary Geeves. Letting her play the third round was heartless by the 'powers that be'. I wonder if Michelle Wie will come back next year to the SFC and prove everyone wrong? Lets hope so.





Maybe they were hoping that she'd blow up in the 3rd round, then it wouldn't seem like such a travesty to DQ her or maybe they knew the tournament would take a hit so they delayed her DQ as long as possible. Probably none of the above and just one of those s**t happens things. Another of those stupid rules that makes it hard to take take this game seriously.