Graphic Novel Review: All-Star Superman by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely
Published June 19, 2008
I still have images of Superman comic books stuck in my head from when I was growing up in the 1960s. They were fantastic, a mixture of superhero and science fiction, two of my greatest loves ever at that age. I loved the stories of Lex Luthor (in his traditional gray prison uniform) teaming up with Brainiac (in a pink shirt and shorty-shorts). One of the most prevalent of those images was of Superman shrunken down and trapped in a birdcage.
Ahh, those were the days. But as I grew older, Superman grew more serious and so did his problems. Sadly, so did I. I realized there were worse things for Superman - for anyone - than being trapped in a birdcage. However, I still loved those stories. They were part of my childhood, and I won't feel badly for hanging onto them.
Especially since Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely are revisiting Superman with the same love and tenderness I remember from those comic issues. Those plots were innocent and fun in a way that comics haven't been in a long time. Now, Morrison and Quitely are doing the same thing in the pages of All-Star Superman.
The series exists outside of the traditional Superman universe. From what I've seen of this first graphic novel, anything goes. Clark Kent is still something of a boob. Lois Lane is sharp and still doesn't have a clue that Clark is Superman (until he tells her). Jimmy Olsen is perky and sharp and a geek all at the same time. Luthor is violently opposed to Superman breathing the same air as him and is brilliantly carrying out multi-layered plans to bring that to an end.
And Superman is quietly heroic throughout it all.
The graphic novel gathers the first six issues of the series. Some of the stories function as stand-alone tales, but they all have continuity threads. And they're all just good fun. This is a Superman book I'm gleefully handing off to my ten-year-old because I know he's going to have a blast with it, too.
The first story shows Morrison's deviousness. Luthor has a plan to destroy Superman by overexposing him to the sun's rays. During the initial set-up of the story, Morrison quickly and quietly introduces his readers to the familiar cast of characters, letting everyone know just how he's going to spin the relationships and at what point in their lives we are. The sequence of Clark entering the newsroom on the double is a long montage that expertly showcases Quitely's artwork. I loved it.
The first issue leaves us hanging regarding Superman's fate after the overexposure to the sun. But the second issue is a fan's dream come true: Lois Lane is given super-powers for a day and becomes Superwoman, the way we all imagined she might back in the 1960s. Not only that, but Quitely draws her smoking hot! The two-page spread of the Fortress of Solitude is awesome.
- Graphic Novel Review: All-Star Superman by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely
- Published: June 19, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Action and Adventure, Books: Adventure, Books: Comics and Graphic Novels, Books: Fantasy, Books: SF, Books: Young Adult
- Writer: Mel Odom
- Mel Odom's BC Writer page
- Mel Odom's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us






Thanks for the recommendation! Helpful reviews as always.