Xavier Nady, The Outfielder That Saved Pittsburgh
Published May 09, 2008
Roughly one full month and 30-plus games into the Major League Baseball season it is officially the time when "it's still early" as an explanation/excuse/retort to any variety of statements about individual players and collective teams is no longer applicable. If you need proof that this time has come, turn to any of the various ESPN media outlets and you will see the commentary confirming the death of this statement as a qualifier, leading off a plethora of different analysis, ranging from the struggles in Tiger Town to the continual dominance of Cliff Lee in Cleveland.
Yes, it is no longer "still early" on the baseball calendar. And while the rest of the long haul that is the Major League Baseball season will no doubt be heavily laden with streaks, turnarounds, and drama, the early season returns — with a full month of data to draw conclusions from — provide solid insights into the trends and emergences that will produce and composite the continual story lines that will populate the current season.
The most intriguing and underrated of these stories smolders out of the haze of black factory smog that hangs like a cloudy monument to industry, looming ominously over the iron city of Pittsburgh — a place whose rich baseball legacy is now so entrenched solely in the history books that many young generations barely know it ever existed. Wagner, Clemente, and Drabek are distant ghosts, diluted longingly in a modern lineage of losing that has become the status quo since Bonds and Bonilla took the money and ran.
Since being drafted in the second round of the 2000 Amateur Draft by the San Diego Padres, Xavier Nady's career has been defined by great potential, minimal results, and a persistent lack of opportunity. Although in 2000 Nady became only the 18th player since 1965 to ascend directly to the pros without any minor league experience, he only stayed there for one game, one at-bat, and not surprisingly one hit, before being exiled to the Single-A farm team for the rest of the season.
During the next two years, Nady never got another cup of coffee in the show, all the while posting titanic minor league numbers. In his first full minor league season, Xavier populated his trophy case with a good amount of hardware. For his work in 2001, Nady was bestowed with multiple honors including the Padres Minor League Player of the Year award, the California League MVP award, and also that league's Rookie of the Year award. For the season he batted .302/26/100; a strong indication that although Nady wasn't playing on the Major League level, he was immediately capable of demonstrating an uncommonly balanced ability to hit for both power and average — a trait coveted by teams when evaluating young talent.
- Xavier Nady, The Outfielder That Saved Pittsburgh
- Published: May 09, 2008
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Sports
- Filed Under: Sports: Baseball
- Writer: Anthony Tobis
- Anthony Tobis's BC Writer page
- Anthony Tobis's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Mclouth is definately on a tear but his story is far different. He was a 25th round draft pick who never hit over .258 before this season.
I'm not trying to prove that Nady is Ted Williams in this piece. He's simply a good story about a one time highly touted prospect, finally fully utilizing his skills to the benefit of a baseball starved town.
Mclouth is the sensationalist story, but if anyone is going to fall back to earth its him.
I'm not a Pirates fan, but from an objective standpoint, Nady is a patient hitter who walks, hits for power and average, and produces with men on base. This article only attempts to illustrate that these attributes have been shown in small doses over Nady's career, and are now fully manifesting, precluding the idea that this is meerly a random hot streak that will inevitably die off.
While the Pirates will most likely trade Nady to the Mets, this is only because they continually screw their fans by fielding garbage teams year after year, and expecting fans to pay to watch. The idea that contenders are clamoring for this guy says something in itself.







first of all, nate mcclouth is a much more interesting story than nady. second, his "finally" arriving this april has been MUCH more about a complete inability to stay healthy than about a lack of opportunity (he never got the latter BECAUSE of the former).
and whil i am a pirates fan, i am also a realist. his .806 OPS and 107 OPS+ are not "very good". they are, by definition, league average. a player who, at age 28, posted a career best OPS+ that was just above league average is NOT a player who is going to maintain a 170 RBI pace. his numbers last year were right in line with his career numbers, so even though i enjoy watching him play, he needs to be traded before he hits a slump that will bring him right back to the numbers he has always posted.