Book Review: The Saint-Germain Memoirs by Chelsea Quinn Yarbro
Published May 10, 2008
"A Gentleman of the Old School," originally published in Dark Delicacies, is one of the very rare Saint-Germain tales set in the present-day. This story concentrates much more on its mortal characters, with Saint-Germain appearing as a wealthy man of mystery who feeds an eager female reporter some clues in a serial murder case. In her Afterword, Yarbro describes her writing process, explaining that her character "talks to her" and that "I'm one of those writers who has to have characters come alive before I can write about them...I immerse myself in the environment of the story, the history, the circumstances, and as much actual information we have regarding how people of the time saw themselves and their world." I completely sympathize, because I write the same way. But some years ago I had a conversation with Yarbro and asked her why she hadn't written a novel about Saint-Germain in the present day. She told me that for some reason, those stories just wouldn't easily gel for her. "A Gentleman of the Old School" has that in common with the other modern-day Saint-Germain stories: somehow, Yarbro's hero hasn't quite found a natural place in the post-Y2K world.
The novelette "Intercession" was originally published in Repentants. Presented in epistolary style, "Intercession" consists of letters written by Saint-Germain's manservant, Rogerio, in his efforts to free his master from incarceration in 17th century Spanish territory in the New World. Readers of the novels already know that Saint-Germain is imprisoned when his oldest friend, the vampire Olivia, dies in an explosion in Rome. This story includes that event.
However, I found "Intercession" to be the weakest of the five pieces in this collection. To me, it merely seemed repetitive: the years go by as Rogerio writes letter after letter seeking answers or aid. The point — that in such historical times even a wealthy person could be unjustly imprisoned indefinitely without hope of redress — is made long before the story ends. Including Olivia's death in that time frame without any mention of its effect on Saint-Germain leaves too large a gap. "Intercession" demands that the reader imagine how Saint-Germain must be feeling: helpless, cut off from all friendly communication and aware that Olivia is gone. This can be an effective device, but in "Intercession," it simply doesn't work for me.
- Book Review: The Saint-Germain Memoirs by Chelsea Quinn Yarbro
- Published: May 10, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Fantasy, Books: Horror, Books: Short Story
- Writer: Vyrdolak
- Vyrdolak's BC Writer page
- Vyrdolak's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us








