OPINION

Jesus Be Black, Yo

Written by Stephen Foster
Published May 07, 2008
page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

I'm not sure, but was he supposed to back away from what he said in an earlier sermon, the now infamous "God Damn America" talk? Did I miss something? Why back off—because it sounds unpatriotic? What, you can't be critical of your country, even at the deepest of levels, and be patriotic? We all love our children, but rebuke and sometimes punish them when they misbehave.

Would anyone disagree that we've perpetrated acts of terrorism (O.K., let's use "war" instead, if it makes us feel better—public vs. private truth again) against other countries? If we invade another country and if the result is death and mayhem and chaos and uncertainty and disorder (see: Iraq) wouldn't that be a kind of terrorism to the afflicted countrymen? They'd say so.

And of course, Iraq is not the only example. But here's the point: the United States has plenty of blood on its hands.

Why is it an outrage to admit the truth of that statement? Now, if we were right in all of our terrorist-like incursions, that didn't make them any less bloody, didn't make their victims and sufferers any less likely to hate us for it. And, obviously, we weren't always right. For better or worse, our actions overseas have caused hardship and misery to tens of thousands. Do we really believe that our actions will not have consequences in this country?

Regarding Wright's relationship with Louis Farrakhan, TOA's article says that, in his "meandering" response to a related question he tries to "parse" the difference between Zionism and Judaism. No he doesn't. And his response doesn't meander: "Where Louis said twenty years ago that Zionism, not Judaism, is a gutter religion, he was talking about the same thing United Nations resolutions say, the same thing now that President Carter is being vilified for, and Bishop Tutu is being vilified for, and everybody wants to paint me as if I am anti Semitic because of what Louis Farrakhan said twenty years ago." (To wit: Palestinians should have a homeland.)

Frankly the response is not as cogent as it might be, but there's no support here for Farrakhan or anti-Semitism. TOA says, "There are multiple layers of offense associated with this comment alone." Really? Where? At bottom, Zionism is not so much religion as political movement, and at its most fervent it is counter-Palestine. But I don't see the multiple layers of offense. I see an honest response to what another incendiary figure, Farrakhan, got tangled up in years ago. But what does that have to do with Wright today?

TOA presents the common fallacy: "To say that Zionism is a "gutter religion" is to say that Judaism itself is a gutter religion." Really? How so? I don't truly know how Farrakhan distinguished, if he did, between fundamentally a political movement and the religion it defends, but I'm not sure it's germane to anything.

Again, TOA on Farrakhan: "Wright goes on to say, 'Louis and I don't agree on everything...' but then described Farrakhan as "one of the most important voices in the 20th and 21st century, that's what I think about him."

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5
Stephen Foster (no relation to the composer) plays the violin and piano, but so what? He doesn't play them well. So he writes about music, has written extensively about rock, soul, jazz, and all things alt. He goes to sleep listening to Portishead every Tuesday and Thursday. He is working on a history of how the Cubists influenced the early Ramones. In his spare time he grapples with the metaphysics of the mandolin. He is the publisher and managing editor of www.culturecrank.com.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Jesus Be Black, Yo
Published: May 07, 2008
Type: Opinion
Section: Politics
Writer: Stephen Foster
Stephen Foster's BC Writer page
Stephen Foster's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Stephen Foster
All Politics Articles
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — May 7, 2008 @ 16:09PM — Ruvy

I read this article in its entirety, Stephen.

First of all, if you view G-d as merely a man, however superior His powers might be, you've bought into the Greek worship of idols. The title of your article and your assumptions within it detail clearly one reason why Christianity is abhorrent to most Jews.

G-d is not a mere man to be assigned a skin color. The Creator of the universe is beyond the imagination of all men, and for a mere man to look directly into the face of G-d is to invite death. The appropriate term in English is ineffable. If you don't know what it means, find an unabridged dictionary (preferably a ten kilo tome you have to work to lift) and look it up.

Second of all, while most of your article deals with the experience of black Americans, something I can comment on only minimally, the last page deals with Zionism and Judaism. As a Jew living in liberated Samaria, I know quite a bit about both.

I suggest that fools like Louis Farrakhan and Jeremiah Wright know nothing about either Judaism or Zionism.

Judaism is a nationality and a religion, based on three Covenants with G-d.

1. The descendants of Abraham through his son Isaac and grandson Jacob are granted the right to live in the Land of Israel in perpetuity, to worship there and carry out the commandments of G-d there.

2. The Children of Israel are granted a Torah, a guide to holiness, that they are to follow and guard scrupulously; this Torah is our guide to being holy in a holy Land, and we are charged with being as holy as the Land we are granted.

3. The Children of Israel, chosen to guard this guide have the task of teaching mankind (when it is ready to be taught) the Seven Laws of Noah, universal laws of civilization.

In ancient days, our people were governed by a Sanhedrin, a court of 71 judges, an institution that was established in the days of wandering the desert before the conquest of the Land under yehoshu'a (Joshua) ben nun.

A little under two thousand years ago, the last sovereign Jewish entity in this country (until the present State) was destroyed by the Roman savages after a rebellion against pagan rule. The city of Jerusalem was burned to the ground, along with the Temple of hordos (Herod), thousands died, thousands more were taken as slaves and a six hundred year genocide was started against the Jewish people in this Land.

The remnant of the Sanhedrin snuck out to the city of Yavne to try and figure out what to do to save our people.

The only weapons they had were words.

So they constructed a liturgy of prayer to remind every Jew of what had been lost to the Roman savages in tens of generations of exile that were to come.

Central to this liturgy is the 'amidá, a standing prayer recited silently three times daily.

From its text:

Let the great trumpet of liberation be sounded, let the banner be raised for the gathering of our exiles, and bring us together from the four corners of the earth. Blessčd are You the Eternal, Who collects together the outcasts of His people, Israel.
......
And Jerusalem, Your city, in mercy return and dwell therein as You have said. Rebuild her speedily, in our days, and the throne of David repair within her. Blessčd are You the Eternal, Who builds Jerusalem.


There is more, of course, a great deal more, all recited standing at attention, but the point is to remind every Jew, every Child of Israel who recites the 'amidá who he or she really is and where his or her ultimate loyalty must lie.

The difference between a believing Jew and a non-believing Jew is how seriously he takes what he says to G-d three times daily; and what he does to make those prayers a reality.

It is from this 'amidá that Zionism gets its concepts. But Zionism is a mere movement of secular Jews to establish a state. Having established that State, Zionism accomplished its purpose, and as events have shown over the last twenty years, has lost its way. Zionism, as a movement, is basically over.

The next step in the evolution of the Jewish nation is to turn this country into a truly G-d centered country, instead of the pathetic imitation of the pagan west it is now.

Neither Louis Farrakhan nor Jeremiah Wright have any understanding of this: most American Jews like the "Obnoxious American" (who is not obnoxious at all) don't understand this either.

But pay attention to what I write. Your elections are pretty much your affair, but at least you now have a real concept of who and what the Children of Israel are.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/76489)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments