REVIEW

Book Review: Kingdom Come by J.G. Ballard

Written by Philip Spires
Published April 26, 2008

Kingdom Come by J.G. Ballard is not a successful book. Richard Brown is an advertising executive who has been estranged from his father for some time. Whilst the son has been in sophisticated London, the father has lived in Brooklands, a commuter town whose occupants, though bored to the core, know what they like. Above all, they like consumerism and, because of that, they like their Metro-Centre, a vast shopping mall that people actually worship. They also despise the stuck up sophisticates who live in London. And so Ballard begins by constructing a model of contemporary British society, whose addiction to mass market products now borders on denying any alternative a right to exist, especially anything with intellectual content.

But there has been a problem. An apparently random shooting in the Metro-Centre has left Richard Pearson’s father dead. Richard has thus arrived from the nearby metropolis that might as well be a different planet, to find out what has happened. He finds a town divided, where gangs of sports fans wear St. George cross shirts and divide their time between drinking, shopping and beating up members of ethnic minorities. They like contact sports.

What ensues is a riot, of sorts, a political revolt, of sorts, and a conspiracy, of sorts. What Ballard appears to be trying to do is make comments on the nature of consumer Britain, its lack of values, its non-entity identity, its apparent praise of brainlessness, its resentment of anything that is non-mass market, its latent, incipient fascism. But the book fails.

The characterisation is weak throughout. The only person to make an impression is David Cruise, a presenter who fronts the Metro-Centre television channel, who becomes something of a fascist leader, midway between Big Brother and a Sky newsreader. But even his character is tame where it could be surreal, lapdog where it might be threatening. Coincidence upon coincidence casts Richard Pearson as his former adman, a status that gets Richard into the inside, a position he hopes will reveal who killed his father.

But the book’s most serious weakness, apart from an empty and thoroughly confused plot, is its complete lack of a character inside the mob. The reader is constantly reminded of the hordes of sports fans who riot and fight in defence of their beloved retail park, but we never meet one. We do have an analyst who describes their collective destruction obsession as elective psychopathy. We have Asian neighbours who get set alight, but we never really get inside the mobs, never understand their motives. Perhaps they don’t have a motive. Perhaps that’s the point, but, if it is, it fails to register.

And so the occupation of the shopping mall continues. We have riots, hostages, killings, shootings, attacks. We have mass hysteria, boredom, rampant consumerism and ice hockey. But in the end the experience is as vacuous as the Metro-Centre’s dome. The police officers, the headmaster, the Metro-Centre administrators — in fact everyone in the book, even Julia the doctor who seems occasionally to do something human — they all reveal themselves as duplicitous, confused, scheming, disloyal and, worst of all, flat. Meanwhile the mob just continues its collective anonymity. A charitable review might suggest that this was Kingdom Come's point, but it would be taking charity too far.

I was a child in Sharlston, then a mining village, and then Crofton, near Wakefield, UK. I went to London University and then did two years as a VSO in Kenya. I then taught in London for 16 years before moving to Brunei technical education. I then worked in Zayed University in the UAE for three years. Since 2003, I have lived in Spain, and have completed a PhD in education’s role in Philippine development and two novels, Mission and A Fool's Knot.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Kingdom Come Kingdom Come
James Graham Ballard
Book,

Book Review: Kingdom Come by J.G. Ballard
Published: April 26, 2008
Type: Review
Section: Books
Filed Under: Books: SF
Writer: Philip Spires
Philip Spires's BC Writer page
Philip Spires's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Philip Spires
Books: SF
All Books Articles
Philip Spires's personal weblog
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — April 26, 2008 @ 16:58PM — Kevin Eagan [URL]

You've written a very thorough review here, and I totally see your point...but it seems to go against a lot of what I've read about this book. Granted, I haven't yet read "Kingdom Come," but I'm familiar with Ballard's previous work. The way you describe this novel seems to suggest that this is a true "ballardian" book, with elements of dystopia, contrasting and elusive morals, and ambivalent characters. So, are you critiquing Ballard as a writer (obviously he's an acquired taste) or are you critiquing this novel because it doesn't hold up to his previous works?

Or, are all of the good reviews I've read about this book a symptom of book critics who become enamored with certain writers and start to think he/she can do no harm? Because that happens as well.

Anyway, just some thoughts.

#2 — April 27, 2008 @ 01:50AM — Philip Spires [URL]

Hi Kevin

Just a quick note to confirm that this review is about this book only, not the author. I have read other works by J G Ballard and agree that he is an acquired taste, but one that is worth acquiring. Kingdom Come is a good idea, but one that doesn't work.

#3 — April 28, 2008 @ 16:16PM — Kevin Eagan [URL]

You know, I think that professional critics often give established writers more of a pass on average or bad work, especially if that writer already has an "establishment" reputation for writing good literature. It's kind of like when a new writer's first novel is far better than an established writer's last book, yet the established writer will get a better review.

Maybe that's what has happened here. I'd like to read the novel anyway and see for myself.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/76226)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments