Music Review: Mudcrutch
Published May 05, 2008
Mudcrutch is by no means a radical departure from The Heartbreakers, and that's a good thing. The qualities that make them such a timeless, uniquely American band are still prominent here. What makes Mudcrutch such a welcome diversion is the way they incorporate a few new influences and brilliantly blend them into the fabric of what has always been there. The Heartbreakers have perfected the art of making Byrds-influenced Southern rock records, a style that is uniquely American and timeless. The band still draws on '60s music, but Mudcrutch has found a secret weapon in the hands of the amazing Benmont Tench. He plays less piano and more organ for Mudcrutch, and does so in a way that turns this into a psychedelic Southern rock record. It's still uniquely American, but this has a very retro feel. The nine-minute epic "Crystal River" is a perfect example, as is the "I Won't Back Down" sequel "Scare Easy." Even "The Wrong Thing To Do," a song that borrows a tad from "Mary Jane's Last Dance," has that vibe. Those two songs represent two of the strongest moments on the album.
Where Heartbreaker records were obviously inspired by The Byrds, Mudcrutch reaches further back than just the '60s. "Six Days On The Road," "Shady Grove," and "This is a Good Street" have a great strut to them, reminiscent of the work of Carl Perkins, Elvis Presley, and Buddy Holly. Petty has been hosting a show on XM Radio called Tom Petty's Buried Treasure, filled with gems from America's musical past — Chicago blues, cowboy songs, and hippie music. Now rather than just admiring those styles, he's infusing his songs with elements of them and the result is music that is livelier and more invigorated than anything he's done in quite some time. That's not a knock on a record like Highway Companion — which is a fine record filled with great songwriting — but is high praise for a project that has a vibe of relaxed fun.
Petty and his collaborators aren't getting any younger but it wouldn't be such a bad thing for him to have one more outlet, especially one this good. Mudcrutch isn't likely to resurface, but I won't be sorry if they do. If this is the final hurrah for the band that almost was, let's hope they capture one of the handful of shows they did on their short California tour. The Heartbreakers have yet to release a truly powerful live album. It would be fitting if Mudcrutch beat them to the punch. It would be a small victory, but a fitting one.
- Music Review: Mudcrutch
- Published: May 05, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Roots Rock, Music: Rock, Music: Country and Americana
- Writer: Josh Hathaway
- Josh Hathaway's BC Writer page
- Josh Hathaway's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanks, JC. It's an excellent record and I think you're right about holding this up in a couple of years. I'd like some of what they did here to follow them back to The Heartbreakers' next record.
After listening to the album, I am now kicking myself for not trying harder to see them at the Troubadour. I did find some bootlegs, so that will have to suffice for now.
Thanks, Bicho. I hope and pray there is a live CD/DVD package out of that string of dates they played.


Josh Hathaway is 


Excellent review. It'll be interesting to re-read it in a year's time, maybe two, and see where Mudcrutch fits into Tom Petty's canon of work.
Hi to all on Mudcrutch Farm! Rock hard and rock well!